6 ms·

What's a good Jira replacement? Redmine? Phabricator? OpenProject? Just leaving the jira server alone and hoping there's no new and exciting zero-days? One thin

What's a good Jira replacement? Redmine? Phabricator? OpenProject? Just leaving the jira server alone and hoping there's no new and exciting zero-days? One thing is clear, these guys are a bunch of cowboys who can't be trusted with any amount of data.

elxr 5y ago
If you're hosting your code on GitHub, then GitHub projects is definitely worth using. Does everything I used to use Jira for, but feels more modern and lightweight. Also, it has dark mode.
deleted 5y ago
[deleted]
originalvichy 5y ago
For pure engineering teams it’s either Gitlab or Azure Devops. Those are the most common competitors I hear about. If you have non-engineers the choice gets trickier.
dzikimarian 5y ago
I'm on the same boat. Currently best choice seems to be youtrack, which has reasonable licensing model for self hosted option.
420official 5y ago
I'm not at all familiar but a tweet linked from the OP and written by the author plugs https://linear.app/ https://linear.app/
- gkoberger 5y ago
  Linear is phenomenal. Probably built for a different audience than Jira (it's like Superhuman for tickets), but if you want something that works well and is opinionated I highly highly recommend it.
- bloopernova 5y ago
  Linear has a dark mode. I'm already won over! ;)
- astroalex 5y ago
  I recently started using Linear at my new job, and I am a big fan. 1. It's snappy. Moving between issues and views is a breeze. 2. The UI is extremely functional and consistent. 3. Great keyboard shortcuts! Using Jira felt like having brain fog, and Linear is such a relief after that experience.
- linsomniac 5y ago
  Linear has offered free services to users impacted by Atlassian's outage through the end of the year. I took a look at it (we aren't impacted), and notice it can import tickets from Jira, and also has a "Jira Link" where you can use Linear as a kind of front-end to Jira if you aren't ready to go all in on Jira. When we chose Jira, one of the points that was made was: If we decide to leave Jira, there will almost certainly be an importer from Jira to the new system. Which does seem to be true. We came to Jira from Fogbugz, and I spent the better part of a month writing tools to import our tickets and wikis. Jira had a Fogbugz importer, but it was horribly broken. Looking at Linear, there is no such escape hatch, or indeed, searching the docs I saw no "export" or "backup" capability at all.
  - enra 5y ago
    It's in the settings, "Import / Export" in the sidebar. We support CSV export or alternatively you can use the GraphQL API. You're right we need add a page in the docs. It was only mentioned in few pages in passing. For now I added a section here until we can make a full page about it: https://linear.app/docs/workspaces#export-workspace-data https://linear.app/docs/workspaces#export-workspace-data If you are looking anything else hit cmd+k to search the docs.
    - linsomniac 5y ago
      Thanks for the reply. Linear looks pretty slick, I'll probably give it a try with the Jira Link, and get some experience with it without having to do a whole conversion plus get buyin from the rest of the team. We weren't impacted by the Atlassian outage, but Linear does seem to have a pretty compelling feature-set.
_dark_matter_ 5y ago
Bugzilla
histriosum 5y ago
I've used Request Tracker for years. It's not pretty, it's written in Perl, but I can fairly easily make it do all the ticket tracking flows I care about and it just runs and runs and runs. My scale is admittedly small, but I put tens of thousands of tickets per year through my instance, and i basically never have to touch it unless I'm setting up a new queue or different flow for something.
- beardbound 5y ago
  Wow, I’ve never seen anyone mention RT here. I used it for years when I was working IT for my university while in undergrad. It worked pretty well. It didn’t have a lot of features but it allowed clients/customers to respond to tickets via email which was pretty cool at the time (late 00s). It also ran pretty fast on the terrible servers we had it on.
  - secabeen 5y ago
    We still run it today; they had a major release last year, I think. Its key feature is that it remains email-first. Customers never interface with the website, for them it's all just like they're emailing a human, with some extra tooling and tracking on top.
WC3w6pXxgGd 5y ago
kitsune_ 5y ago
Gitlab would be enough for engineering teams
nicoburns 5y ago
We switched from JIRA to Shortcut https://shortcut.com/ https://shortcut.com/ (formerly Clubhouse), and I'd highly recommend them. It's much better than JIRA ever was, both from a UX perspective and an implementation/performance perspective.
- jamesfinlayson 5y ago
  I used to use Clubhouse and moving a ticket between columns was so snappy. With Jira it is a long wait.
cerved 5y ago
kernel.org
astura 5y ago
I haven't seen Trac mentioned yet.
takeitaussie 5y ago
Gitea is nice. It's a self-hosted Github-like. Not sure how well it scales to big teams and projects though. Probably can't be worse than Jira...
dimgl 5y ago
I've used Linear and Shortcut (formerly Clubhouse). I was a huge Shortcut proponent, but there were a couple of concepts that weren't fully fleshed out. Linear has none of these issues. I've been super impressed with it.
closeparen 5y ago
I loved Phabricator but it's end of life. https://www.phacility.com/phabricator/ https://www.phacility.com/phabricator/

elxr 5y ago

If you're hosting your code on GitHub, then GitHub projects is definitely worth using. Does everything I used to use Jira for, but feels more modern and lightweight. Also, it has dark mode.

deleted 5y ago

[deleted]

originalvichy 5y ago

For pure engineering teams it’s either Gitlab or Azure Devops. Those are the most common competitors I hear about. If you have non-engineers the choice gets trickier.

dzikimarian 5y ago

I'm on the same boat. Currently best choice seems to be youtrack, which has reasonable licensing model for self hosted option.

420official 5y ago

I'm not at all familiar but a tweet linked from the OP and written by the author plugs https://linear.app/ https://linear.app/

gkoberger 5y ago
Linear is phenomenal. Probably built for a different audience than Jira (it's like Superhuman for tickets), but if you want something that works well and is opinionated I highly highly recommend it.
bloopernova 5y ago
Linear has a dark mode. I'm already won over! ;)
astroalex 5y ago
I recently started using Linear at my new job, and I am a big fan. 1. It's snappy. Moving between issues and views is a breeze. 2. The UI is extremely functional and consistent. 3. Great keyboard shortcuts! Using Jira felt like having brain fog, and Linear is such a relief after that experience.
linsomniac 5y ago
Linear has offered free services to users impacted by Atlassian's outage through the end of the year. I took a look at it (we aren't impacted), and notice it can import tickets from Jira, and also has a "Jira Link" where you can use Linear as a kind of front-end to Jira if you aren't ready to go all in on Jira. When we chose Jira, one of the points that was made was: If we decide to leave Jira, there will almost certainly be an importer from Jira to the new system. Which does seem to be true. We came to Jira from Fogbugz, and I spent the better part of a month writing tools to import our tickets and wikis. Jira had a Fogbugz importer, but it was horribly broken. Looking at Linear, there is no such escape hatch, or indeed, searching the docs I saw no "export" or "backup" capability at all.
- enra 5y ago
  It's in the settings, "Import / Export" in the sidebar. We support CSV export or alternatively you can use the GraphQL API. You're right we need add a page in the docs. It was only mentioned in few pages in passing. For now I added a section here until we can make a full page about it: https://linear.app/docs/workspaces#export-workspace-data https://linear.app/docs/workspaces#export-workspace-data If you are looking anything else hit cmd+k to search the docs.
  - linsomniac 5y ago
    Thanks for the reply. Linear looks pretty slick, I'll probably give it a try with the Jira Link, and get some experience with it without having to do a whole conversion plus get buyin from the rest of the team. We weren't impacted by the Atlassian outage, but Linear does seem to have a pretty compelling feature-set.

_dark_matter_ 5y ago

Bugzilla

histriosum 5y ago

I've used Request Tracker for years. It's not pretty, it's written in Perl, but I can fairly easily make it do all the ticket tracking flows I care about and it just runs and runs and runs. My scale is admittedly small, but I put tens of thousands of tickets per year through my instance, and i basically never have to touch it unless I'm setting up a new queue or different flow for something.

beardbound 5y ago
Wow, I’ve never seen anyone mention RT here. I used it for years when I was working IT for my university while in undergrad. It worked pretty well. It didn’t have a lot of features but it allowed clients/customers to respond to tickets via email which was pretty cool at the time (late 00s). It also ran pretty fast on the terrible servers we had it on.
- secabeen 5y ago
  We still run it today; they had a major release last year, I think. Its key feature is that it remains email-first. Customers never interface with the website, for them it's all just like they're emailing a human, with some extra tooling and tracking on top.

WC3w6pXxgGd 5y ago

kitsune_ 5y ago

Gitlab would be enough for engineering teams

nicoburns 5y ago

We switched from JIRA to Shortcut https://shortcut.com/ https://shortcut.com/ (formerly Clubhouse), and I'd highly recommend them. It's much better than JIRA ever was, both from a UX perspective and an implementation/performance perspective.

jamesfinlayson 5y ago
I used to use Clubhouse and moving a ticket between columns was so snappy. With Jira it is a long wait.

cerved 5y ago

kernel.org

astura 5y ago

I haven't seen Trac mentioned yet.

takeitaussie 5y ago

Gitea is nice. It's a self-hosted Github-like. Not sure how well it scales to big teams and projects though. Probably can't be worse than Jira...

dimgl 5y ago

I've used Linear and Shortcut (formerly Clubhouse). I was a huge Shortcut proponent, but there were a couple of concepts that weren't fully fleshed out. Linear has none of these issues. I've been super impressed with it.

closeparen 5y ago

I loved Phabricator but it's end of life. https://www.phacility.com/phabricator/ https://www.phacility.com/phabricator/