12 ms·
Apple introduces new version of iMovie featuring Storyboards and Magic Movie
- etchalon 5y agoI love that iMovie just keeps existing.
- Tsiklon 5y agoI think Apple see iMovie and GarageBand as the entry point into funnelling interested users towards Final Cut and Logic Pro when they’re ready to reach for something more capable
- dlivingston 5y agoYou also can’t discount how effective they are as marketing tools to signal “Apple is the computer company for artists and creatives”.
- adammenges 5y agoYeah that’s fair too
- adammenges 5y agoYeah maybe, I think most other companies tho would recognize that all of that is such a small part of their business and cut it off. I’m so happy Apple doesn’t.
- spoonjim 5y agoYes, this is one of the ways Apple succeeds -- by being able to make management decisions like spending money on GarageBand and iMovie that would get cut in any other type of typical Corporate America VP structure.
- rchaud 5y agoSo who made the call to kill iWeb? Or other iLife products that disappeared?
- Angostura 5y agoThey are also the reason that Macs turn up in secondary schools in the UK
- Y-bar 5y agoYup, and I am still a bit salty Apple discontinued Aperture, which was to iPhoto as Final Cut Pro is to iMovie. I am paying for Lightroom Classic and there are still UI idiosyncrasies that makes no sense to me that just clicked in Aperture (Lightroom CC? Let's not even talk about that version...)
- Ancapistani 5y agoMe too. I'm using Lightroom CC, because I'd migrated away from Lightroom Classic several years before. I can't begin to understand why things like "open selected images as layers in Photoshop" _still_ isn't possible in Lightroom CC. It works really well on my iPad Pro, though, and gives me 90%+ of the features I need for my workflow there. I just wish they provided an accessible scripting environment that I could use to automate things.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoWhat stopped you from sticking with Classic or moving to Davinci Resolve?
- c0nsumer 5y agoResolve? How is that a replacement for Lightroom Classic? I've been looking at CaptureOne myself as a replacement...
- modoc 5y agoDo it. CaptureOne is the only thing I've found after Aperture that I like. Still miss Aperture, but CaptureOne is great, and they improve it frequently.
- c0nsumer 5y agoI've been dragging my feet because I Keep getting a friends and family discount on Lightroom Classic from an Adobe employee friend. But I really, really should... If I can also move away from Illustrator for map making, I'll be set. (Read: I really need to spend some time with Affinity Designer to be sure it meets my needs, then just cut the Adobe cord.)
- spoonjim 5y agoNot just Final Cut and Logic Pro, but the Apple ecosystem itself. I've long lusted after Google Pixel's camera quality but the three reasons I will never switch are iMessage, GarageBand, and iMovie. My literal 4 year old son can use iMovie on the iPad and it is a great way for us to construct family memories (I load in the clips and then he decides the order, the music, and the editing)
- cactus2093 5y agoI honestly don't understand their strategy with Final Cut and Logic Pro. These apps can't make very much money, they are a suspiciously good value and they never upsell you on anything. Logic Pro cost like $300 over a decade ago, it still costs $300 today, and all major updates in that time have been free for existing users. Compare that to a competitor like Ableton Live which has cost like $800 since Ableton Suite 8 and major upgrades have come out every 3-5 years and cost a few hundred dollars to upgrade. Or compare it to Pro Tools which now costs $300 for 1 year of a subscription license. So it really doesn't seem like funneling Garage Band users to Logic is a very high priority for Apple. More likely Garage Band and maybe even Logic Pro are loss leaders to show that the mac is a platform for creatives. On a related note I never understood why they killed off Aperture which was beloved by many photographers, why didn't they keep a similar upgrade path from the free Photos app -> Aperture like they did for Garage Band -> Logic Pro? Seems like another indication that they really don't like to be in the pro software business, they are only there reluctantly at this point.
- avar 5y agoIt probably has a small dedicated team, and the sales revenue easily covers their salaries and any overhead. I don't get why niche programs like that within larger companies are the exception.
- jkestner 5y agoThe pro apps are probably paying for themselves, but their purpose is to sell hardware, both directly because you want that functionality, and to serve as a benchmark for other pro apps especially when you have shiny new silicon to take advantage of.
- whazor 5y agoFinal cut pro supposedly has around 2.5 Million users. Many of them buy expensive Macs and other Apple products. The software uses the latest features from Apple's hardware, which gives users an incentive to keep upgrading. I think they keep the software more affordable to attract new (starting out) users. Then eventually they will hopefully go for a Mac studio or something. Another question you could ask: why not make these pro tools free? I am guessing that they are using the income as an internal development budget. Should be sufficient to afford the development I think.
- savoytruffle 5y agoAlas for Aperture
- michelb 5y agoApps like iMovie, pages, numbers etc are ‘required’ to have people switch to the mac, so you don’t have to pay for thirdparty apps to do basic stuff with all your media. It’s really nice that these apps are also quite powerful to the average user. It ties the whole experience together.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoI suspect that iMovie still sells Macs. Maybe not singlehandedly, but it's an important factor. I don't want to say "there's nothing like iMovie available for PC's", because I frankly suspect there is these days—but I don't think there's anything normal people know about in the numbers that know about iMovie.
- sylens 5y agoThey briefly offered Windows Movie Maker and then Windows Live Movie Maker as a free download with Windows Live Essentials. Recently, they acquired Clipchamp and attempted to extract a subscription fee for it if you wanted to export in anything above 480p. It also placed watermarks on the free tier. The resulting outrage forced them to walk it back. https://www.ghacks.net/2022/03/30/clipchamp-free-plan-export-1080p-videos/ https://www.ghacks.net/2022/03/30/clipchamp-free-plan-export...
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoI used both at the time, and Windows (Live) Movie Maker was never anywhere near as good as iMovie.
- sylens 5y agoAgreed but it was something that they gave away for free
- shostack 5y agoCan I work with 2.7k 60fps HEVC videos from my GoPro in it yet? Or is that still busted? I jumped through endless hoops getting DaVinci Resolve's free version setup because I didn't want to degrade my video quality.
- throwmeariver1 5y agoWhat hoops are there to jump through besides the forced registration? It’s a one click installer.
- shostack 5y agoMostly learning curve and time to render optimized previews (considerable). My needs are very lightweight and perfect for the iMovie use case beyond it's inability to handle what I consider not uncommon quality with today's rise of higher resolutions and frame rates.
- ArchOversight 5y agoSounds like you are in the best position to give it a shot and see if it works. You have source material, you have iMove...
- bdlowery 5y agoWhy not just Buy Final Cut Pro or screenflow? I’d rather pay $149 (screenflow) for for a product that just works vs wasting hours of my time trying to get something setup.
- kranke155 5y agoResolve is fine and it’s free. I work in the moving pictures industry and Resolve has been used at some step for 99% of the films you see out there.
- dagmx 5y agoI highly doubt that claim. Most end to end pipelines are still heavily driven by Avid and Final Cut. For smaller ventures, Resolve has gained a lot of traction. Especially for its color workflows. But a claim that the vast majority of films use resolve is highly unlikely IMHO
- lekevicius 5y agoThis is the part of Apple that I love. iLife, enabling creativity with great results out of the box. Even makes me forget, for a second, that they still run a monopoly on kid casino in form of an App Store.
- basisword 5y agoiLife was fantastic. It was the main selling point in convincing me to buy a Mac. When I was younger (before I could afford to buy a Mac) I would watch the iLife updates each year so jealous given the lack of comparative software on Windows at the time. Edit: Just had a flashback to iWeb. That was really great. Such a simple way for a kid to build and publish a website before things like Wix (which are still nowhere near as easy to use).
- breakfastduck 5y agoI remember submitting countless work in school, magazines, websites etc that were all done using iLife. It was so easy to produce stuff that looked fantastic. iWeb in particular was brilliant for kids.
- Fezzik 5y agoEven brilliant for adults: I did my entire professional website in iWeb when I started as a solo attorney back in 2011. I think at that point it had been sunsetted, but I used it for a year and it was amazing. Nothing before or since has been comparable. I wish I still had the files but they are long gone.
- scanr 5y agoIt doesn’t look like it can make vertical videos in the iPhone app yet which is a little disappointing. I’ve been looking for a simple video editing app for a family member who needs to post short form videos to social media. Fortunately there are alternatives. Clips looks pretty good. Other suggestions welcome. Just seems like a useful feature for iMovie to have.
- nobrains 5y ago1) Rotate the video to landscape in Photos app. 2) Import that video in iMovie and do all the editing you need to do. 3) Export the final video. 4) Rotate the final video back to portrait in Photo app.
- smortaz 5y agoyes it’s quite bizarre that key functionalities are split between the built in Editor and iMovie. almost all videos have to be done using both. doing vertical videos + text is very awkward.
- savolai 5y agoWow, this is the one feature I expected would be the raison d’être for an update of iMovie. Now it's still useless. That's really odd.
- armadsen 5y agoLumaFusion is the obvious step up from iMovie. It's much more powerful than iMovie, but aims to also be very approachable for complete beginners. Disclaimer: My day job is as an engineer working on LumaFusion.
- uuyi 5y agoI love how Apple just releases these things out of the blue. If it was Microsoft they’d be crowing about it loudly on blogs for 6 months before then underdeliver a broken pile of crap.
- seabriez 5y agoThis has been on Windows since like Windows 8. Probably before that since I haven't been tracking it. But I remmember I used to make these types of movies with storyboards years ago.
- lostgame 5y agoiMovie is not on Windows. AFAIK it has never been, unlike Logic.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoI suspect you're thinking of Windows (Live) Movie Maker. It's nice in a pinch but it's no iMovie.
- haunter 5y agoI don't get this unnecessary flak against MS? Like what's the point? Totally not relevant, they don't even have a similar product on the level of iMovie
- n8cpdx 5y agoWere you not burned by the many iterations of Windows Live Movie Maker? It was a 16-year product. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Movie_Maker https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Movie_Maker Here’s Microsoft’s Windows blog post about ClipChamp, their latest attempt: https://blogs.windows.com/windows-insider/2022/03/09/announcing-windows-11-insider-preview-build-22572/ https://blogs.windows.com/windows-insider/2022/03/09/announc...
- uuyi 5y agoThey did. And they kept rewriting it, reimagining it and breaking it every damn release.
- gnicholas 5y agoFYI: iPhone/iPad only, not MacOS. I have tried editing movies on my mobile devices in the past but the experience was never great. Even just trimming a clip in Photos is difficult with the touch interface.
- xnx 5y agoAfter trying ~10 different Android apps (all of them pretty bad), I've been very pleased with CapCut (from Tiktok).
- uuyi 5y agoI’m using lumafusion on my iPad Pro without any problems.
- wenc 5y agoThanks for the recommendation. I’ve used iMovie for years for simple movie editing on my iPad but recently I found myself needing something just a tiny bit more sophisticated. I just bought Luma Fusion ($40) and so far it feels intuitive but I can already tell it has more controls than iMovie — the ones I wished iMovie had (like quick audio fixes and equalizer). This is super useful because I can’t run Audacity on an iPad and sometimes I just need quick audio fixes done.
- armadsen 5y agoI'm an engineer on LumaFusion, and one of my specialities is audio. If you run into things that could be better, let us know. support@luma-touch.com (real humans read every email, we're a small team).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mattl 5y agoiMovie 3.0 for Mac OS X came out almost 20 years ago. iMovie for Mac OS X is 10.3 now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- torstenvl 5y agoThis is great and all, but it's been years and I'm still waiting for rebooted QuickTime to catch up to QuickTime 7 Pro.
- galad87 5y agoIt mostly did. It can open image sequences, trim, cut, export, merge, remove audio or video tracks, display the timecode track. Cutting a piece of a movie is a bit cumbersome, but it can be done (move to the first time, edit -> split clip, move to a second time and split again, and then delete the clip in the "show clip" mode).
- djxfade 5y agoIt's a shame it doesn't support third party codecs anymore. That makes it almost useless for all but a few supported formats.
- whatever1 5y agoWho is the target user for this? All video editing happens within the TikTok app nowadays.
- zitterbewegung 5y agoApple will probably add more and more features to iMovie than porting over Final Cut Pro.
- laurent92 5y agoMaybe Youtubers, as soon as you want to do something barely elaborate. Sometimes free tools don’t benefit the user, but their audience ;)
- killerdhmo 5y agoWould it surprise you to know that not everyone is editing or making (or even consuming) TikTok videos?
- vimy 5y ago> Availability iMovie 3.0, including the new Storyboards and Magic Movie features, is available today as a free update on the App Store for devices running iOS 15.2 or later and iPadOS 15.2 or later. Not for Mac?
- Shadonototra 5y agoYou can run iOS/iPad apps natively on every Mac since the switch to ARM
- Synaesthesia 5y agoThere’s a Mac version though.
- janandonly 5y agoI wondered this morning why my MacBook said there was an upgrade... Now i know.
- dmarcos 5y agoApple has been always about empowering creatives. They have world-class camera hardware and editing software. It always made sense to me that at some point they would close the circle and try to compete against YouTube. They instead went with Apple TV+ that feels more like yet another streaming platform and doesn't leverage many of other Apple's strengths and costumer base. Apple seems to have low tolerance for content they cannot tightly control. YouTube reactive style curation and permission-less publication probably feels alien and scary to them.
- foobarian 5y ago> YouTube reactive style curation and permission-less publication probably feels alien and scary to them. Now that you put it this way, I'd bet no established enterprise would have what it takes to start something like YouTube now. Heck I doubt even Google would be able to given the amount of "doing things by the book" these kinds of orgs require.
- spoonjim 5y agoApple stands for a tightly curated user experience overall. Want that weird app? No. Want user-generated content? No. Want to isntall some weird software to make your home screen swipe up-and-down rather than left-to-right? No. For desktop computing I would find it frustrating (and use a Windows box with a ton of malware/weirdware on it) but for my phone I prefer it this way.
- dagmx 5y agoI don't think Apple has any interest in social networks (and that's effectively what YouTube is these days) The risk to reward ratio for the brand itself is not something they'd want to undertake. You see it all the time with other tech stories. If Apple does something bad or is even associated with something bad, that is standard across other tech companies too, the news articles will focus on Apple. Imagine that with user posted comments. Google can get away with it because they have YouTube under a separate brand, and they've established that it's looser. Apple would never want to do it as a separate brand if they can help it (beats and FileMaker not withstanding because they existed prior) and the amount of vitriol that the brand would receive over any contentious content would negate any benefit.
- freecodyx 5y agoI personally use apple keynotes to produce videos. It’s a powerful tool, and just yesterday i was wondering why imovie was lacking so much features. And that is what i like about apple, they target consumers, not professionals
- auggierose 5y agoIs there a good way to blend in your face during a slideshow? I am using a third-party app for that now, and then use QuickTime Player to record the screen. It works, but it is a little bit more convoluted than I expected.
- killerdhmo 5y agoLive Video? https://support.apple.com/guide/keynote/add-live-video-tan6a7b90433/mac https://support.apple.com/guide/keynote/add-live-video-tan6a...
- auggierose 5y agoOops :-D I gotta check that out!
- llampx 5y agoKeynote is basically a Powerpoint competitor, right? How do you use it to produce videos?
- alsetmusic 5y agoJust in time for a video project I’ve been considering. Oh, wait… for iPad and iPhone. Not at all how I want to cut together ~100 video files stored on my Mac and NAS. C’mon, Apple… When people diagnose Apple’s software business as wilting, that’s no joke.
- scyzoryk_xyz 5y agoWell, you could just do a YT tutorial and do it with DaVinci Resolve. Apple is clearly thinking about the kind of user here who doesn’t know what a “Mac with NAS” is. Someone who maybe doesn’t even know how to get video files from their iOS device into their Mac.
- killerdhmo 5y agoiMovie exists on a Mac? And there's Final Cut Pro?
- jackomelon 5y agoThese features probably aren't for you and your use case, and that's okay.
- Synaesthesia 5y agoiPads and iPhones have pretty good video processing performance.
- olah_1 5y agoThe old Windows Movie Maker was the best. So straightforward. No nonsense trying to “help” you. Just give me a basic timeline system please!
- lesgobrandon 5y ago
- npunt 5y agoThe cool part about iMovie and Garageband is they're basically a more approachable UI layer to Final Cut Pro and Logic Pro. They share a lot of the same core code, and teach you the same concepts just without the fiddly pro bits. I love that bifurcation because it really makes the pro apps more approachable without compromising their usefulness (pro apps require info density, consumer apps avoid it), and it allows their power be scaled down to iPhone and iPad. I wish more software was made this way!
- doctorhandshake 5y agoAs a longtime user of various pro apps in these categories - AE, Premiere, Final Cut, DVR, as well as ProTools, Digital Performer, Logic, etc, all of which share a lot of UX paradigms that make it relatively easy to switch between them, I find the type of simplification at work in iMovie and Garage Band makes them almost unrecognizable, stymieing my ability to use them at all almost every time I try.
- scarecrowbob 5y agoI started in Sony Vegas back around the turn of the century and share your enjoyment of the standardized UI paradigms of professional software. It's great to be able to pick ups something like Davinci Resolve and just know what I can do and find the 10 keyboard shortcuts I want and then get to work, just because I learned Ae and Premiere a decade and a half ago. I also share your frustration with iMovie and garageband... I can't get a damn thing done in GB and I've tried several times. It's like the CLI: I already know exactly what I want to do, and I have an understanding of how the computer is going to deal with it. These apps feel like trying to drive a car with an iPhone app. However, I work with a lot of non-professionals and they love these tools. So more power to them. I remember using logic back when I started 20-something years ago and had no idea baout how MIDI worked. I remember being able to actually have fun getting things done in fruity loops or rebirth. I'm glad there are tools out there which are nerf'd up for the beginners.
- npunt 5y agoIt's hard to go back to Duplo once you know Lego. Curse of knowledge.
- yubiox 5y agoiMovie is impossible to figure out (it was easy many years ago then they ruined it). How about a simple app to let me trim and splice video and add audio? And a simple way to export, but not so simple that the choices are youtube and something else. Just export at whatever resolution I choose. And don't put stupid intros, outros, and transitions unless I ask for them.
- alephnan 5y ago> how about a simple app to let me trim and splice video and add audio? And a simple way to export, but not so simple that the choices are youtube and something else. Just export at whatever resolution I choose. And don't put stupid intros, outros, and transitions unless I ask for them. That's literally iMovie.
- BSOhealth 5y agoAnyone have any experience or anecdotes on the extent to which Apple has Product Managers working on its in-house software? And what sort of overlap or collaboration happens between products and teams? Is it a fun gig? As a PM, I would love to work at Apple. If I were looking at open job descriptions, should I expect them to call out specific apps I’d be working on?
- shp0ngle 5y agoJust for fun. This is an ad for first iMovie released, from 2000. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9oIjd5qsvZo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9oIjd5qsvZo