4 ms·
>Maybe this is all more difficult than I think. I think you basically get it. It all comes down to property rights vs public good. Take the extreme case of som
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
>Maybe this is all more difficult than I think.
I think you basically get it. It all comes down to property rights vs public good. Take the extreme case of someone with a vacant lot in downtown Manhattan.
On one hand, the development could help the city and improve general prosperity. On the other hand, someone owns it and is free to use it (or not) as they see fit.
My understanding is that the current state of eminent domain is that public good is necessary, but not sufficient to justify the forced sale of the land. The city can not take it because someone else could develop it for the public good. The city could take it in very narrow cases, like if they wanted to put in a metro station and there were no viable alternatives.
Whether this is a feature or a bug is really a matter of perspective. Is the goal of the government and law to optimize for the greater good, or protect individuals against the greater good as long as they aren't harming anyone (and opportunity costs don't count!). I tend to land on the latter side, but get that others don't feel the same way.