3 ms·
This is exactly what it comes down to. "I'm a free speech absolutist. Twitter should allow free speech." So we should allow spam bots shilling Bitcoin scams o
by paxys 5y ago
This is exactly what it comes down to.
"I'm a free speech absolutist. Twitter should allow free speech."
So we should allow spam bots shilling Bitcoin scams on every thread? "No, I obviously didn't mean that."
What about obvious phishing attempts promising Nigerian riches? "Those are obviously fake, and we need to keep users safe."
Hardcore pornography? "No, lots of children use the site. Those should be filtered out at least behind some kind of flag."
Explicit threats of violence? Blackmail? "No, all of that is obviously not allowed."
Should I be able to write a script to post a thousand Tweets a second? "No, that strains the infrastructure. There should be a rate limit."
So then we come back to a long list of rules for what should and shouldn't be allowed, and all the absolutism goes out of the window.
- indiv0 5y agoThat assumes a dichotomy of either: everything is allowed, or Twitter blocks things they want to block. There are other forms of moderation that might be acceptable to people who are otherwise free speech absolutists. Crowd-sourced block lists (i.e. subscribe to a list of accounts marked by other users as spam), with the option to introduce your own exclusions to the list. Alternatively, a web-of-trust model where you only see tweets & replies from people you follow. Or maybe the people you follow + the people they follow. Or maybe configure it on a per-person basis, if you trust person A's followee list more than person B's. There are a ton of options. The point is that users don't currently have a choice, and have to deal with Twitter's policies with no opt-out or whitelisting.
- dm319 5y agoWhat you're describing is really just maintaining your own bubble in social media. This is something that most people think is a bad thing, on both sides of the spectrum. You're not talking about speech which is generally felt to not be permissible in public. To give an example, this would like saying Elon Musk could simply block the twitter account that follows his private jet, rather than persuade the account to stop. It's not really the same thing.