2 ms·
Well, yeah. Those sessions are aimed at their colleagues, who know 99.9% of the subject and only need to be taught about the .1% that is novel. Such presentatio
by jfengel 5y ago
Well, yeah. Those sessions are aimed at their colleagues, who know 99.9% of the subject and only need to be taught about the .1% that is novel. Such presentations are for people at the very limits of the field, learning the things that push the boundaries. It's not a tutorial aimed at bringing newcomers on board -- even if that "newcomer" is in a slightly related field.
They'd be just as lost in a presentation by a PhD in your field explaining their work.
That's before you get to the fact that most such presentations aren't very good. Presentations are yet another skill unto themselves, and few PhDs have actually mastered it. I think of them as more like infomercials. If you actually want to get on board with the material, you'll go read the paper or talk with the people. Or better, both.
There's a famous cartoon putting this into perspective:
https://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ https://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/
It's just the fact that there's so much to know that any one person only has the ability to know a tiny, tiny slice of it. Anything else looks alien. You could figure it out with time put into it. But you have to allocate your time, in whatever way seems best.
It's not a bad idea for you to put some of your own time into making good presentations. It's a tricky skill to learn, since it's subjective, but at core it's about empathy -- imaging how the world looks from somebody else's perspective. That's a good talent to have, no matter your field.
- ducktective 5y agoThanks