8 ms·
Russian trolls tried to distract voters with music tweets in 2016
- Cenk 5y agoLink to paper: https://oa.mg/work/10.1017/psrm.2022.9 https://oa.mg/work/10.1017/psrm.2022.9
- baybal2 5y ago
- overthemoon 5y agoHow effective was it?
- croon 5y agoThe desired outcome was reached, and the effort and money spent likely wouldn't have been spent unless deemed necessary. Always difficult to draw direct causality though.
- vintermann 5y agoWe don't know that. The situation right now is a great example that Russia likes to adjust its "goals" in retrospect, to say this was what they wanted all along. And "money wouldn't have been spent unless it was deemed necessary"? You have an awfully high opinion of Russian institutions' fiscal responsibility! I still say what I said right after, and have said for 4+ years: Russian propaganda during the election was probably intended to hobble Clinton with domestic political troubles, not actually for Trump to win.
- croon 5y ago> We don't know that. The situation right now is a great example that Russia likes to adjust its "goals" in retrospect, to say this was what they wanted all along. Russia hasn't stated anything on the subject. The goals are evident in the actions. > By constructing a timeline of the IRA messages, they found left-leaning IRA trolls posted large volumes of entertainment content in their artificial liberal community and shifted away from political content late in the campaign. Simultaneously, conservative trolls were targeting their community with increases in political content. The effort would have encouraged the right to vote and the left to ignore politics. > And "money wouldn't have been spent unless it was deemed necessary"? You have an awfully high opinion of Russian institutions' fiscal responsibility! I'm not claiming it was worth it, I'm saying someone there did think it was, evidently.
- Msw242 5y agoHonestly the media coverage makes it sound like the Russians run our elections. That perception is a much bigger win from them than anything they got from Facebook ads and bots. So many Americans want to believe that the only way anybody could ever disagree with their beliefs and preferences is through manipulation by malicious foreign actors. The reality (that half the population disagrees with them and has different values) is completely unpalatable.
- watwut 5y agoI did not detected such perception, really. There is a lot of blaming other party for wrong values going around all the time. That is not even mutually exclusive with foreign actors trying to influence politics, whether successfully or not.
- Msw242 5y ago>I did not detected such perception, really. Well, there was such a perception E.g.: "How Russia Helped Swing the Election for Trump" https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/10/01/how-russia-helped-to-swing-the-election-for-trump https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/10/01/how-russia-hel...
- watwut 5y agoThat is one article, you are saying "Honestly the media coverage makes it sound like the Russians run our elections." and "So many Americans want to believe that the only way anybody could ever disagree with their beliefs and preferences is through manipulation by malicious foreign actors." I did not seen this opinion that elections were all about Russia to be frequent fo prevalent or dominating either news or what Americans talk about.
- Msw242 5y agoHow many sources would satisfy you, given that an institution like New Yorker publishing the take doesn't? If you give me a reasonable number (less than 10 min of work) I'm happy to deliver.
- livinginfear 5y agoVery effective. As long as you only retroactively accuse Russia of responsibility for all of the democratic outcomes that you didn't want.
- watwut 5y agoLooking at abstract, the article is not trying to estimate actual impact. Just what those accounts were doing. As, in, it is analysis of actions rather then achievements.
- stirkac 5y agoSo, how is this different compared to a slap by one famous person that got reposted thousand times?
- smcl 5y agoI think one man publicly assaulting another at an incredibly high-profile event in front of a live global audience was bound to be insanely popular regardless of whether or not a Russian bot army signal boosted it.
- koheripbal 5y agoWhile true, it is important to know that they DID signal boost it, and that at least for those couple days, news about Ukraine was more buried than it otherwise would have been. Don't think in binary terms. Russian influence campaigns excel by exaggerating valid newsworthy events.
- ASalazarMX 5y agoYou can think in binary terms if it's not a bit, but a binary tree.
- smcl 5y agoThe question was: why is this any different from what happened at the Oscars? The answer is: the Will Smith thing was bound to be a huge story regardless of whether it was assisted. Do you disagree? I'm not sure what your point is, if I'm honest.
- tablespoon 5y ago> The question was: why is this any different from what happened at the Oscars? Honestly, the problem with that question is that it's asking about the wrong object. It's like asking what's the difference between shooting a person and shooting a target, when the bullets are identical. A bullet can be used to perform a lot of different goals, just like a piece of attention-grabbing content can. The thing to pay attention to isn't the content itself, but how it was aimed and who did the aiming. To give a similar example: The text of the First Amendment says "Congress shall make no law...abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press...," yet slander and libel are still illegal. No amount of banging on that pithy text will change that actual situation.
- beefbudd69 5y agohey thats what the US or any other western government do as well, lets not forget the convenient let's pass these pork filled bills while the plebians are watching their soccer world cup, super bowl etc.that happens EVERYTIME...really democratic too, considering the pork in these bills consist of things the people do not actually want such as making encrypted chats illegal or forcing people to get the jab or lose their jobs makes you wonder where these politicians are getting their ideas from ...
- dsrees 5y ago
- livinginfear 5y agoHaven't we heard enough of this bad faith narrative already? > "There are going to be all sorts of bad actors trying to interfere in the midterms, especially in the contested races..." Vote the way we want you to vote. Otherwise you're being undemocratic! And Russia is to blame! > "The fact that the average person would not associate music with Russian trolls means that they’re doing a good job." Isn't this statement a bit Kafka-esque? The implication of this is that if you don't live in fear, somehow associating the mundane flood of meaningless content that is social media with you purposefully being misdirected by Russia, you're just ignorant.
- metalliqaz 5y agoSpoken like someone who welcomes the help. Propaganda is real, it does work, and it is a problem. I struggle to explain why anyone would brush it off, other than it happens to align with their own goals. An electorate that is perpetually thinking and voting with activated amygdalas is not a good thing.
- brightball 5y agoFor most of my life I feel like politics has worked that way though. It's human nature to respond to fear. It's why so many people spend more time talking about why we have to stop the other guy from getting in office rather than why our own guy should be there. And it certainly happens for a reason, besides the empty promises brought by most politicians the most visceral human response comes from fear. The more fearful people are, the easier they are to manipulate in general. If you take a step back and look at political messages designed to inspire fear, it will all become pretty visible.
- livinginfear 5y ago> "Propaganda is real, it does work, and it is a problem." Do the supporters of 'Liberal Democracy' never employ propaganda? I use this as an example since when the issue of foreign interference in the American democratic process is brought up it's usually in the context of the 2016 election. Trump of course representing a deviation from decades of America's foreign policy being the export of 'Liberal Democracy or else'. > "An electorate that is perpetually thinking and voting with activated amygdalas is not a good thing." What if people use their "activated amygdalas" and come to conclusions that you don't agree with?
- paganel 5y agoI'm starting to believe that there are genuine Western trolls that come up with the "it's all Putin's fault!" whenever the going gets tough, like right at this moment. Didn't think that I would have put an institution like Cornell in the Western troll camp, but I guess that's what hybrid war gets us nowadays.
- _3u10 5y agoMusic tweets. Sounds like a highly engaged voter base…
- sremani 5y agoThe past 2 months are evidence that both Russian kinectic and cyber warriors are not 12 feet tall. The next few months will prove they are not 4 feet tall either. Russian troll farms did play a role, but my hypothesis is they are neither insignificant nor decisive in 2016 election result.
- ramesh31 5y ago>“You might think you’re clicking on a cat meme, but really you’re potentially putting a troll network into your feed that could later start posting divisive content, or monetize their following.” The problem is that you can explain this to people in depth, and they just don't care. People are completely incapable of comprehending what a powerful mind control device that glowing rectangle in their pocket is. I think long term this will be a new arena of warfare. The will of the social media content consuming zombies is up for grabs to anyone capable of manipulating them.
- helloworld11 5y agoThis needs some serious qualification... For starters, please feel free to define "divisive". I had no idea we were all under some olbigation to be non-divisive, or "united". Secondly, HN is full of posts about the ineffectiveness of ad campaigns, advertising in general and even targeted ads at influencing people heavily. These are campaigns often orchestrated by multibillion dollar corporations that hire PhDs of all kinds to tailor their messages. Yet on the other hand -and especially since the media "misinformation" fiasco of resentment over Trump's victory against the elite's better judgement of what's best for the masses own decision making- suddenly any minor foreign group can somehow magically brainwash millions of Americans and others into making all sorts of decisions. I don't at all doubt that foriegn actors use social networks to spread memes and attempts at viral lies. I've seen plenty of examples of this in action. Its influence level however is being absurdly exaggerated and in very hypocritical, very self serving and ideologically charged ways. All the more laughable is the idea that any of this is something new or outside the area of what supposedly respectable major media organizations would do. Does anyone remember anything about how news sources operated before the advent of the internet? Does anyone recall the innumerable times major publications toed grotesque government lie machines for the sake of specific interests?
- bsuvc 5y agoAt risk of being called a conspiracy theorist, is it only Russia and China that do this, or do western government agencies also do this, to other countries or even to their own populations?
- colpabar 5y agoI'd like to know this as well, and if anyone has any sources that cover it, please list them. I'm so tired of the western media lens.
- throwaway743 5y agoI linked the elsewhere in this thread but will paste them here for convenience. https://www.techdirt.com/2011/03/18/us-military-kicks-off-plan-to-fill-social-networks-with-fake-sock-puppet-accounts/ https://www.techdirt.com/2011/03/18/us-military-kicks-off-pl... https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/04/facebook-must-take-these-four-steps-counter-police-sock-puppets https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/04/facebook-must-take-the... And iirc, there was a bill around 2015 that revoked the blocking of US military from carrying out domestic propaganda. I gotta double check tho. Edit: It was the State Dept who were banned from domestic propaganda via their broadcast arm under the Smith-Mundt act until 2013 when the ban was lifted. https://www.techdirt.com/2013/07/15/anti-propaganda-ban-repealed-freeing-state-dept-to-direct-its-broadcasting-arm-american-citizens/ https://www.techdirt.com/2013/07/15/anti-propaganda-ban-repe...
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThe West will often hires a private company to do the same thing and calls them "political operatives." And presumably the "Western" intelligence agencies are doing something. We have evidence of it happening in South Koreaa around 2010, and it's hard to imagine other agencies didn't learn from it's success.
- throaway_436 5y ago
- throaway_436 5y ago
- guilhas 5y agoBillions were spent in the election, why would some random thing like this make any difference? https://nypost.com/2016/12/09/hillary-clintons-losing-campaign-cost-a-record-1-2b/ https://nypost.com/2016/12/09/hillary-clintons-losing-campai...
- cguess 5y agoBecause Wisconsin was won by Biden by 20k total voters in 2020. VERY small percentages matter.