10 ms·
Yesterday my friend was trying to take pulse ox measurements on his Apple Watch. After searching on the web, he downloaded an app called Blood Oxygen App, [1] w
by gnicholas 5y ago
Yesterday my friend was trying to take pulse ox measurements on his Apple Watch. After searching on the web, he downloaded an app called Blood Oxygen App, [1] which costs $20/yr. It didn't work without a subscription, it seemed, so he asked me for help. I figured out that the Apple Watch comes with a built-in app called Blood Oxygen (no "App" at the end) that does this for free.
I can't believe Apple let this through their review process. Think of how much money they've made by fooling people into thinking their app is the official Apple app.
https://apps.apple.com/us/app/blood-oxygen-app/id1541992656 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/blood-oxygen-app/id1541992656
- GoodJokes 5y ago
- ARandomerDude 5y agoThink about how much money Apple made by letting this app developer fool people into thinking it was the official app.
- KerrAvon 5y agoThinking about zero dollars. The App Store states the developer name prominently. The graphics look nothing like an official Apple app. It nowhere claims any official anything.
- gnicholas 5y agoI think GP was referring to Apple’s 30% cut (just 15% if this dev is clearing less than $1M annually). Edit: subbed < for >
- RC_ITR 5y agoIt's a fine line to walk and one that I don't think they can sustain for much longer. On one hand, they deny it and the app developer posts a medium sob story about Apple crowding out independent devs. that gets traction on Hacker News. On the other hand, they let it through and this article gets posted. I wonder how heavy the head that wears the crown gets before it's chopped off.
- josephcsible 5y agoThey don't need to walk a fine line. They decided to make a walled garden, but they do a terrible job of moderating it such that there are way too many of both false positives and false negatives.
- duxup 5y agoI doubt it is much compared to Apple's balance sheet. Doesn't seem like a real motivation.
- testbjjl 5y agoDoesn’t App Store utilization by both end users/consumers and perhaps more importantly developers, who make apps for end users, reflect indirectly in the share price? If this were the case, the revenue to app developers in this instance could motivate Apple to not discourage this type of confusion.
- tshaddox 5y agoIf it were a real motivation they could execute it much more effectively by not including their first-party app at all.
- crossroadsguy 5y agoDo you think Apple had that 1 trillion dollars entry in their balance sheet spontaneously appear in one majestic swoop of same sale?
- duxup 5y agoDo you?
- heavyset_go 5y ago> I can't believe Apple let this through their review process. Think of how much money they've made by fooling people into thinking their app is the official Apple app. I can, given that there are multimillion dollar scams on the App Store[1]. Last time I looked, I found about a half dozen Chinese Bonzi Buddy clones on the Mac App Store, as well. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2021/2/8/22272849/apple-app-store-scams-ios-fraud-reviews-ratings-flicktype https://www.theverge.com/2021/2/8/22272849/apple-app-store-s...
- vmception 5y ago> I figured out that the Apple Watch comes with a built-in app called Blood Oxygen (no "App" at the end) that does this for free. Only the latest models, or latest few models, come with the sensor necessary. It was a pandemic feature addition that came too late, just like all their other pandemic feature additions.
- jdavis703 5y agoSure I’d have liked all these features on March 2020. But at least where I live the pandemic is still very much raging on. We still have mask mandates and vaccine passport checks. Having masked FaceID and vaccine passports in the wallet still makes daily life better. And also, the pulse oximeter helps build a better image of overall cardiovascular fitness (basically they can estimate VO2 max). This is important for keeping the body in shape to fight off SARS-2 and whatever comes next (people with cardiovascular problems were more likely to die or be hospitalized.)
- roody15 5y agoWhere is the pandemic currently raging on ?
- goosedragons 5y agoEverywhere? Lots of places have decided to basically ignore it but there's still hundreds of COVID deaths a day in the U.S, China has had Shanghai under lockdown for almost month, lots of 3rd world countries lack vaccines. It's not over by a long shot.
- vmception 5y agoThe person they replied to is subject to mask mandates and vaccine passports So I’m also curious to where they are referring to since the US doesn’t have that combination anywhere I get that you were replying to the semantical words that suggest the pandemic ended
- dimitrios1 5y agoBefore this used to be the norm, there would be at least a quarterly post on HN by some app developer lamenting the fact that Apple killed their business by just releasing an Apple developed version of their app.
- gnicholas 5y agoI don't know for sure, but I assume that Apple's app was released as soon as the functionality was enabled on the relevant devices (Apple Watch 6 and 7). I don't think this is a case of 'Sherlocking'.
- benatkin 5y agoIt's almost like they enjoy hypocrisy, that it's a game for them. It was very much a game when Steve Jobs had his infamous invitations for potential acquisitions that never panned out: https://twitter.com/apartovi/status/1447251334814523392?lang=en https://twitter.com/apartovi/status/1447251334814523392?lang...
- stevage 5y agoWow, that hurt to read.
- ksec 5y agoWhile I think modern Apple is the definition of pure hypocrisy. I honestly dont see how that is hypocrisy from Steve. And I dont see how that is infamous. I actually thought Steve was very polite in replying. Had the decency to give him a straight answer.
- benatkin 5y agoI didn't say it was hypocrisy from Steve, I said it was a game. I think it probably is though - he calls him a liar but I think he misrepresented his offer. He was very unlikely to pony up 50 million for iLike. A good faith offer shouldn't explode like that. Calling someone a liar while you're lying is hypocrisy. But again in the second paragraph I didn't say or imply that he was being a hypocrite. Just that he was playing a game. When I said hypocrisy I was talking about the current app store approval process. Steve Jobs was only involved in that for about 3 years more than a decade ago.
- tapoxi 5y agoI've been using Apple products for almost 30 years (good ol' System 7.5) but this absolute bullshit of user hostility has made me switch to a Pixel 6 most recently. The App Store, the Lightning connector, two huge hassles that only exist to make Apple more money on top of the premium you already paid for the hardware. It's my device! I paid a premium for it!
- noasaservice 5y ago> I paid a premium for it! You sure paid a lot for a rental. You cant even run your own programs on it, unless you pay $100/yr to them IN ADDITION TO "buying" the hardware.
- kemayo 5y agoYou don't actually need to do that. You can use Xcode to put any app you compile onto an iPhone connected to your Mac, regardless of whether you're paying. However, if you're not paying then those apps will only work for 7 days before you have to re-deploy them. I'm not saying this is great. Just that you were wrong. :D (To be fair, this is a fairly recent change. 2019 or so, I think?)
- username190 5y agoI believe you’re limited to 3 apps this way, as well as being limited to 10 App IDs (most popular apps will include multiple App IDs for things like extensions, widgets, etc). If you have the $99/yr Apple Developer account that the user mentioned, those restrictions don’t apply.
- cultofmetatron 5y agois the bar really so low that "need to connect your mac and redeploy the app every 7 days" is acceptable??
- kemayo 5y agoI did say it wasn't great. It's just not as bad as the poster claimed.
- jjtheblunt 5y agoit's because the automation in the review process is a work in progress, given the huge nonstop flow of applications to review
- not1ofU 5y agoYou would think that the non-stop flow of cash apple has at its disposal would be able to offset the issue. I love how apple has everyone so brainwashed that random people just jump to their defence. Do you have some excuses for this? I really would like to hear them :-D LTT Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8IHqntr8FjY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8IHqntr8FjY
- jjtheblunt 5y agoI'm not a random person. I worked in Apple engineering for years, and what I said is factual. Consider how the challenge of reviewing app submissions is an ever evolving game, and you'll see it's genuinely tricky to get right all the time.
- ksec 5y agoYou are suggesting a flaw in review automation, while Apple is telling the world how they have people checking every App submissions.
- jjtheblunt 5y agoif that's so, that's news to me. ?
- not1ofU 5y agoWell apologies for assuming you were a random person. I conceed that reviewing app submissions would be quite challenging, but based on all the screenshots provided in that twitter thread, it doesnt look like any effort at all goes in to screening submissions. I would assume (correct me if I am wrong) that comment reviews would be flagged for inappropriate words, and if this assumption is correct, why not also scan / flag on the word "scam". After which, someone would install the app to a test system, and would immediately see that this is in fact a scam / against the rules, etc., etc., because of the immediate paywall thats presented in these examples. My comment relating to apple brainwashing / jumping to their defence was not so much directed at you, and more directed at, everytime I see a valid complaint, there is always someone that chimes in with, "well thats because of x" (even if x= thats hows its always been done) and I do admit the bit that tripped me into writting a response was "work in progress" from your comment. They make more money than the entire GDP of a few countries, "work in progress" doesnt cut it. As an ex-apple employee, I am even more curious on your thoughts on the video link I posted. Cheers
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- varenc 5y agoI just gave this app a try it doesn't seem like an out-right scam to me. It has 20,000 reviews and plenty of them look like they're written by real humans that actually appreciate the app. The app also works with other bluetooth SpO2 sensors, and I believe that Apple's official "Blood Oxygen" app is only available if you have an Apple Watch! (Though in either case presumably the app is just leveraging iOS's built in functionality?). Also the app seems to focus on data sharing which Apple's Blood Oxygen and Health apps don't provide. There are some 1 star reviews, but they seems mainly from people that are upset this app can't track SpO2 by itself without a watch or other hardware. Also the app works fine without a subscription. It does aggressively prompt you to subscribe when you first open the app so it might not have been clear it was optional. Making this non-obvious is sketchy. Subscribing enables Apple Health syncing, sharing, and stats. There's plenty of out right scams on the App Store but this doesn't seem like one.
- derefr 5y agoIt sounds like you're looking at the iOS app, which may well have a sensible reason to exist. I presume the GP, on the other hand, is talking about an Apple Watch app, which would only be doing something the Apple Watch already does.
- varenc 5y agoThey're the same thing. There's no separate Apple Watch app. This iOS app just has an Apple Watch app component that can be installed on the watch if you have one. So the reviews include both. (I think this is true in general and every Watch app is also an iOS app. You can't even setup an Apple Watch without having an iphone to pair it with.)
- mikeryan 5y agoThere aren’t really Apple Watch apps. Just iOS apps with Watch interfaces
- Tagbert 5y agoHow certain are you that this app doesn’t do more than the free app from Apple?