3 ms·
Anyone who has been a landlord can attest "providing no service" isn't true at all.
by refurb 5y ago
Anyone who has been a landlord can attest "providing no service" isn't true at all.
- rapind 5y agoSubjective. When I used to rent, I never saw my landlord after signing the lease. I was renting a house and taking care of small maintenance issues myself. I'd say it was far less effort to rent to me, then it would have been to live there himself. Of course there are bad tenants, but I suspect, like most things, we focus on those negatives and ignore all the low maintenance tenants when thinking about it.
- boredumb 5y agoa new roof is over 20,000$ a new floor in a modest home is over 10,000$ a burst pipe will be over 1,000$ interest payments are thousands a year property taxes are thousands of dollars a year all are guarantees even with the lowest maintenance tenants.
- rapind 5y agoAgreed. Home maintenance, property tax, mortgage interest, is a cost of owning regardless of whether you are renting or living in it. So that needs to always be part of your calculation, and I would hope most landlords are considering that. I was just hypothesizing that the "Bad Tenant tax" is potentially overblown. Sure it can be an absolute nightmare if you're unlucky (or bad at screening), but on average I suspect it's pretty minor. I honestly don't have anything but anecdotal data to back that up though. I just suspect, like a lot of things where exceptional horror stories are propagated, we could be over-weighting the negatives.
- bombcar 5y agoThe problem with small landlords is they can't average bad tenants over a large number of units. They have one or two units, and even one just sitting empty for a few months destroys years of cash flow. Let alone actually getting a bad tenant. It may be a low chance, but if it comes up, you can be hosed out of the entire value of the house (usually you can still sell the land, but in the absolute worst cases where the property was turned into a meth factory, you may be out more than the entire value).
- IgorPartola 5y agoThis. 1. Immediately turn a profit would mean that monthly rent is higher than the cost of the property. This is not a thing. If they person you are replying to means “cash flow positive” then sure in 20-30 years the renter will have paid off the property for the landlord. 2. Renting provides choices. Tenant wants to move across the country or across the street? No problem: ride out your lease and move when ready. If you own the property you need to sell it to move in most cases. Ever try to sell when the market changed and suddenly your property lost 30% in value and you are suddenly underwater? I have. On the other hand if you are renting you can just move on a relatively short timeframe and get the fuck out of dodge no matter where property values are. 3. The responsibility for maintaining the building is on the landlord. Sure, some are bad at this but know your rights and interview your landlords well and it won’t be a problem. 4. Rentals provide inventory. If you don’t have $500,000 saved up for a large single family home in an expensive state (like where I have been stuck for the past decade), what do you do for housing? Mortgage your life away and hope jobs and markets go your way? Or rent for a small premium over a mortgage payment with no money down and a 12 month commitment? For most people renting is actually a much better choice provided they save the difference between renting and owning the home and invest it wisely. Over a lifetime there are few places in the US where you’d be better off buying instead. NYT had a nice comprehensive calculator to this effect.
- bombcar 5y agoMost landlords aren't even cash flow positive if you correctly account for everything - http://www.johntreed.net/positive.html http://www.johntreed.net/positive.html The majority of cash single-family landlords are because they're paying a mortgage on 2005 prices whilst charging 2020s rent. But to properly do the accounting you'd want to compare selling the house and buying it again vs the rents. Buying is usually worse than renting unless you value the relative freedom to do what you want with the property and even then renters have the ability to change the house they're in (unless they're effectively stuck because of grandfathered in lower-than-market rates). The idea that housing problems are caused by landlords is obviously false on its face, as each landlorded house already has people living in it. Speculators sitting on empty inventory and refusing to landlord, now that could be a cause.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andrepd 5y agoBut I have been a landlord, I rented out my old apartment for several years after I moved to my new home. I don't pretend the income I got was for "services rendered". It is trivially easy to demonstrate that: you can outsource all tasks (cleaning, maintenance, even management and accounting) and still turn up a profit, which implies that this profit is entirely due to your monopoly on capital wrt. the rentee, and not due to actual material services rendered.
- refurb 5y agoBut the rental market and home purchase markets as separate markets. There is nothing that says rent has to be more than the cost of ownership. Go to a big city like Toronto and you'll meet plenty of landlords taking a loss each month. And there is nothing that says it has to remain static. Rents can drop while housing prices go up (see SF during Covid). And in the end, I'm not sure it matters? I've lived in cities where despite being able to afford ownership, I choose to rent. I'm glad to exchange my money for exclusive use of a house that I take no financial risk on, have no obligation to maintain, has only negligible transaction costs and I can walk away from with a months notice. All of those things have intrinsic value to me, some of those being services that I don't have to perform. I mean, is it unfair when someone rents out their cars on Turo and make a profit each month? Are they "extracting rents"?
- trgn 5y agoThat's it. Tons of homeowners are letting at a loss in the superstar cities. They're banking on appreciation, or see inherent value to stake a foothold in their city, possibly for generations. The cost of renting in the most expensive markets is much lower than the cost of home-ownership in those same markets. It's not because of supposed rent-extraction of landlords that housing is expensive. Renters will be in for a cold shower if they think that the cost of rent is just because of parasitic extraction from landlords right now. It's because of a zoning structure and tax-code which punishes capital investment in land, and favors speculative landholding. Without meaningful change to either, there won't be downward pressure on rents.