4 ms·
> Nature creates superfluous number of males A rather astounding statement. Selective pressure should result a ratio appropriate for a given species of plant
by gumby 5y ago
> Nature creates superfluous number of males
A rather astounding statement. Selective pressure should result a ratio appropriate for a given species of plant or animal. It’s not my field, but I haven’t seen any literature suggesting any such thing, nor do I know of any country full of sultans.
- autosharp 5y agoE.g. most chickens (about 2/3) that come out of their egg are male. But a flock only allows maybe 1 adult male for every 5 females, with the surplus murdered by other chickens. So almost all male chickens are superfluous in that sense. It is still selective pressure which makes chickens have 'too many' males, because apparently those chickens/flocks have created more of themselves. Same for lions, btw, although I don't know about their sex' birthrates.
- rybosworld 5y agoBirth sex ratio of chickens is naturally 1:1. You can do weird things with temperature to affect those birth rates, but the ratio will not reach as high as 2:1 as far as I know.
- gumby 5y ago> Same for lions, btw, although I don't know about their sex' birthrates. If you don't know the rate how can you say it's true? By definition there is some sort of distribution of male/female cubs and there is presumably some sort of distribution of pack sizes. But apart from the victorian-inspired documentaries that talk about juvenile male ronins being chased from the pack I don't really know the dynamics, and I doubt anyone but a specialized community does. Where I live in Palo Alto the distribution of lone mountain lions that show up in town seems, anecdotally, to be predominantly female. Humans are a good example: slightly more males are born but within the range of about 20-50 years of age, the sex ratio is 1:1. Humans have been basically* monogamous throughout recorded history and for whatever reasons that might be it would select for this birth ratio wouldn't it. * Sure, there are plenty (well, a few percent) of kids whose father is not the male in a given hetero "couple" but it's the couple phenomenon itself that matters here.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- astine 5y ago> > Nature creates superfluous number of males > A rather astounding statement. Selective pressure should result a ratio appropriate for a given species of plant or animal. It’s not my field, but I haven’t seen any literature suggesting any such thing, nor do I know of any country full of sultans. This is not actually true. The math works out that there is usually an even ratio between males and females, and that this is even the case in tournament species (where one male is able to mate with multiple females.) The thing to understand is that in this hypothetical, it wouldn't be a country full of sultans, but a country full of would-be sultans. A very different proposition. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisher%27s_principle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisher%27s_principle
- gumby 5y agoInteresting. Technically it doesn’t contradict my statement, as 1:1 must be some sort of Panglossian survival ratio :-). But of course you twigged that that wasn’t what I was thinking at all at all, which is what makes your comment so interesting. But it takes a lot of effort to make offspring, so none of them would be of a “surplus” sex. I must say that I’m surprised that the 1:1 ratio survives in schooling or herding species in which a large proportion perish. I suppose it’s insurance against an unfortunate loss of all males. There’s probably an interesting maths PhD in there someplace.
- upsidesinclude 5y agoSuperfluous is roughly synonymous with 'unnecessary' and that seems to be the confusion here. Extra males are unnecessary. They exist, but could easily not exist and that wouldn't present major issues for the species
- dsq 5y agoYes, thank you. I was sloppy with my phrasing. The idea is that it takes only a small number of males to procreate the next generation, so the rest of the males are a kind of surplus that can be diverted, to fighting for example.
- dsq 5y agoI was careless in my phrasing. What I should have said was that only a fraction of the males in a generation are necessary for fathering the next generation, and that all the other males can be diverted to other tasks or simply left to fend for themselves.