3 ms·
Is it deeply wrong that you can go on stock market and buy part of company and immediately turn up profit when they pay dividends. Essentially inserting yoursel
by Ekaros 5y ago
Is it deeply wrong that you can go on stock market and buy part of company and immediately turn up profit when they pay dividends. Essentially inserting yourself as parasitic middleman in the process, providing no service and extracting an economic rent... Or doing same by buying existing debt?
- basch 5y agoThe dividend payout is priced into the purchase price.
- andrepd 5y agoYes. I'm actually also against tradeable joint-stock corporations, admittedly a quite radical position, but one I share with people such as Adam Smith ;)
- bombcar 5y agoThe clarification in my mind is the assumption of risk. When you buy a stock that pays dividends, you're also taking on the risk that the stock goes down in value, that the company Enrons, that Musk decides he wants it, etc. A landlord has a similar risk associated with the property, and not just in loss of value but other real risks, such as lawsuits, etc. The stockholder is protected from many risks and can't lose more than his investment (ignoring cases where he owns so much of the company that the corporate veil can be pierced) - but a landlord easily can - especially with a mortgage, but even without. Insurance can be purchased to mitigate some of those risks, but few do beyond what a bank may require. Let's take the example of landlords of property in areas threatened by climate change; real risks exist there that the renter doesn't have to worry about beyond considering moving.