3 ms·
If the mainland decided on a military take-over of Taiwan they would not care about this. Their aims would be longer term and motivations deeper and this would
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
If the mainland decided on a military take-over of Taiwan they would not care about this. Their aims would be longer term and motivations deeper and this would not act as deterrent. If anything the push by the mainland to develop its own semi industry is aimed at avoiding 'suffering' from sanctions and loss of Taiwan's production capability.
So, IMHO, this suggestion from the US military serves US interests (the US Army War College is obviously looking after US interests not foreign countries'), probably because destroying TSMC facilities in Taiwan would prevent the mainland from acquiring state-of-the-art tech, or at least slow it, and would prevent mainland China from 'owning' the global semi production capacity. On the other, as things stand, this would wreak havoc on international semi markets and global economy.
Lastly, any looming invasion would be known many months in advance because of the massive scale of the military build-up (probably bigger than D-Day) and be preceded by large scale air attacks.
- philliphaydon 5y ago> If the mainland decided on a military take-over of Taiwan they would not care about this All Pooh cares about is being able to put his name against concluding Maos war. “I did what no one else could”
- FooBarWidget 5y agoThis is a very simplistic, cartoonish, and frankly wrong, reading of what motivates their behavior. Unfortunately China literacy is quite low in the western world, which in turn encourages people to perpetuate stereotypes like this. Here's an actual China expert who talked about the subject of literacy: https://twitter.com/China_Digital/status/1509490066426581005 https://twitter.com/China_Digital/status/1509490066426581005 This is not to say that their behavior is justified (nor am I saying they are not justified). My point is that proper understanding is important no matter whether one agrees or disagrees.
- philliphaydon 5y agoYou must be joking, that was a long thread of nothing. At the end of the day, Xi wants to achieve the goal of invading Taiwan and destorying the remains of the ROC. It's plain and simple. There is very little benefit to taking Taiwan, there's no valid claims to Taiwan. The majority of the people here don't identify as being part of China and don't want to be part of China.
- trasz 5y agoProblem is, nothing above matches reality - except for the absurdity of taking Taiwan, but then you failed to draw any conclusions from it. It's just another mindless repetition of US state propaganda.
- starfallg 5y ago>If the mainland decided on a military take-over of Taiwan they would not care about this. This conflicts with your subsequent statement - >If anything the push by the mainland to develop its own semi industry is aimed at avoiding 'suffering' from sanctions and loss of Taiwan's production capability. The reason they are developing their own semiconductor industry is they are acutely aware that Taiwan's production expertise and capabilities are currently irreplaceable. And until they have caught up, it is a massive risk invading Taiwan and destroying TSMC in the process. So the deterrence effect is obviously there, whether how long that is effective for is another matter.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoNo contradiction. The mainland knows it needs to develop its own semi industry. It's already having issues because of US sanctions, and would likely face even more sanctions if it decided to invade Taiwan, not to mention the risk of destruction of Taiwan's facility, indeed. On the other hand, as things stand destroying TSMC would hurt everyone, as you say. China is working on reducing that hurt because it is obviously sensible to do so, the US are also working on reducing that hurt for the same reason. But the historical and political forces are such that I don't think China would be deterred because Taiwan planned to blow up TSMC facilities... So, IMHO this is just the US trying to make sure that China would not get TSMC fabs as that would be the worst outcome for them, not a deterrent.
- signatoremo 5y agoIt would be a deterrent to a China’s invasion as long as China is still lacking in semiconductor manufacturing. It allows Taiwan and the West to buy time. 10 years? 20 years? Who knows what will happen during that time — Xi may have died, the West will have diversified the semiconductor industry, a new generation of Chinese can grow past nationalism and recognize Taiwanese people’s will for independence.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThe issue of Chinese re-unification goes beyond Xi and "nationalism" used pejoratively... Especially, China has a long history of struggling to achieve and hold national unity that dates back millenia before the CPC. This is mixed with the last two centuries of being the victim of foreign aggression. It's not that the people in Taiwan overwhelmingly want 'independence', by that I mean that they oppose re-unification, is that they do not want the communists (which is the whole reason of the current situation in the first place), and the 'independence' camp is suiting US interests. Ultimately I believe that the mainland is willing to sustain a level of economic pain to get hold of Taiwan but this would be calculated based on domestic politics, not TSMC's fabs.