3 ms·
I have a few thoughts: If you don't know how they can mislead you, it only means you are more vulnerable. We don't know what we don't know. Whole worlds of iss
by wolverine876 5y ago
I have a few thoughts:
If you don't know how they can mislead you, it only means you are more vulnerable. We don't know what we don't know. Whole worlds of issues and problems can be easily omitted, for example. Trusting any source as described is a fundamental mistake.
But this is really unnerving:
> Very rarely, that process gets it wrong
Why do you say that? That is not my understanding of the process. Look at all the exonerations from death row, cases that receive the most attention and process. Look at all the abuses of minorities and political outcasts.
> you should be careful of believing 100% anything that involves a DoJ accusation but no indictment
Do you mean, 'indictment but no conviction'? Indictments are easy - the old saying is that a decent prosecutor can indict a ham sandwich.
> Convictions are how we write history. We have now answered the following question: did this guy conspire to violate sanctions? The answer was yes.
That's not how knowledge works; we don't get relief from certainty. What we know is that they were convicted. Many accept, whether true or not, that that process is better than any available alternative; I don't know many people who have as much confidence in its accuracy as you do.
- cormacrelf 5y agoFrom 1976 to 2020, federal prosecutions led to only 11 people executed, and 8 of them were in 2020. https://sgp.fas.org/crs/misc/IN11474.pdf https://sgp.fas.org/crs/misc/IN11474.pdf In comparison, there were about 1500 from state courts. This makes sense when you realise murder is almost always prosecuted as one of 50 different state crimes. You have missed that I'm specifically talking about the US DoJ. State equivalents are entirely different organisations that I am not commenting on. > DoJ accusation but no indictment > Do you mean, 'indictment but no conviction'? No. Your little aphorism is true of many district attorneys but not of the US DoJ. I am referring to, e.g. statements by the FBI, which is a branch of the DoJ. The FBI in particular has a much more questionable history than the DoJ's criminal division, which handles prosecutions. Finally, on this theme of distinguishing federal prosecutors from everyone else, no, I don't have as much confidence in all criminal convictions everywhere as you might have been thinking. But I have quite a lot in US DoJ's ones. I studied law, but not US law. I do know how they can mislead you. Feel free to take my word for it as far as that goes.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Your little aphorism is true of many district attorneys but not of the US DoJ. Why would you say that?