3 ms·
Disney is the rightsholder. They are free to do with this property as they please, including shutting it down completely with no hope of revival. No one else ha
by bitwize 5y ago
Disney is the rightsholder. They are free to do with this property as they please, including shutting it down completely with no hope of revival. No one else has this right, except as licensed by Disney.
The fact that it was shut down does not change copyright law, which these people were violating.
- KyeRussell 5y agoThe person you’re replying to is making a common sense argument (“a law that allows this is faulty”). “Yeah, well, it’s still legal” does not add to the discussion at all. Nobody is genuinely concerned about the legality of Disney’s actions. Rather, Disney had a clear history of influencing legalisation to suit its interests.
- aaron695 5y ago
- hedora 5y ago...proving that obeying copyright law is morally reprehensible?
- kinos 5y agoWhat do you acquire by having this opinion?
- bitwize 5y agoNothing, it's just that if it's illegitimate to enforce copyright in this case, then copyright itself has no meaning. Consider Song of the South, a movie so controversial that Disney wants to bury it. As the copyright holder they have every right to do so to protect their reputation. Because copyright, especially in civil-law countries, is bound up with the broader concept of authors' rights, including your right to protect your reputation as an author, the right to completely cease any further publication of a protected work is intrinsic to copyright itself; without that right, the concept of copyright falls apart. And if we abolish copyright because it's meaningless -- a move that would be curiously popular among programmers but unpopular among other creative professionals -- how are professionals in art, music, literature, etc. going to put food on the table? Do we just say "let them drive Uber and pursue their art as a hobby"?
- diordiderot 5y agoA sense of moral superiority for their 'cut throat rationality'
- xxxxx1234 5y ago
- krolden 5y agoIsn't that called being a copyright troll?