2 ms·
> So what if they died of the evacuation, the nuclear accident caused the evacuation. I wasn't aware that the nuclear accident caused massive flooding (the per
by godelski 5y ago
> So what if they died of the evacuation, the nuclear accident caused the evacuation.
I wasn't aware that the nuclear accident caused massive flooding (the person you're responding to is saying that everyone died from the tsunami, not the radiation). Your point still stands about large economic costs to exclusion zones, but I don't feel you responded in good faith. As per the article (and as someone who actually did study nuclear physics), the risk of creating an exclusion zone in Germany is extremely small. Last I checked German doesn't have many earthquakes nor large bodies of water that could lead to danger from tsunamis. Germany seems fairly stable from an environmental standpoint, so the only real causes for a nuclear disaster would be from a freak accident. Considering we've learned a lot about safety in the last decade (and way more since Chernobyl), this risk is pretty small.
- nl 5y agoIn Ukraine a nuclear power station was recently shelled with artillery. If a power station was shelled in Germany what measures would avoid an exclusion zone? And to be clear, there are plenty of groups that would deliberately cause an issue exclusion zone.
- kaba0 5y agoHow is it different than shelling a water dam? I would wager it is much easier to do huge harm that way than to shell a concrete hull made to withstand two planes simultaneously hitting it, or even cutting the main pipe in half, which will still safely shut down the plant. The only real (and exceptionally tiny) risk with modern nuclear plants is some contamination, but it needs several several fuckups to happen even with a goddamn tsunami hitting it
- nl 5y agoNo exclusion zone is needed after a dam breach. A reactor rupture causes widespread contamination even with modern reactors. There is nothing at all in modern designs that stops that.