4 ms·
Unless they are also planning to nuke the rest of the planet, there is no "victory" in that scenario.
by paxys 5y ago
Unless they are also planning to nuke the rest of the planet, there is no "victory" in that scenario.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fmajid 5y agoNuking Kyiv would probably kill more Russians and Belarusians than Ukrainians from the fallout.
- Barrera 5y agoThe elimination of large chunks of the Ukrainian army in a single detonation could lead to the stated goal of the invasion, which was regime change in Kyiv. It would be a calculated risk that the response from the West would be much like it has been so far. We're not talking "The Day After," but more like a really big bomb and 2,000 more where that came from. The response to the invasion has been fragmented at best, and it's not unreasonable to think that would continue, especially given a county that has demonstrated a willingness to use nuclear weapons in battle. I'm not saying this is likely, but more speculating as to what series of events would cause the scenario to play out.
- hindsightbias 5y agoThere's no massive army operating in one place. It's a bunch of units running around in the woods, hills, towns and cities. Their largest forces are probably near the largest Russian forces, so sure, if they're willing to cull their own.
- yucky 5y ago>the stated goal of the invasion, which was regime change in Kyiv. Where was this stated as the goal of the invasion?
- Chyzwar 5y agoImagine that this tactical nuclear weapon from 70's fail and expolde over russia territory Or is dropped and do not not work. Russia would need to make tests and reach readiness to use them, ideally with air superiority.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The elimination of large chunks of the Ukrainian army in a single detonation could lead to the stated goal of the invasion, which was regime change in Kyiv. A tactical nuke won't do that, though.
- greenonions 5y agoI don't think it's entirely clear that the US/Europe has the appetite to go to war over the use of a tactical nuke.
- hollerith 5y agoHas the US or NATO even threatened to go to war if Russia starts using tacnukes in Ukraine? I haven't seen any reports to suggest so, and I've been following the news on this war closely. (The US has threatened more sanctions if Russia uses WMDs. That threat was in response to signs Russia was getting ready to use chemical weapons.)
- mattm 5y agoNuclear or chemical fallout that drifts into NATO countries could potentially warrant a response. Here's one such article from a few weeks ago. https://www.military.com/daily-news/2022/03/23/if-russia-uses-wmd-ukraine-fallout-could-trigger-nato-response-key-lawmaker-says.html https://www.military.com/daily-news/2022/03/23/if-russia-use... Of course, we won't know for sure unless it happens (and let's hope it doesn't).
- hollerith 5y agoOK, but even when detonated high enough above the ground that no appreciable fallout is produced, nukes are quite destructive. In fact, for many kinds of targets, cities being one, the altitude that maximizes destruction is high enough.
- histriosum 5y agoMy uneducated guess is that the primary goal of the latest rhetoric about the possible use of chemical weapons is intended to make this more clear. If "we" (not the US yet, but other countries that are nearer) are signalling a readyness to respond kinetically if chemicals are used, surely the message is that nuclear would trigger an even greater response.
- 5y ago
- oceanplexian 5y agoI don't know, I'm quite worried. I don't think this is as cut and try as people make it out to be. If Russia did launch a limited tactical strike on Ukraine, let's say super low-yield, honestly not much more than the MOABs we fired off in Iraq, is the USA really going to risk Berlin, or US cities getting vaporized to defend a non-NATO country?
- moffkalast 5y agoI presume it would at least make a full embargo more likely?
- aorloff 5y agoUkraine has also not yet attempted to hit Moscow (the city, not the ship) with missiles. Once a nuclear bomb is used, a lot of gloves will come off, not just the Russian ones, and so far Ukraine appears to have a lot of extremely competent military partners and Russia has a reluctant Belarus.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoWhat missiles capable of striking Moscow does Ukraine have? It's 500km from the closest point within Ukraine's borders. That's at the limit of long-range variants of Iskander, and Ukraine only has older stuff like Tochka.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoRussia is so weakened I doubt NATO would want them to regain strength if they start dropping nukes.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> If Russia did launch a limited tactical strike on Ukraine, let's say super low-yield, honestly not much more than the MOABs we fired off in Iraq, is the USA really going to risk Berlin, or US cities getting vaporized to defend a non-NATO country? The Baltics and Poland have already been pushing for NATO intervention because they want Russia checked because they don't want to be next; Article 5 is nice, but they’d rather stop Russia before it's on their land. Nuking Ukraine, even a tiny little nuke, ratchets that up enormously and forces the US and Western European NATO powers to decide how to secure the eastern flank of the alliance.
- emilsedgh 5y agoDo you mean the response to a Russian nuclear aggression would be nuclear?
- paxys 5y agoIt doesn't have to be nuclear. Any direct response from NATO would be a losing scenario for them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]