35 ms·
Drive is incredible…ly terrible. Our non-technical staff (and some good technical people too) are always losing track of where files are. They write a doc the
by gumby 5y ago
Drive is incredible…ly terrible.
Our non-technical staff (and some good technical people too) are always losing track of where files are. They write a doc then can’t find it later.
The desktop tool (so you can use it like Dropbox) keeps getting confused and disconnecting on the Mac.
I’m also part of a scout troop that uses google to organize its activities. In the troop’s Drive I’ve found doctor’s patient records, the marketing plan for a major public company often mentioned on HN, and other documents clearly accidentally stored/shared with this group.
- thisiscorrect 5y agoI'm not making the trip. It sounds like you're saying users are moving files to the the wrong folders on their computers and the desktop tool respects that. What should the software do differently?
- huffer 5y agoI guess the idea was that it's very confusing for non-technical people, and very easy to misplace.. (sorry if your message was accompanied by an "/s" -- I didn't see any)
- ghaff 5y agoI can usually find the docs I've created pretty easily--but then I'm pretty good about sensibly filing things. But finding random Shared with Me is pretty problematic especially if I don't know exactly what I'm looking for. And, of course, as you say, if you're sharing docs, it's pretty easy to share with someone you don't mean to. Of course, the same could be said with sending around docs on email.
- gumby 5y agoAnd docs shared with me can’t be moved into my filesystem
- ghaff 5y agoWhether you can make a snapshot copy depends on permissions I think. But, yes, what I'd really like to do in many cases is to basically create a symlink to documents I know I'll be referencing/working with somewhere that they aren't mixed in with all the shared meeting presentations and the like I'll never look at again.
- gumby 5y agoIndeed because a snapshot loses the shared editing, which is only sometimes what you want.
- tepitoperrito 5y agoNot by right-clicking on the docs. You have to select the folder or document and then press "Shift-Z" which brings up a prompt letting you select where in your drive you'd like to move it. And yes, according to their forums, even this feature will be removed at some point in the medium term future.
- orangepurple 5y agoIf your drive folder has more than 50,000 files and you try to download an archive ZIP of them, your files will disappear at random. The only way to avoid this outcome is to install a desktop client and sync the folder.
- gumby 5y ago> The only way to avoid this outcome is to install a desktop client and sync the folder. Except the google desktop client is utterly flaky. They make Dropbox look good.
- 72deluxe 5y agoUse rclone to grab them instead.
- kingcharles 5y agoAnd that's a low barrier. The Dropbox client is totally flaky with me. I've never managed to get it to sync my files, because I have too many I guess? I just used rclone to get everything out of my Dropbox so I can close it.
- thevagrant 5y agoI've synced terabytes with Dropbox no issue and know others doing the same. All others cloud sync products I've tested are much more flaky. Google drive was the worst and had many issues supporting others who decided they must use it. Not sure what your dropbox issue is but I'd check you have the latest client, check you have granted file folder permissions to the app if using macos. First sync takes a while but performance is good after the first sync.
- orangepurple 5y agoI hope you verify file existence and integrity using a third party tool instead of blindly trusting the syncer or eyeballing it.
- 5y ago
- krinchan 5y agoI used to be part of a volunteer organization that is a loose confederation of local chapters that are all kept in line with a bit of copyright law by the original chapter. The central council that meets nationally on a monthly basis is organized almost entirely through Google Drive. The problem with the Business side of Drive is how Google conflates Groups, the message board/mailing list product with Groups that you apply permissions to. The chapter I belonged to had our own Google Apps domain. My account on that domain was added to one of the mothership's Groups so I would get announcements and participate in discussions. Unknown to them, that Group inherited a lot of default permissions from their Shared Drives. I couldn't get to the drives by browsing, but if I searched for terms that matched documents in those shared drives, I could open the documents AND open the containing folder. At which point I could browse up to the root of the shared drive. I reported it on the sly, one Mistress of Webs to another. We had a good "holy sh** what?!" laugh about it. It got fixed but as I've spoken to people at other NPO orgs that use Google apps, I've found that most have had the same mess happen: A group with external members was created as a convenient mailing list. Then, later they discovered that if the external member was also a Google for Business account they "inherited" some interesting access to things in Drive.
- agentdrtran 5y agoDrive's organization is a usability nightmare and I hope someone at Google has a plan for this. Shared with me is a graveyard, file permissions are a nightmare to manage, and repairing mistakes is painful to impossible.
- gumby 5y ago> usability nightmare and I hope someone at Google has a plan for this One of the things I love about HN is the humor.
- atraac 5y ago> I hope someone at Google has a plan for this Knowing Google the plan is to kill it and make a new thing, without options of moving, make it free so people flock to it and then turn into a subscription a year later.
- johnywalks 5y agoI'd rather pay to use Dropbox than have 50GB+ free on gDrive.
- mitchdoogle 5y agoIf you can't find files, are you saying they're disappearing? I'm having a hard time understanding what the problem has to do with Drive specifically. If people just forgot where they put something, it seems like you need to develop and practice some organization. I work with lots of clients and use Drive and organize things into folders named for each client, and then into separate categories based on what the file is. It's relatively easy to find things. If I happen to forget, then I've found the search works well. I use the cloudsearch page at cloudsearch.google.com
- saynay 5y agoWe have had a few files just seemingly disappear, never to be seen again. Only once or twice, but still. Mostly, organization of files behaves... oddly. It is weirdly hard to ensure everyone has a consistent view of a hierarchy / folders. Search does work, so long as you have a good idea what you are searching for. It isn't great for discoverability, or if you only have a vague idea what it is you are looking for.
- gumby 5y agoThe interface does not make it easy to figure out where a file you have opened is located.
- bornfreddy 5y agoI consider myself a technical person, but opening the files on Drive is always stressful for me (fortunately I don't need to do it often). The navigation sucks (I don't see the files that I know are there), the search is the only thing that works - if I know what to search for. I wonder how many files I simply don't know I have.