15 ms·
Study suggests mechanism through which psychedelics may alleviate depression
- Tenoke 5y agoI've been asking for a while but what's going on with the less descriptive, previously(?) against the rules title editorializing?
- newbamboo 5y agoI’m all for this but part of me gets a very “Brave New World” vibe. Are we all going to have to micodose shrooms to tolerate our prosperous progressive society? It’s seeming increasingly likely.
- raxxorraxor 5y agoThe trick is that these reservations vanish after being shroomed.
- replygirl 5y agodrugs that make you feel good about spending all day in your ego will do that
- greatpostman 5y agoI tripped and it reset my brain in fundamental ways. Felt like an operating system reinstall.
- Overtonwindow 5y agoDis you trip while also on other medication? I was on Wellbutrin and Zoloft, but 3 grams didn’t do anything for me. Four grams did, but only mildly, that was enough to have significant therapeutic relief. I suspect depression medications may inhibit the effect?
- at_compile_time 5y agoI've read that SSRIs interfere with them. It feels like a pretty cruel irony.
- hobs 5y agoAfter a quick skim https://mind-foundation.org/psychedelic-antidepressant-interactions/ https://mind-foundation.org/psychedelic-antidepressant-inter... is worth reading - in a nutshell I have personally seen this: 1. Someone taking SSRI's and psilocybin finds that the dosage... simply doesnt work. I had one individual who ate up to 8! grams before seeing and feeling things that I would see in normal people at about 1.5. 2. This might be really bad for you! There's some evidence that mixing that level of both drugs might be not good for your liver and might get you into toxic levels, and suggests tapering - I honestly dont suggest tapering your anti-depressants unless you are working with a medical professional because well, suicide. 3. If you really want an undenyable trip, just take some salvia (properly), 15 minutes and many of the same after effects.
- DrBoring 5y ago> I suspect depression medications may inhibit the effect? When I was on Wellbutrin, it stopped the mental effect of alcohol. When I imbibed, there was no loss of inhibition normally associated with alcohol use. However, I did still lose physical coordination. Zoloft did not have the same effect. The brain is a crazy thing.
- tomek_ycomb 5y agoI agree 100% brain is a crazy thing. In general I think this is most pronounced even within antidepressants of the same class, with similar binding affinities, some people report limited success with one or the other seemingly similar drug. All this said, wellbutrin is a very different drug than zoloft. It have more dopamine and norepinephrine activity iirc. Also for anyone else, try to avoid alchohol and wellbutrin or take it knowing that your seizure threshold goes down on wellbutrin so its easy to black out and do worse than you realize (also related to the reported effects above)
- hackingthelema 5y ago
- throw93232 5y agoSF folks will now support microdosing for homeless, because it may cure their depression, and help them of the streets :)
- DrBoring 5y agoI would argue that many people today already have their own form of Soma. Alcohol being the most popular one due to its abundant supply. A lot of people just need to step out of their own minds every now and then.
- BossingAround 5y agoThe alcohol, cigarettes, caffeine and sugar that helps us cope doesn't give you a "Brave New World" vibe?
- vermarish 5y agoI always understood BNW's soma as a drug that is administered regularly to provide an escape and instill complacency. Modern examples might include alcohol, Netflix, and cushy salaries. Psychedelics are the opposite; they provide perspective and they make you yearn for something greater.
- dkarp 5y agoOpioids and Benzodiazepines (Xanax) are even closer to what I imagined Soma was
- Trasmatta 5y agoShrooms had the opposite effect on me, where I suddenly became much more cognizant of the damaging aspects of our society, to an almost unbearable level. It made me overall less capable of operating in society, not more. Can't say I was really a fan of its effects on me. Psilocybin seems to induce a highly plastic state of mind, and so the results can be somewhat unpredictable.
- colpabar 5y agoDid you take them alone? Did you go outside at all? I think your environment really affects your experience. I always tell people to go outside as much as possible, ideally on a nice sunny day. Walk around in a park or the woods and I bet you'd have a different experience. If you're alone and indoors, you'll most likely end up going deep inside your own head, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but things can definitely start getting dark.
- Trasmatta 5y agoI took them alone, but did go outside. Going outside was the best part of the trip. It wasn't a "bad trip" (had those on DXM before, this was much different). It was more that it opened my mind more fully to the amount of suffering in the world, and how much of it is caused by humans. Something we usually have to suppress in order to function from day to day. It was probably overall a good thing to have those realizations, but it was highly challenging, and it was detrimental to my mental health over the following months. But the lessons were probably just as important as a trip filled with just love and joy (never had one of those).
- pmoriarty 5y ago"Shrooms had the opposite effect on me, where I suddenly became much more cognizant of the damaging aspects of our society, to an almost unbearable level. It made me overall less capable of operating in society, not more." It's important to connect with others who've had similar realizations of the dysfunction of our society. Together we are stronger, can support each other, and work together for positive change. Don't go it alone.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoMicrodosing - definitely not. Regardless of what the proponents say, even small doses of psychedelics induce some degree of impairment (please don't microdose and drive!) But you touched on one of the key problems with psychedelics: We can't really expect people to trip every few months forever. If psychedelics are used, I would expect them to be in the context of intense therapy. Many of the studies will require patients to go through 10 or more therapy sessions before, during, and after their psychedelic dose.
- derbOac 5y agoI don't know why this doesn't get more attention. It's a classic ethical dilemma in psychiatry, and ultimately the basis for many science fiction works. Let's say, for the sake of argument, you have a pill that can make people feel really positive and boundless, that they love their lives and nothing could make them feel better. This pill will work regardless of their circumstances. On the other hand, their environment is horrible: they are in poverty due to societal injustices and systemic failures, and loved ones are dying from completely preventable diseases due to those same societal failures. Works like The Matrix explored this theme in an extreme form, almost to a fault, where the premise is so absurd that it becomes dismissed. It's difficult to argue about treatments that will help people feel better and be better in their lives, whatever that means for them, but I can't help but be angry, even furious at the paradigm that underlies current behavioral biomedical research, where everything is seen as being a problem within the individual. It's not so much that there's something wrong with doing research like this, it's that other research, focused on more environmental factors, is seen as soft or unsexy, or the domain of some other field, or some such thing. I can't help but feel that our society is hurtling at astonishing speed toward an ethical crisis that gets almost no attention. What happens when we can alter behavior and experience with extreme precision and power, but still live in a worldview that treats individuals as the primary determinants of their own fate? What happens when withholding treatments or enhancements becomes a salient problem, when opportunity costs become a form of corruption?
- emadabdulrahim 5y agoYou're talking about too many different points in one: 1. How much of someone's suffering and/or depression is due to brain chemical imbalance vs society and environment around them. 2. Would alleviating someone's depression and/or excessive anxiety would make them happy but with indifference to their surrounding, making them oblivious to the environment around them while being in a state of bliss. 3. The ethical dilemma of "fixing" someone by handing them a pill, instead of working on actually improving the real issues that may be contributing to their psychological pain. I think these are different issues that are not necessarily easy to answer one way or another. Non of these issues are self evidently clear which way should we go about them.
- asdff 5y agoHumanity has always been getting intoxicated on drugs and alcohol though. Society practically evolved to organize the brewing of beer in Mesopotamia and Egypt. It's only recently that human societies have gotten so conservative with these things.
- karpierz 5y ago> placebo that turned out to be escitalopram, an SSRI antidepressant. How is this a placebo?
- BossingAround 5y agoIf that was sugar, it's pretty easy for me, as a study participant, to tell whether I've been given mushrooms or not (i.e. am I feeling drugged or not). I suspect that played a part of the reasoning to use a psychoactive compound instead of sugar pills as a placebo.
- TheBlight 5y agoIIRC, AstraZeneca did a similar thing when testing their covid-19 shots. In one of their trials the placebo was a meningitis vaccine.
- cnity 5y agoIsn't the term "control" more accurate than "placebo" in these contexts? I thought that a placebo was inactive, while a control is used to set a baseline for judging improvement. A placebo is a type of control, but not vice versa.
- bragr 5y agoA placebo doesn't have to be inert, it's more that it has to have no therapeutic value. Meningitis vaccine doesn't protect against covid so it's an effective placebo for testing covid vaccine for example.
- arghwhat 5y agoA placebo does not need to be completely inactive, it merely needs to not exhibit the effect you are trying to test for. Using an anti-depressant as placebo for a test regarding anti-depressive effects does seem a bit odd, but it is fine if the test is for effects or durations exceeding the capability of placebo drugs.
- 5y ago
- Overtonwindow 5y agoThere was another discussion recently about this study because it was also reported in Bloomberg. From my own personal experience, shrooms was the greatest thing that ever happened to me. It was like someone flipped a switch on my depression and the depression magically went away. The study really validates what I experienced, and the truly life-changing effect that it had.
- BossingAround 5y agoInteresting. Did the effects last? Are you still using it, or was it "one-and-done" kind of an experience?
- pigtailgirl 5y agowhen start to feel less motivated - don't want to go out - struggling at work- I take ~3 grams - usually lasts about 2 months or so - find this much better than microdosing personally
- starkd 5y agoHow do you measure out 3 grams? I would think it would be difficult to control that level of granularity.
- Karawebnetwork 5y agoThree grams of mushrooms is easily 4 to 10 individual mushrooms. Usually people simply weight the entire mushroom and not the exact psilocybin content. This is not ideal since potency will vary but it's enough to give you a good idea of the dose when comparing to previous sessions. However, there are more and more legal services who can provide already weighted product with the exact psilocybin content on the label.
- vsgzusnex 5y agoProbably just means 3g of actual mushroom fungi matter. Just need a food scale.
- bencollier49 5y agoEarlier discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30991278 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30991278
- newman8r 5y agoas a reminder, california SB-519 could decriminalize this substance in 2022 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billStatusClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220SB519 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billStatusClient.xh... I'm not sure what the best way to support it is, but I'm following the progress closely and it isn't getting much coverage - I figure I might as well spread the word whenever I can.
- coding123 5y ago
- alan-hn 5y agoEnding prohibition would mean that criminals would no longer be involved in drugs, because people can buy them at the store. It doesn't work super well if the regulations and taxes make legal drugs more or as expensive as legal drugs, so that needs to be managed well for things to work.
- jjulius 5y ago>... I have to smell weed pretty much all the time now. Life could be worse. >They are Hmong... Why is this at all relevant?
- coding123 5y agoJust whatever.
- maerF0x0 5y ago> They are Hmong How is this relevant?
- alan-hn 5y agoRace is always relevent to racists
- 5y ago
- krylon 5y agoOnce upon a time, I took a (by my standards) pretty large dose of mushrooms while rather depressed (although I did not realize it at the time). The trip itself was rather dark, but the next day, my depression was entirely gone, I was actually happy for the first time in months, and it lasted for quite a while. The first time I took LSD, my mood was significantly improved for weeks afterwards, even though I don't think I was depressed before. But I did notice that things that normally annoy me tended to annoy me less, and things that made me happy made me happier. Again, this lasted for at least a month. Considering how often antidepressants tend to be a hit-or-miss game (not to speak of side effects), I am a bit annoyed psychedelics don't get more attention for medical use.
- luckydata 5y agoPsychedelics used to be a fairly common treatment for depression and addiction in the 50s before the witch hunt of the US government against what was considered "street drugs". Leary didn't do them any favors either as he was essentially telling everyone to load up on psychedelics, which triggered the usual over the top uninformed response our dear elected officials are so fond of.
- iknowSFR 5y agoSame experiences. Dropped drinking, started exercising. The LSD dose was much higher and the after effects listed lasted for weeks. However, the mushrooms dosage was lower and while the after effects were similar, it didn’t last as long. Truthfully, I felt a deeper connection with the moment post-LSD. The LSD trip kind of hurt but after the first few hours, became a solid 6-8 hour span of self reflection. Mushrooms started out chill and evolved into a pretty painful experience before moving into that self reflection stage. What’s happening during that self reflection stage is best described as a feeling of losing it all. Family, friends, etc. but not so much material items. In that moment, I felt complete loneliness and the fear associated with that loneliness. That fear led to asking what would make me be alone and the answer was my personal ego. It ultimately was a confrontation of personal flaws like narcissism or selfishness. Later in the trip, like 5-8 hours, a feeling of being content with who I am and where I need to improve to not lose the things that truly matter was the result. I don’t know if I’ll ever try either LSD or mushrooms again but the reset on my personal ego made me value a lot of important things that get backburnered in the grind and stress of life.
- lvl102 5y agoI believe depression is not something you can resolve with drugs. Sure, it helps to numb it all away.
- bin_bash 5y agoThe way these drugs seem to work is they stop serotonin from being blocked in habitual ways. The resulting experience makes people see/feel things as if it was for the first time. "Numb" is a poor description for this phenomenon.
- philosopher1234 5y agoI'm not sure if "these drugs" refers to psilocybin or SSRIs, but the science does not support SSRIs as a solution to depression.
- siloed 5y agoWhat? Do you mean SSRIs specifically? Or are you including SNRIs, α2 blockers, MAO inhibitors etc? Do you have any evidence to support this or just anecdotes?
- bin_bash 5y agoI'm referring to psilocybin and other tryptamines but I suspect you knew that and simply wanted to take a jab at SSRIs for some reason
- weakfish 5y agoSource on that statement? Considering they’re the leading pharmaceutical treatment, the burden is on you to prove that claim
- spicymaki 5y agoThis is a really unpopular answer, but I whole heartedly support it. Unfortunately, many people are looking for a solution (a quick fix) in a pill. They don't want to hear that perhaps the way they are living or the society they live in is not conducive to happiness. Perhaps an alternative to intoxication is to work towards a world of human flourishing.
- rubatuga 5y agoJust from working with a few psychiatrists for the past month, none seemed to be enthused about trialing or studying psychedelics for depressed patients. I think we will need a lot more case studies and a comprehensive list of harms and adverse reactions before convincing them. Worth mentioning this treatment also requires more work on the therapist/psychiatric side. Something that doesn’t need a lot of therapy sessions is ECT which is very effective for treatment resistant depression. Lastly, psychedelics used to be researched for military purposes and mind control, wondering if this is still a risk factor for patients?
- lampshades 5y agoI think the largest risk factor is to the wallets of psychiatrists.
- philosopher1234 5y agoOr perhaps its just another round of hurting people being taken for a ride by massive pharma companies, and psychiatrists aren't thrilled about it.
- lampshades 5y agoYou can grow a mushroom in your closet.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoIt’s fun too!
- philosopher1234 5y agoSure, you can, and feel free to try it. But thats not the reason for psilocybin's sudden popularity with pharma sponsored studies.
- siloed 5y agoThe parent comment draws an important difference between the use of psychedelic therapy and, say, ECT. I support this research but "Big Psychiatry just wants the cash!" is a reddit-level of nuance we can do without please.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoLink to actual paper: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01744-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01744-z These open-label studies also need to be carefully evaluated within the context of their selection criteria. One of the biggest challenges with open-label studies for psychedelics is that they tend to collect "true believers" who are already convinced that psychedelics will cure their depression. They seek these studies out specifically for the opportunity to receive psychedelics, often because they've read books and news articles telling them it will be successful. Notably, 1/4 of participants admitted to past psychedelic use (and I suspect the actual number is much higher, given that study participants often lie if they think a certain answer might exclude them from receiving the drug they want) The study also explicitly required treatment-resistant patients to have tried and failed multiple antidepressants in the past, which explains the low response rate to the SSRI arm: > The open-label trial had the additional criteria of TRD, as defined by no improvement despite multiple courses of antidepressant medication (mean = 4.6 ± 2.6 past medications; range, 2–11)39. Patients were asked whether they had previous experience of using psychedelics. In the open-label trial, 25% had previous experience. Similarly, in the DB-RCT, 31% of patients in the psilocybin arm and 24% in the escitalopram arm had previous experience.
- ProjectArcturis 5y agoThere's also an ongoing problem in the analysis of MRI functional connectivity. About 2010, someone had the idea to apply concepts from graph theory to fcMRI. That is fraught with a number of heroic assumptions (fcMRI correlations do not necessarily represent physical connections, and continuous relationships must be binarized with arbitrary thresholds). But most importantly, there are so many different graph theory metrics, and ways to tweak the analysis, that a determined postdoc is basically guaranteed to find something that can reach statistical significance. I suspect something like that has happened here.
- lampshades 5y agoI took a large dose of mushrooms about 11 years ago and haven't had depression since. My life was on track to nowhere and now I'm doing great. Hard to not give mushrooms a bit of the credit, the results were immediate.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoHow large?
- lampshades 5y ago14 grams
- mattbaker 5y agoOregon will be formalizing their program to provide therapeutic access to mushrooms in controlled settings soon. I have mixed feelings and some potential fears about the execution, but it’s still going to be absolutely fascinating to watch and I’ve got my fingers crossed it could become a really positive treatment option for residents here. I bet we’ll see some articles about it on HN in the years to come!
- philosopher1234 5y agoDepressed people need therapy. Enough with the pills. The science backing up antidepressants or psilocybin is very weak.
- emadabdulrahim 5y agoDo you have any data on the effectiveness of talk therapy for patients with depression? Any data on how long it takes for the patient to experience any noticeable relief?
- philosopher1234 5y agoNo, sorry. I'm not a scientist, just summarizing the impressions I've gathered from reading folks who are.
- tomek_ycomb 5y agoI believe a proper summarizing might be closer to "people need therapy AND drugs" The strongest results across the board are a combination of therapy and medication. My personal opinion is to vouch for therapy the most, and push hard against the pill narrative. But I think it adds to the shame of pills to not acknowledge the potential role many people have for pills. Now disregarding the "ssris are more effective combined with therapy" i also want to point out that most of the psychedelic studies are also combining therapy. My personal conjecture and perhaps some other peoples would be that drugs can help enable the conditions in which talk therapy is more effective. The classic example is the mdma ptsd therapy trials. Therapists can't apply cognitive therapy techniques if someone's fight or flight kicks in too powerfully. Drugs can help to bring the person to a state where they can get therapy. I've also seen this with friends --> deep depression, ssris helped elevate to the point that therapy was more successful than deep depression would otherwise have allowed.
- pmoriarty 5y agoMy own impression (and I've been intensely interested in both therapy and psychedelics for several decades) is that psychedelics in combination with therapy (and sometimes even psychedelics alone) can be much more effective than therapy, antidepressants or their combination. A positive outcome from psychedelic therapy is not guaranteed. Some people don't benefit from it, but many more people benefit from it than other approaches. And when they do benefit, the benefit is often much more pronounced and also typically longer lasting. There's a lot of research on this, particularly on individuals with treatment-resistant depression. Psychedelic therapy is not a panacea.. and nothing that operates on your mind is going to magically fix the circumstances you're in or your relationships with others -- you have to do that yourself. But the depression itself can be helped.
- rank0 5y agoThere’s definitely some benefit for some people but this headline is straight sensationalized. People need to be careful with psychedelics. The afterglow wears off pretty quick. I’ve met many people for which psychedelics actually reinforced “negative” aspects of their person…except now they believe to be enlightened from their trips. After dozens of trips myself, one of the things I’ve learned is that these drugs induce the feeling of profundity. The experience of a trip FEELS profound, regardless of the actual content of your thoughts. Sometimes it’s great! — When your new idea or outlook is truly beneficial for yourself and others. Not everybody gets that. My cynicism has been magnified.
- pmoriarty 5y ago"People need to be careful with psychedelics." Absolutely. Psychedelics are incredibly powerful substances and they need to be treated with respect. Everyone considering doing them should educate themselves thoroughly beforehand and use them in maximally safe, constructive ways. James Fadiman's Psychedelic Explorer's Guide[1] has lots of great advice on how to do this. "The afterglow wears off pretty quick." It really depends on the substance and how it's used. Ketamine, for example, commonly needs to be readministered relatively frequently (though some people have lasting effects), while many people get very long lasting effects from between one to three therapeutic MDMA or psilocybin sessions (sometimes lasting for years). It's people who tend to use psychedelics outside of a therapeutic context, to "party" and/or without constructive intention or post-trip integration that tend to lack lasting effects.. but even then it's not at all uncommon for the experiences to be life-changing. [1] - https://www.amazon.com/Psychedelic-Explorers-Guide-Therapeutic-Journeys/dp/1594774021 https://www.amazon.com/Psychedelic-Explorers-Guide-Therapeut...
- droopyEyelids 5y agoIt's not cynicism imo- psychedelics can help people with depression, but they add fuel to the fire for people with 'dark triad' personality traits.
- globalise83 5y agoJust thinking back to one of my happiest student memories: watching the sea water pouring off the tail of a breaching whale... on a poster on the wall of my friend's digs.
- vincentmarle 5y agoQuestion: wasn't psilocybin recently legalized in California? How does one get it? Asking for a friend..
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoDecriminalized in Oakland and Santa Cruz. My friend was able to buy psilocybin capsules at a shop in Oakland, though I forget the name.
- greyface- 5y agohttps://zidedoor.com/ https://zidedoor.com/ ?
- TaylorAlexander 5y agooh yah thats the one!
- jmacd 5y agoI had dinner with two psychiatrists who are working in this field both with adults as well as one of them who is doing work in paediatric psychiatry. They have both taken LSD, Psilocybin and ketamine as part of their work so they would be able to introduce it to patients properly. One key component that seems to be missing from a lot of the excitement about these treatments is how important an ongoing therapy or other behavioural support component usually is. A lot of patients find some relief from a ketamine or other therapy but it can open up a host of issues they have not dealt with or it can resurface old behaviours. One example was a patient who had a long history of abuse which was more or less hidden by their severe depression and suicidal tendencies. They had a series of ketamine treatments by an anesthesiologist and it cracked that past right open. The place they were taking the treatment was not equipped to support that and they did not have immediate access to psychiatric or even good psychological support and it did create a bit of a spiral. I don't think any of that comes as a surprised to people in the field, but each patient and circumstance is different. The sooner we can bring these treatments in to mainstream health research, the more holistic the approach to patient health can be. Lots of interesting stuff to learn. I am just bystander-fascinated by it and am not professing any expertise here.
- pmoriarty 5y agoUnfortunately, a lot of people can't afford therapy... and insurance doesn't tend to cover psychedelic therapy. Hopefully one day it will, but we're not there yet. This will, at least in the short-term, unfortunately lead to widening inequality, where relatively wealthy people will be able to afford therapeutic treatment, while the poor will be left to their own devices.
- mise_en_place 5y ago> They have both taken LSD, Psilocybin and ketamine as part of their work so they would be able to introduce it to patients properly. While I think there might be potential for psychedelics in therapy, let's be honest here. That would be like a Wall Street guy saying he snorted 3 lines of cocaine to better advise his clients on investments
- 5y ago
- extrememacaroni 5y agoFunnily, I find the idea that a susbstance can influence your behavior so much rather depressing :( is there anything there that is fundamentally unchangeable no matter the chemistry that could be called a "self".
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoEvery experience every day changes the self. Every time you form a new memory your brain changes.
- barnabee 5y agoStrange, I find the same idea immensely reassuring/satisfying…
- pmoriarty 5y ago"is there anything there that is fundamentally unchangeable no matter the chemistry that could be called a "self"" The Buddhists don't think so. One of their fundamental tenets is "anicca" or "impermanence", which is often interpreted to mean that nothing is unchangeable or everlasting. Many materialists/naturalists/physicalists don't believe there's an unchanging self either. But those who believe in a soul, in resurrection, or in reincarnation might. It's not a settled question, and a lot depends on what you mean by "self".
- asdff 5y agoWatching an elderly relative in cognitive decline is even more depressing. You won't be you forever even if your body is still around.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 5y agoSo, how does one start DIYing this in the meantime?
- rednerrus 5y agor/unclebens
- pmoriarty 5y agoAlso see Alan Rockefeller's excellent videos on psilocybin mushroom identification: [1] [2] [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pInqVRRva7M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pInqVRRva7M [2] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcL-7u80kjs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcL-7u80kjs
- joeberon 5y agoI had horrific and long lasting negative effects from LSD. My wife absolutely laments that she convinced me to take it the two times I did. I saw mortality and impermanence directly, I felt entirely alone, and also I got extreme motion sickness and was passing out in a mess of white fractals and intensity in my body. I developed severe flashbacks to the trip and every time I had one I became extremely suicidal. The only good thing that came from it is that it pushed me towards an actual solution for me, which is practising zazen (goalless sitting in the Soto Zen tradition of Mahayana Buddhism). Resting in this moment, as Buddha, unmoved by external conditions. If I did not learn this, my life would be over, and indeed taking a break from the practise for 6 months the old grasping mind returned and I found myself heavily desiring death again. I sit and this all goes. My life after LSD was so traumatic that I was forced to find a way. The worst part is that therapists had no idea how to even consider the cosmic horror I felt, they just said it was “weird” and tried to shift the focus to tangible things, but it was the ineffable infinity that I was scared of. Anyway, I always say that LSD fucked up my life so much that I had to turn to _religion_ to cope!! As a former militant atheist, that’s an incredible thing to say
- jamal-kumar 5y agoEver hear of psychedelic integration therapy? There's a whole class of therapists who won't dose people on psychedelics because they feel the risks are too high (legally+medically) but will gladly take in people like you to help integrate the experience and helping with coming to some closure and insights. Might be worth a session or two. Also sounds like you took a really freakin high dose... Yeah acid has its own agenda and lasts waaaaaaaaaaaay too long, there's a reason a lot of the recent research is on psychedelics that don't blow you away for up to 12 hours straight. Can you believe some of us do that for FUN? Maybe it helps to be spiritually seeking to begin with. I think learning your lesson with these tools is kind of like getting in a fight. You might get your ass kicked but some of us throw hands professionally with a shit eating grin on our faces the whole time.
- pmoriarty 5y agoI'm wondering if you are sure it was LSD? Did you test it yourself? Also, what context did you take it in? Did you have an intention for the trip? Were you with a trusted, experienced sitter? Did you combine the substance with any other drug?
- ThinkBeat 5y agoDepression is not a well understood phenomenon. It is vital in such a discussion to be mindful of the term "depression". It is used colloquially as a synonym for being "sad", "grieving" or just having a sad day. I am depressed because my mom died. Usually means "I am going through natural grief process because someone very dear to be died recently" Robert Sapolsky explains this much better than I [1] I have lived with major depression for 3 decades or so. Treatment is frustrating. You go through whatever diagnostic process is being used. Then they throw pills at you. This one might work, take it for 3 weeks - 3 months and tell us how you feel. You have to take it for a good amount of time to ensure that it's "fully working". Some make you more depressed and more suicidal. Some have other serious side effects. If the doctor treating, you figure that you tried out one for long enough they will throw a different pill at you and then you rinse and repeat until you feel better. Then they will start to try combinations. That is even more fun. I have spent years being a Guiney pig for the most part getting worse and having to deal with various side effects. I am not unique in this. It is common for major depression to have to try and fail, try and fail, try and fail meds. We have no physical way to diagnose depression as far as I know. You can't go to the ER and they measure something and can tell you if you are or not. We dont know what causes it, (we have many ideas of things that sometimes do) and we have no way to measure how much better you are getting. Its based on talking, filling out endless forms, and being asked if you feel better. There is no cure. (well death) (Being suicidal) It is something you cannot run away from. It is in you, and you can run, but it makes no difference. (Exercise can be beneficial, but I am not talking about that right now.) Well-meaning people will suggest all forms of activities that "Will make you feel better". It does not. Then they will nag you about how much better you feel now. Which you dont. I just want to urge people to be careful about using the term depression and dont build up too much hope in people (like me) because this new drug will fix you all up. I would take LSD, MDMA, K (all have shown promise). If prescribed or as part of a study if I could. It will take massive research over time with plenty of Guiney pigs to figure out if it works, how it works, for how many it works. With headlines and discussions on this, we will cause people with major depression to run out, buy street drugs, self-administer it and in all likelihood end up with even more problems. Given the unknowns of street drugs, how pure is it, what else is in it, how much should you take? It is highly unpredictable. [1] Stanford's Sapolsky On Depression in U.S. (Full Lecture) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc
- sidesleep4life 5y agoPsychedelics caused me to have ongoing dissociative panic attacks. So, you know… it’s not all rainbows :P Hopefully with careful study a safe treatment can be developed. (Certainly without any study people will keep tripping, so certainly I advocate continuing study!)