3 ms·
With a generous interpretation, they can be said to break classical thermodynamics, since they quantum physics onto the table, most notably magnets can have neg
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
With a generous interpretation, they can be said to break classical thermodynamics, since they quantum physics onto the table, most notably magnets can have negative temperature according to the statistical definition. Nothing that breaks physics at large, but would probably cause Ludwig Boltzmann a mild headache if he heard about it.
It's still not going to allow you to make perpetual motion machines, though.
- pwr-electronics 5y agoWhy would you use a classical model to describe a quantum system? That's the kind of wordplay that those articles do, and almost identical to my example about materials. It's entertaining, but meaningless.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoWell in this case you absolutely can, the results just seem counter to our intuition about temperature. Negative temperature is a meaningful description of these types of systems.
- pwr-electronics 5y agoI'm trying to explain how articles often conflate "intuition" with "breaking physics", and you're making your argument by conflating them. We're having different conversations.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoWhere have I said anything about any of this breaking physics, other than repeatedly clarifying that it doesn't...?
- pwr-electronics 5y ago> With a generous interpretation, they can be said to break classical thermodynamics https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31008263 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31008263
- marginalia_nu 5y agoOperative word being classical. Quantum physics breaks classical physics. Stopped being controversial about a hundred years ago. Thw very same comment specifically states that physics itself is not broken.
- pwr-electronics 5y agoOk, so you're confirming that you're doing exactly what I said popular science articles often do.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoNo I am not. Breaking classical physics is not breaking physics.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pwr-electronics 5y agoI'm running out of ways to explain myself, so I'll just reword and summarize this thread from my perspective: OC: Is it broken? Me: No, they make generous interpretations to claim that it's broken. You: With a generous interpretation, they can be said to break ... Like I said, we're not having the same conversation.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoThis is just sophistry. You're omitting the crucial context of what it is in these sentences, and it is only when this is done they appear contradictory.