6 ms·
Why was the McDonald's one not frivolous? Was it just because it was 185 degrees? Edit: Why are people disagreeing with this? It's literally 2 questions and it
by giantg2 5y ago
Why was the McDonald's one not frivolous? Was it just because it was 185 degrees?
Edit: Why are people disagreeing with this? It's literally 2 questions and it seems the temperature was the issue when looking at culpability.
Edit 2: someone here provided the additional type of information that I was interested in. It wasn't just the temperature, but also that the cup had a design flaw that made it likely to collapse if you took the lid off. Thanks!
- watwut 5y agoBecause a lot of effort went into trying to convince people that this particular result was correct rather then failure.
- vkou 5y agoThe coffee was much hotter than the industry standard. McDonalds already had multiple successful suits against them about this very thing. The lady in question got incredibly serious burns on her legs. She originally sued only for medical expenses, and McDonalds wasn't interested in settling. The award was later reduced. If the answer to bad corporate behaviour is not regulation, but rather lawsuits, then that lawsuit perfectly encapsulated the series of legal escalations necessary to deal with a bad corporate actor, that has been alerted of a problem in their product, and refuses to resolve it.
- giantg2 5y ago"McDonalds already had multiple successful suits against them about this very thing." Ok, then I want to hear the reasoning behind those rulings/awards. "The lady in question got incredibly serious burns on her legs." That's an outcome/result. That has no real bearing on the culpability. "She originally sued only for medical expenses, and McDonalds wasn't interested in settling." Again, nothing speaking to culpability here. "The coffee was much hotter than the industry standard." Ok, so this is basically what my comment said. It seems 185 is about 20 degrees higher than other restaurants. It also has a warning on it (jury said it's not big enough, but maybe we should have everyone sign waivers first?). "legal escalations necessary to deal with a bad corporate actor" Depends on your viewpoint as to who is "bad". Edit: why disagree with this?
- CharlesW 5y agoGosh, if only you were there to defend that poor multinational corporation 20 years ago!
- giantg2 5y agoI'm not sure what you mean. All I wanted to know was the reasoning behind the culpability. Saying "other successful suites" is like saying "because it always worked that way". It doesn't show the reasoning. The part about bad corporate actors was not specific to the McDonalds example. I was merely saying that we could label any company as bad. For example, some might say abortion clinics are bad, while others might say gun makers are bad.
- res0nat0r 5y agoWatch this movie as it explains everything, it wasn't a frivolous lawsuit like it was always portrayed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bBKRjxeQnT4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bBKRjxeQnT4
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- colpabar 5y agoI think people are just somewhat annoyed because your comments seem argumentative. This is a very famous case and there is tons of material online to read, including the court documents themselves! I have also heard from friends who went to law school that this is used as an example of a case that isn't a frivolous lawsuit despite appearances. It just seems like you are very set in your views and are demanding that we all argue with you, and if that's the case, make a new post about the mcdonald's case because this thread isn't even about that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Random_BSD_Geek 5y agoGenuinely not sure if you're trolling or not, but.... > Ok, then I want to hear the reasoning behind those rulings/awards. ... > Edit: why disagree with this? You're asking internet randos to explain something to you that is an easily researched matter of public record. I too used to think the McDonald's coffee case was a punchline for an overly litigious America. Then I read the horrifying details.
- ender341341 5y agoBecause they had multiple warnings that the near boiling coffee was likely to cause severe burns but didn't heed them cause it meant less refills from people dining in. From the wiki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald%27s_Restaurants#Burn_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald%27s_Restau... > she had suffered third-degree burns on six percent of her skin and lesser burns over sixteen percent.[14] She remained in the hospital for eight days while she underwent skin grafting. During this period, Liebeck lost 20 pounds (9.1 kg) (nearly 20 percent of her body weight), reducing her to 83 pounds (38 kg). After the hospital stay, Liebeck needed care for three weeks, which was provided by her daughter.[15] Liebeck suffered permanent disfigurement after the incident and was partially disabled for two years. I'd highly recommend looking up details of the case if you think it was frivolous.
- giantg2 5y agoFirst, I never said it was frivolous. I asked a question. It seems the temperature of the coffee is the reason. The other stuff you mentioned are outcomes and don't necessarily speak to the culpability portion that I was questioning.
- s5300 5y agoProbably not the best tl:dr, but - It quite literally burnt/melted part of her vagina onto her leg/part of body that was not her vagina. I think pictures are out there if you google for them, it’s been quite a while but IIRC pretty gruesome.
- willis936 5y agoAsking "Is this not so?" and then saying you were not implying it is a betrayal of the cooperative principle, in the most generous of interpretations.
- giantg2 5y agoI guess that wording does evoke a negative reaction that I didn't mean to imply.
- mcculley 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald's_Restaurants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald's_Restaura... "She was hospitalized for eight days while undergoing skin grafting, followed by two years of medical treatment."
- giantg2 5y agoJust because someone is injured doesn't say anything about culpability. The culpability part is what was being questioned, not her injuries.
- mcculley 5y ago"Other documents obtained from McDonald's showed that from 1982 to 1992 the company had received more than 700 reports of people burned by McDonald's coffee to varying degrees of severity, and had settled claims arising from scalding injuries for more than $500,000." We know why coffee vendors make the coffee so hot. It expresses more caffeine. It is very simple. They decided that the value in keeping consumers addicted was worth the risk.
- derekp7 5y agoThe culpability is two parts. First part is serving a beverage that was much hotter than what an average consumer would expect, without a warning such as "this product will cause third degree burns within 3 seconds of touching your skin". But the biggest issue that I don't see mentioned most times this case is brought up is that the coffee cups at that time were defective by design. They relied on the lid for structural integrity. When you grasped the cup and squeeze it hard enough to keep it from falling, then if the lid pops off the cup collapses and the cup falls, spilling scalding liquid on you. Notice that the current cups don't crush as easily even without a lid on, they still hold their structure when squeezing it hard enough to pick it up. Also, the old cups would cause discomfort when holding them, which indicates that the liquid lost a lot of its thermal energy to the environment in a short amount of time. Due to that, customers that had to transport their coffee for some distance before wanting to drink it would want it to be served hotter than normal. Then it would be the perfect temperature when they get to their classroom / office. The newer cups have much better insulation properties, so this is less necessary.
- geoduck14 5y agoYou don't deserve downvotes. It is a legitimate question from someone who doesn't understand
- jshier 5y agofused labia
- Sohcahtoa82 5y agoYou just named my next rock band
- gambiting 5y agoI found that even trying to discuss this case like reasonable human beings immediately attracts downvotes, be it here or on Reddit - it's like "how dare you even question this! Of course McDonald's was in the wrong and even asking 'why' is a violation of some kind" Edit: case in point - this comment is currently in negative and I literally have no idea why, I've been commenting on this site for almost 10 years and this is one topic that is always guaranteed to attract downvotes no matter the context.
- blowski 5y agoI don’t think the OP is discussing in good faith. They’re projecting a rather tangential opinion disguised as an innocent question. Their opinion is then being undermined by facts, thus they are being downvoted, and complaining about the downvotes. There’s a lot of behaviour there that goes against the guidelines of most forums.
- paulmd 5y agoThis tactic is called "sealioning", named after this comic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning http://wondermark.com/1k62/ http://wondermark.com/1k62/ HN's rules around faux-politeness make it extremely susceptible to this kind of attack: not everyone is actually acting in good-faith and it makes discussions extremely tedious dealing with sealions who exploit that to drag the discussions of interest to a halt while the bad-faith user demands that we engage in a lengthy discussion of basic underlying points to keep from engaging the actual topic of discussion. Oh, but if you say it then you're the bad guy, because we have this rule! Again, why are we re-litigating a discussion about mcdonald's coffee on a topic about workplace harassment? Literally the only connection is they're both lawsuits. There's been a ton of words written about something that is entirely off-topic, because of this sealioning from the parent. That is textbook, open-and-shut, exactly what this tactic is designed to do.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> HN's rules around faux-politeness make it extremely susceptible to this kind of attack Not if people downvote rather than responding to nonproductive contributions. The problem isn't the rules around good faith when responding, the problem is people feeling obliged to respond.
- stirfish 5y agoHave you seen the photos of the injury?
- brimble 5y ago> Edit: Why are people disagreeing with this? It's literally 2 questions and it seems the temperature was the issue when looking at culpability. Downthread? Because you're being obtuse and, when people answer, asking a bunch more questions that you could easily google the answers to. It's not coming off as a good-faith discussion.
- freedomben 5y agoAs someone slightly on the spectrum, I regularly get accused of being "obtuse" when I'm asking honest questions to make sense of something. Of course some people really do intentionally be difficult, but OP's question was not near enough info to conclude that, and his additional responses were after he got slammed with downvotes (which usually bother people)
- brimble 5y ago> Why was the McDonald's one not frivolous? Was it just because it was 185 degrees? The questions read as slanted. This is a warning sign that you're dealing with someone who's already made up their mind and is just looking to argue. That "just" especially is... a red flag. That on its own might not mean much, but then, there's this entire post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31042870 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31042870 Which looks like a continuation of exactly that kind of thing. Asking questions in a one-sided way, demanding others do things for you even when they already pointed you in the right direction, hostile tone, et c. Even if done innocently, this style of posting can't be tolerated because it's a beloved trolling/shitposting tactic.
- giantg2 5y agoI think there was a communication issue. My post could have been worded better. I was specifically interested in the culpability portion. To my knowledge at that time it was simply about the temperature of the coffee. People were bringing up the injury portion. I wasn't questioning that part. Someone else on here brought up that the design of the cup was defective. That was the type of information I was looking for. Even some Google searching was not bringing up that for me, probably because like this thread, most people are focused on just the injury and the temperature. The cup issue really added to my understanding of the case, and answered my question about why it was not a frivolous case.
- freedomben 5y agoPurely anecdotal and worth nothing as evidence, but I remember how hot that damn coffee was. It was insane. We would literally take the lid off and hold it in front of an A/C vent to try and cool it off and it still took 20 mins before you could drink it. It burned the hell out of our hands lol. But, it was good coffee once it cooled down.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoYou need to read about what happened to that lady. She got 3rd degree burns. That is not "185" degrees. It was concluded that the coffee had to be right near boiling when it was poured on her. It was not frivolous at all. It is an easy google search away. I don't know why anyone would wait possibly hours for a response on HN on something like that?
- bsder 5y agoHere were relevant things: The coffee was turbo-hot--far in excess of standards that exist. McDonald's had been warned about this before. The design of the cup had it's own issues. The woman's initial lawsuit was for perfectly reasonable medical expenses given the horrible nature of the injuries. And, in response, McDonald's went completely nuclear. So, when McDonald's lost, THAT'S why they got hammered. And, even then, the award amount later got reduced, but nobody remembers that.