4 ms·
What a fun video regardless of whether it's correct or not. It comes across as an asmovian psychohistory and that's a fun lens to play with regardless of its ut
by kelseyfrog 5y ago
What a fun video regardless of whether it's correct or not. It comes across as an asmovian psychohistory and that's a fun lens to play with regardless of its utility.
Assuming it's a useful model, where does that leave us? Basically with nothing. The author suggests "spending less than we make, and treating each other well." Or in other words, fiscal austerity and compromising with non-compromisers. If Dalio has examples of nations retreating from the inevitability of collapse, or engineering soft landings, he doesn't share it in the video. Either way, why should a system which inevitably results in big cycles stop producing big cycles. Of course each empire wants to avoid its demise. Wanting to avoid demise isn't a sufficient condition.
What I hoped Dalio would confront, was the possibility of changing cycle producing machine itself. You can start to see where this is going by identifying the change needed in each of the sub-components. Eliminate economic systems which create wealth gaps. Upend the global reserve system entirely. End Westphalian sovereignty. &c &c. Any or all of these naturally lead to big cycle formation and resistance toward changing the system creating big cycles is a tacit endorsement of the big cycle machine which I fully expect to receive (big cycles are good actually!) :)
- ayngg 5y agoThe video itself is a super condensed version of his book primarily aimed at the Youtube audience demographic, the book it is based on probably goes much further into depth.
- kelseyfrog 5y agoThe book's calls to action are as such: > Know all the possibilities, think about the worst-case scenarios, and then find ways to eliminate the intolerable ones. > Diversify > Put deferred gratification ahead of immediate gratification so you will be better off in the future. > Triangulate among the smartest people possible Each of these have varying degrees of paragraphs detailing their nuance, but they all come back to the point of making personal decisions to navigate a decline rather than changing the system of decline.
- jstx1 5y agoIs deferring gratification still sensible when the future is uncertain? The point is that you give up something in the present in order to get something in the future. But when the future is less reliable, it’s more likely that you’re giving up stuff for no future benefit.
- kelseyfrog 5y agoThat's right. Deferring gratification is deciding to pass on the mousseline sauce on an ill-fated voyage across the Atlantic. I'd much rather be focused on advancing safer modes of transport than worried about which lifeboat I'm going to head for.
- ayngg 5y agoI think Dalio is choosing to focus on what the individual can do to navigate change one cannot control, which is a lot easier for individuals to do compared to what systemic change could be done to make changes for the better, which often requires massive resources, coordination and political capital not available to the average person. That sort of stuff is outside of the scope of what the book is about it seems.