4 ms·
Those inspections may technically be illegal. Depending on how you turn your head and squint, impeding those trucks (especially if it's via inspections domestic
by shadowgovt 5y ago
Those inspections may technically be illegal. Depending on how you turn your head and squint, impeding those trucks (especially if it's via inspections domestic vehicles don't experience) could be a violation of the commerce clause of the Constitution.
- Auracle 5y agoI mean, according to the Supreme Court you can squint your way into justifying almost anything using the commerce clause.
- shadowgovt 5y agoSure, but that's the point. The reinterpretation of the commerce clause circa the Great Depression seems (to my not-a-lawyer eyes) to imply that if these border stops are going to raise prices in Oklahoma, the Executive is within its purview to tell the Governor to give his state troopers something else to do. My gut says that Abbott knows this, but he just needs to string the legal process out 'til election day so he doesn't care.
- gowld 5y agoIt's quite a stretch to suggest that (interstate/international) Commerce clause doesn't grant the Federal gvernment the power to regulate commercial trucks crossing state and Federal borders. Oklahoma prices don't matter for this.
- ThunderSizzle 5y agoThe existence of a person may have a potential affect of some degree on interstate commerce, and therefore can be regulated in entirety under the commerce Claude. That is the reasoning behind the affordable health care act on existing without government mandated levels of health insurance e. Your existence as a human affects commerce, and therefore is penalizable. And the stupid 16th amendment. That's caused just as many problems as the commerce clause.
- 8note 5y agoOverall the 16th sounds pretty perfect? Ability to have income taxes, without the states objecting? Or is your criticism that some states should pay more income tax than others?
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Your existence as a human affects commerce, and therefore is penalizable. Your existence can be taxed directly under the original constitution; that doesn't need the reinterpreted commerce clause.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoWhy was I downvoted? The text of the sixteenth amendment makes this obvious: > The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration. That qualifier -- "without apportionment among the states" -- allows income taxes that aren't head taxes. Head taxes were already allowed. Nothing to do with any interpretation of the commerce clause.
- 8note 5y agoInspecting incoming vehicles sounds a lot like the job of customs to me, so you don't have to squint very hard
- nomel 5y agoDoes a state have no control of its international borders, especially if it can be proved that customs is performing insufficient inspections? I would imagine Texas could claim that they have to pay for these people, to some extent.
- gowld 5y ago> Does a state have no control of its international borders. Generally, no, and not in usurpation of Federal law. That's what the Commerce Clause literally says -- regulating foreign trade is a Federal role. They or Congress can sue the Federal executive in Federal court.
- nomel 5y ago> can sue the Federal executive in Federal court. How does it work the other way around? Does the federal court sue Texas?
- shadowgovt 5y agoGenerally, no. "... and [the United States] shall protect each of them [the States] against Invasion; and on Application of the Legislature, or of the Executive (when the Legislature cannot be convened) against domestic Violence." This plus the 10th amendment makes the division of responsibility (and authority) pretty clear. If the federal government is doing a poor job, the remedy is to vote the bastards out, not subsume a federal obligation. This was made even clearer after the Civil War, because States had attempted to use such authority to disregard federal law regarding anti-foreign-competition tariffs.
- Spooky23 5y agoNo. But there are some complex laws about motor carrier safety, etc. Ultimately Texas benefits greatly from Mexican trade, so even by the dim bulb standard set by modern Texan officials, this is a really stupid measure.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I mean, according to the Supreme Court you can squint your way into justifying almost anything using the commerce clause. Yeah, but actual cross-border trade being an exclusive federal authority isn't one of the squinty bits.
- humanistbot 5y agoThis here is why you shouldn't take legal advice from a tech forum
- shadowgovt 5y agoYou're not wrong. But I'd be very interested to hear the counter argument. I've been trying to chew through the reporting on the topic and I haven't actually found yet what the Governor's justification is for these inspections. The best I can tell is he appears to be lumping them under general public safety authority, which is a paper thin excuse when the thing that he admits we're keeping people safe from is international trafficking. There are vast swathes of public safety that are not the responsibility of a state government.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoYou're talking about a governor who passed legislation that allows private citizens to enforce a criminal statute and financially rewards them for doing so.
- shadowgovt 5y agoAs legal wranglings go, that's quite a bit smarter than just pretending that the supremacy clause and the commerce clause don't exist.
- pandaman 5y agoIANAL but IMHO if the commerce clause prevented states from controlling who,what, and how moves on its roads then it surely had been used already to abolish state licensing and registration for one. Not to mention smog checks, weight stations, California Border Protection Stations etc.
- refurb 5y agoHow is the inter-state (between US states) commerce clause relevant to an international border crossing?
- bluefinity 5y agoHave you read the commerce clause? It's not very long, so I'll post it here: > To regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes;
- refurb 5y agoI was specifically referring to "especially if it's via inspections domestic vehicles don't experience". But fair point, Commerce Clause also has a less well known international aspect, but court cases have indicated that the states do have some ability to control that trade.