4 ms·
A lot of the rah-rah boosterism of "decentralization" is coming from VCs that saw how much money there is to be made by ignoring laws and regulations for long e
by rchaud 5y ago
A lot of the rah-rah boosterism of "decentralization" is coming from VCs that saw how much money there is to be made by ignoring laws and regulations for long enough. Airbnb and Uber are the most brazen examples of this.
What's left unsaid of course is that the only interest deep-pocketed investors have in dismantling elements of the financial system (MC/Visa dominance, KYC/AML checks, suspicious transactions disclosure rules), is so they can replace it with a system that they personally have an equity stake in.
- datadata 5y ago> they can replace it with a system that they personally have an equity stake in. Isn't this a fact about capitalism and not at all specific to the financial sector?
- nojs 5y agoI think this is the expected cycle of business long term. 1. Entrepreneur notices an opportunity to avoid overzealous regulations and provide better value to customers 2. Everyone wants a piece of the action, bad actors start to move in and updated regulation is required 3. New regulations get out of hand and start to become extremely costly to comply with (see banks) 4. New entrepreneur comes along with a novel way of avoiding said regulations, providing better value to customers again. Repeat. At any given point in time the industry is either in cowboy crypto mode, or crusty overregulated bank mode. Both have drawbacks, and it’s just a pendulum that swings back and forth.
- toomuchtodo 5y ago“Overzealous regulation” = regulation they prevents me as an “entrepreneur” from profiting off of unsophisticated people, in this example.
- qeternity 5y agoWho determines what qualifies as “unsophisticated”. This is where the overzealousness creeps in. Regulators always push for more regulations.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoRegulators discover and patch regulatory gaps. One might say that’s doing their job, versus overzealousness.
- Jorge1o1 5y agoSo a “poor” but highly knowledgeable financial planner making “only” $180k a year can’t invest in their friend’s startup because the regulators deem it too risky. But some random dentist can? https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-09-24/earning-the-right-to-get-swindled https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-09-24/earnin...
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThe dentist can weather the poor investment. Knowledge does not make you financially solvent. It just improves your gambling odds as it relates to equity investment.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoFrom my perspective, only letting people who are well off enough to 'weather the loss' seems like something that only exacerbates the wealth gap.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoSuper off topic, but the wealth gap is exacerbated by not taxing the wealthiest at a high enough rate, not regulations against capital market participation in highly speculative ventures. To argue that accredited investor regulations are the problem is no different than arguing for lottery tickets or penny stocks as an investment strategy for low income citizens.
- mschuster91 5y agoLotteries are super regulated though, it's (no matter the country) an utter nightmare, even stuff like a school's trinket raffle. The reason is a shitload of people making "easy profits" by frauding people.
- thwayunion 5y agoI cannot think of a single previous business cycle that was driven by this dynamic. Can you give some historical examples? This strategy seems unique to the most recent generation of capitalists (sharing economy, crypto stuff, etc).
- VHRanger 5y agoThe 2008 bubble was largely driven by the deregulation of financial instruments (and non-regulation of new instruments) in the late 1990 and early 2000.
- reedjosh 5y agoIt was also driven by easy fed dollars and banks that knew they'd be bailed out.
- rchaud 5y agoLehman Brothers didn't know, Barclay's acquired them for pennies. Same with Bear Sterns (JP Morgan acquired) and Merrill Lynch (BofA acquired). Also quantitative easing began as a result of the massive loss of trust between banks as a result of the crisis. Every central bank in countries with big financial centers had to follow a similar playbook.
- VHRanger 5y agoBanks didn't expect to be bailed out. That question has been studied Bank upper management just didn't care that they'd be bailed out or not because their incentives were on fairly short term horizons.
- throwaway894345 5y agoThis isn't necessarily a bad thing. It's probably good to stop strangling the economy for a bit once bad actors disappear. Moreover, in many cases the regulators themselves are corrupt (e.g., regulators exempting lenders from regulation leading up to the 2008 housing crash), so the regulation may not be delivering the intended value and taking another swing at it in a decade may not be the worst thing. Further still, in a few cases, the regulation may actually not make sense any more due to some change in the landscape--it might be similarly good to back off the regulation, see what problems arise, and address them accordingly (i.e., control loop).
- HWR_14 5y ago> e.g., regulators exempting lenders from regulation leading up to the 2008 housing crash Congress changed the regulations, not the regulators. I really have no idea what examples you're thinking of.
- yrral 5y agoThe concept of visa/mastercard was also largely unregulated at the time they launched. Take a look at the history of visa article on wikipeida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visa_Inc.#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visa_Inc.#History Visa was not the first, and other tries to do a credit/charge before them were much worse or limited in scope. This is similar today to what is happening in web3/crypto. If you don't think the ingenuity of humans will get us somewhere productive with these technologies, then I don't know what to say to you. Quotes from the article about the launch of visa: > In the weeks leading up to the launch of BankAmericard, BofA had saturated Fresno mailboxes with an initial mass mailing (or "drop", as they came to be called) of 65,000 unsolicited credit cards > By March 1959, drops began in San Francisco and Sacramento; by June, BofA was dropping cards in Los Angeles; by October, the entire state of California had been saturated with over 2 million credit cards and BankAmericard was being accepted by 20,000 merchants.[18] However, the program was riddled with problems, as Williams (who had never worked in a bank's loan department) had been too earnest and trusting in his belief in the basic goodness of the bank's customers, and he resigned in December 1959. Twenty-two percent of accounts were delinquent, not the 4% expected, and police departments around the state were confronted by numerous incidents of the brand new crime of credit card fraud.[19] Both politicians and journalists joined the general uproar against Bank of America and its newfangled credit card, especially when it was pointed out that the cardholder agreement held customers liable for all charges, even those resulting from fraud.
- thinkmassive 5y agoThe Cold Start Problem, by Andrew Chen, devotes a chapter to this as a case study. I don’t recall it covering these negative aspects, which are obviously important to consider. Still a great book for startup growth ideas though.
- objclxt 5y ago> This is similar today to what is happening in web3/crypto. If you don't think the ingenuity of humans will get us somewhere productive with these technologies, then I don't know what to say to you. They won't, because they achieve nothing that can't already be accomplished with proven technologies. Axie Infinity could easily be built using regular plain old databases, but they built in on the blockchain using a terrible bridge architecture and as a result had $600 million stole. Such innovation.
- tootie 5y agoIt's true. AirBnB and Uber/Lyft exist almost entirely as tools to weaponize regulatory loopholes. True of a lot of analytics tools as well.
- earthboundkid 5y ago"As all tech industry observers are aware, the twin pillars of a successful startup are cost shifting (i.e. user generated labor) and regulatory arbitrage (i.e. tax avoidance)."