4 ms·
If that were the case, why would someone else not bid $1 more to buy that house and rent it out? Then someone else would logically be willing to bid $1 more tha
by sokoloff 5y ago
If that were the case, why would someone else not bid $1 more to buy that house and rent it out? Then someone else would logically be willing to bid $1 more than that, until there was no easy profit left…
I think the answer is that much of the landlord’s initial profit is more or less income from working a job (buying, insuring, readying, showing, screening, fixing, collecting, etc) as evidenced by the share that a property management company takes if you don’t want to do all that work. That share is often enough to push a small positive cashflow into a moderately negative cash flow, meaning it’s the job aspect not the passive ownership aspect that’s profitable initially.
I laugh everytime someone calls being a landlord “passive income”. I’m not one because I saw the aggravation and effort my parents went through with a series of crappy tenants.
No one calls the pizza shop owner a “parasitic middleman between inexpensive ingredients and $15 cheese pizzas”. Because they can see that it’s work; they imagine being a landlord isn’t.
- andrepd 5y ago> If that were the case, why has someone else not bid $1 more to buy that house and rent it out? Because capital is privatised and scarce, therefore a working-class family wishing to buy a home to live on cannot do so since they're outbid by those with capital. This leaves them with two choices: (1) pay rent to a middleman with capital, who buys the house, or (2) beg a private entity for a capital advance to be repaid with future expected cash flows, i.e. a bank loan. The fundamental issue was always there, but for a time the house prices where well within what working/middle-class people could afford. Now that capital, incl. behemoth investment funds, have pushed these prices well outside what most people can reasonably afford, it becomes much more visible. It's kinda silly that your take is "well why don't working-class people just bid $1 above Blackrock"?
- sokoloff 5y agoThe question is “if Blackrock can buy and turn an immediate profit, why didn’t MAA, Starwood, AvalonBay, or one of 100 others not bid it up from the easy-money, too-cheap level?”
- noahtallen 5y agoFrom experience in Portland and Seattle, large management companies are purchasing as many properties as they possibly can.
- sokoloff 5y agoIndeed. That’s what makes the bids high enough to leave limited immediate cash flow.
- andrepd 5y agoThey do, hence the unsustainable bubble affecting property prices all over the world.
- trgn 5y ago> a working-class family wishing to buy a home to live What people picture is owning houses. Landtax will not meaningfully make that more affordable. It will make holding on to land more expensive, therefore really putting pressure to extract the most value from it. Homes really aren't doing that. That will mean more capital improvements; more units on smaller lots, more apartments, ... It will curb speculation, lower rents in the aggregate, but ownership of land will remain expensive, especially for poorly improved land like family homes.
- gruez 5y ago>I think the answer is that much of the landlord’s initial profit is more or less income from working a job [...] It can simultaneously be true that being a landlord is a bunch of work, and that is being parasitic middleman. That's because being a landlord is composed of two parts: providing access to the land, and building/maintaining a shelter that sits on top of the land. People generally aren't upset with the latter, but are with the former. Lars Doucet explains it more in depth: >[...] don't landlords deserve compensation for their work? What about Ms. Nguyen, the nice lady who manages your apartment block and went the extra mile for you when your A/C went out last summer? >I like Ms. Nguyen too, but let's contrast her with Mr. Slumlord, who owns the apartment block next door that's superficially identical, but who won't help you when your A/C goes out in the middle of summer. >Ms. Nguyen charges higher "rent" for her much better maintained units because part of that "rent" is actually her justly compensated wages for her labor in managing them, as well as interest from returns on the capital she's invested in their ongoing improvement and maintenance. She also collects a good bit of true Georgian rent because she is, after all, a landlord. >Mr. Slumlord puts in as little work as he can get away with and invests as little capital into maintenance as will keep the state off his back. His return is almost entirely rent. And the only reason he can charge rent in the first place is because of the valuable location – value the community produced, not him. >And that's the real injustice of land rent – the community produces the value, but the landlord charges rent to access it. https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/your-book-review-progress-and-poverty https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/your-book-review-progr...
- andrepd 5y agoThanks, that is precisely the distinction I was trying to convey, but put in much better words :)