6 ms·
Coding Horror: The Gamification
- wccrawford 15y agoAbout 2 years ago, I was looking at a forum that looked like the one pictured and thought, "Why would anyone let this happen to their forum?" Signatures started as a way to putting personality into your post, and they still are, but it's gone way overboard. Many forums put a reasonable limit on that stuff now. 2 lines, 100 characters, etc. I never looked at StackExchange as a solution to that, though. Forums were for everything from chatting to problem solving, and are usually conveniently divided for such. StackExchange is just for problem solving.
- nathanb 15y agoI have found the gamification of Hacker News to be detrimental to my experience. Insightful but unpopular comments end up getting buried by retreads of the status quo. It's the tragedy of the commons: if every single person can upvote, the most-upvoted comment will be the one which appeals to every single person. I prefer the threaded discussion style of kuro5hin back in the day where comments might be upvoted, but they stayed in the same temporal order they were posted in.
- tyree732 15y agoThat works to level out the playing field so to speak, but falls victim to countless spam and useless comments clogging up the comments page.
- arkitaip 15y agoUpvotes/Downvotes need to go. I don't think it's too much to ask of adults to read entire thread in chronological order. It's fully sufficient to be able to flag spam or other comments that break policy and have favorites that are completely private.
- icebraining 15y agoPeople here have already said they use flags as downvotes for submissions, what makes you think the same wouldn't happen in comments?
- amalcon 15y agoThis is the tricky thing about game mechanics. Yes, they are effective in creating goals, or at least things to strive for. For games, simply creating a goal (any goal) is often enough. It's much more difficult to create the goal you want. Forum karma and votes need voting ring and vendetta detection to be even minimally useful. Pandering detection would be great, but it's a hard problem. The only way to avoid pandering is to have a culture where: 1) People vote based on what they want to read, not what they agree with 2) People want to read things they don't agree with as much as things they agree with Both of these are hard. HN is the closest general-ish forum I've ever found to this, but it's still very far from the ideal. There's still a lot of pandering that goes on. The pandering just isn't all you see, like it is in many other places. StackOverflow is actually even closer, but this is because of the very narrow focus. People want to read the thing that gives the largest volume of correct information in a concise manner.
- revorad 15y agoI like the Reddit and LessWrong options of sorting comments by age or votes. Sure, it adds more complexity to the site's UI but considering HN is mainly about its discussions, making them better at the cost of complexity may not be so bad.
- wanorris 15y agoPersonally, I tend to want to respond to an article or discussion with whatever thought I'm having at the moment. The HN karma (in particular, the average) reminds me to try to filter my comments based on whether I'm saying something that I think others will find useful or whether I'm just saying it because I feel like saying it. I probably censor about half of what I would otherwise post based on this guideline, and it's nearly always to the betterment of my signal/noise ratio.
- nathanb 15y agoI find myself willing to spend more time/thought crafting a response to an article which I think will be read by more people. For example, I'm just pounding this out stream-of-consciousness style since I know it will only be read by those involved in this subthread, if that. Why not do the right thing and focus on thoughtful, well-written comments for their own sake? Because I have the karma carrot dangling in front of me. I feel like gamification has in this case removed my motivation to do what is most beneficial to the site.
- dennisgorelik 15y agoThat only means that gamification is not implemented correctly on HN. If weight of every voter's vote is evaluated by you (1), then the resulting weight would be tuned up for you. (1) You don't have to manually evaluate every voter. You just vote yourself, and if voter's votes correlate with your votes, then that voter's rank goes up (from the point of view of your personal rating system).
- michaelchisari 15y agoI've heard the quote as "bad artists borrow, great artists steal", which always made more sense to me. A bad artist will take what someone else has done, but it remains essentially the original artists vision and concept. A great artist steals it, and claims total ownership, making it uniquely theirs, despite the original source.
- pavel_lishin 15y ago> Based on the original size of those screenshots, only 18 percent of that forum thread page is content. The other 82 percent is lost to signatures, avatars, UI doohickeys, and other web forum frippery that has somehow become accepted as "the way things are done". Avatars are a quick and easy way to identify an author - and that in itself carries quite a bit of information. (I'd trust someone I knew to be a mechanic to post valid repair advice, vs. someone who posts all the time about their car breaking because of dumb things they did.)
- Unseelie 15y agoI do love Avatars for these reasons, and having a signature as an entirely vain engagement. But quite often, I find myself removing the signature because...as shown on that site, they're quite large, gaudy, and bloody repetitive.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoOn most forums, there's an option to turn signatures off. I almost always do this.
- Periodic 15y agoI noticed something interesting on Reddit. I recently installed the Reddit Enhancement Suite extension for my browser. One of the features is that it displays next to a user's name above their comment the sum of +/- 1 votes I have given them. It also colors them based on their distance from 0 (or something similar to this). Suddenly I find myself reading comments differently based on whether they a strong positive or negative rating from me. I worried a little when I found myself upvoting a comment that was made by a very common poster on the site, and I realized it was the sort of stupid joke that doesn't contribute to the discussion that I would normally down-vote. The reputation the user had with me caused me to give their posts the benefit of the doubt. It was a very odd experience. On HN, I almost never read the name of the person who posted something until I am about to vote on it. I enjoy trying to evaluate a post on its contribution to the topic, and not on the authority or popularity of the author.
- Goladus 15y agoGamification is a fad, it will almost certainly evolve into something more sensible, such as "engage your users," once the frenzy ends. It's nice to see Atwood highlighting the fact that they didn't set out to make StackOverflow gamified, they set out to engage users and foster quality contributions.
- Unseelie 15y agoSaying that 'engage your users' is a better terminoligy for what's going on here than 'gamification' basically ignores the whole point of the idea, which is that people like to be making progress towards goals..not 'engaged', but metrically shown as advancing. That is, at the very basic level, what gamification is, its making an activity into an activity with specific measures of progress toward a goal, such that people can rank themselves (and we do). This isn't a new or faddish idea, its an insight into how people act, and an attempt to use that bit of new understanding, as Atwood did, before being aware of the term, to engage users using what are called 'game mechanics' which are basically motivations outside of the actual reward structures of the activity. I suspect "engage your users" is moving into the much more targeted and practicable mode of "gamify your interface" rather than vice versa.
- Hisoka 15y agoYep, that's the point. People who use gamification for things like green living and saving energy, or advertising, or redeeming rewards, etc are missing the point. There's nothing to freaking gamify. Nobody feels any sense of achievement from saving energy, or redeeming airmile rewards, or checking in to places and doing random stuff.
- Unseelie 15y agoYes they do. First of all, saving energy is in itself a reward. Moreover, that's easily gameable by simply comparing yourself to a group of strangers at their energy efficiency house. Airline miles is kinda a hard one, except for the people in that group, competing there (and I'm sure there is), and as far a s random stuff...I'm here in large part because every once in a while I wonder if I can't get a few upvotes on hacker news, hopefully by saying something helpful or insightful, of course.
- joelhaus 15y agoWhat struck me most is Jeff's disregard for potential patent threats. Perhaps inadvertent, but he also makes a strong case for why such "business method" patents hinder innovation rather than promote it.
- codecaine 15y agoI like how I dont have to visit Coding Horror regularly to see whether there is a new post but rather just check HN
- sayemm 15y agoGreat post by Jeff Atwood here. It reminds me of this old RWW piece featuring SO and some great quotes by Spolsky: http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/anthropology_the_art_of_building_a_successful_soci.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/anthropology_the_art_of... "What we do have to think about [in the era of social networking] is human to human interaction," he said. And according to Spolsky, to do that, you have to think as an anthropologist does.
- akkartik 15y agoI read it as: Coding Gamification: The Horror