3 ms·
"revealing the incomes and tax rates of the 400 Americans with the highest incomes from 2013 to 2018" That seems like an odd analysis? Why would you take the
by refurb 5y ago
"revealing the incomes and tax rates of the 400 Americans with the highest incomes from 2013 to 2018"
That seems like an odd analysis? Why would you take the average income and average tax rate over a 6 year span? I assume that many of these folks have large parts of their income coming not from W2 salary but from periodic equity sales. All of that nuance is lost when six years are all treated as equal.
They do allude to this in a footnote "For the top 400 by income, the total shown in the table is total AGI for the top 400 in each year, so this is a shifting population and one different from the top 400 by average discussed throughout the story."
And before someone says "to protect their private information". Well I mean they are naming these folks directly so any privacy at this point is kind of lost.
And also this footnote "Each individual’s percentage of income taxed at the lower rate is calculated using their highest income earning year from 2013 to 2018." So that stat is not representative of the time period in question but rather a single year. Again, if they offloaded a bunch of long-term capital gains, that number is the max not the typical or average.
- megaman821 5y agoThere are enough nuggets in here for some interesting discussions. Take the Walton heirs, nearly 100% of their income is long-term capital gains, so they will basically pay only 20% or less of their income for their entire lives. A doctor would pay around 30%. Is that delta of 10% represent the risk of investing in the market? Looking at the historical data and the US policy, long term investing in the market is basically a sure thing. The tax discount is way too much for the actual risk.
- refurb 5y agoI didn’t think long-term capital gains rate was lower to account for risk, it was to account for:1) inflation, since you pay taxes on nominal not real gains unlike income which has indexed brackets and 2) to incentivize long term investment over short term investment which is taxed at a higher rate.
- megaman821 5y ago1) Stocks and real estate are a lot more inflation proof than wages. Their prices already handle inflation. 2) I still think there should be a discount for long-term investing, just that it is too much. They could lower the spread between long and short term investing with almost no consequence.
- refurb 5y agoIn terms of #1, it’s the fact you pay taxes on inflation, not just real growth. So if you buy a stock at $100 and sell at $200 ten years later, but with inflation that same dollar is worth $1.50 ten years later, your real return is $50, not $100, but you’ll pay taxes on the full $100 of $20, which means a 40% real tax rate. With income the brackets are indexed to inflation so that issue is removed.
- megaman821 5y agoI get that, but would rather have a $300k salary with a COLA each year or an S&P 500 index fund with an expected return of $300k? There is just no way your take-home income is less with the index fund over a 10, 20, or 30 year period.
- refurb 5y agoSeems like an odd comparison considering your $300k salary would grow over 30 years too. Point is, if you pay taxes on the nominal returns, your tax rate is much higher than the 20% long-term capital gain rate implies.