5 ms·
The best cure for inflation is to increase taxes. This removes money from the economy, and can be targeted towards the areas of the economy with too much money
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
The best cure for inflation is to increase taxes. This removes money from the economy, and can be targeted towards the areas of the economy with too much money.
Raising interest rates paid to the Fed are another way of removing money from the economy, but are a broader brush, although the Fed is a much better steward than Congress. Increased interest rates cause stock market declines, so they also tend to act as a wealth tax.
Cutting spending is another way, but it's slow acting. It's more of "don't make things worse" than attacking the core problem of "too much money".
So if you hear somebody screaming about inflation, ask them if they support increased taxes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoSo if the money I have is worth less, your response is to take away more of my money? Yeah, that may work to stop inflation. It may have a few other consequences, though...
- bryanlarsen 5y agoAll inflation cures are painful. The standard cure is recession and high unemployment. Increasing taxes on the rich is much less painful. Better to take a little bit of your money away than to lose your job. Or you can learn to live with the inflation. Rock and a hard place is the standard expression for the situation we're in.
- chillacy 5y agoI’m curious what the mechanism for reducing inflation is when taxing the rich? Here are my assumptions: 1. Inflation is a function of monetary supply, the velocity of money, and available goods. 2. The rich contribute less to the velocity of money (since they tend to save or drive up asset prices) than the poor
- carlgreene 5y agoI scream about inflation and I do not support increased taxes. The US government is wildly inefficient with the tax dollars I already give them. Until they can show some discretion I'll tell them to kick rocks whenever there's a tax increase on the ballot.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoSo given the choice between recession, increased taxes or inflation you choose recession? That's a valid choice, as long as you acknowledge it.
- _-david-_ 5y agoBelieve it or not those are not the only options. Plus the government isn't going to just take the money out of circulation so it won't really fix anything.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoWhat are the other options? Raising interest rates substantially usually causes a recession, balanced budgets always cause a recession.
- _-david-_ 5y agoYou will need to provide some evidence to your claims. There is another choice though, stop printing money for a while.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThe proof is easy, look at the times the US has had balanced budgets and then look for recessions following a year or so later. Works all the way back to Andrew Jackson's time. As for stopping printing money, the Fed did that last summer.
- vorpalhex 5y agoHow does increasing taxes bring down fertilizer, meat, gas and housing?
- bryanlarsen 5y agoIt doesn't work against transitory, sectoral inflation, no. But HN consensus and the top comment here insist that the inflation is general and permanent.
- vorpalhex 5y agoHow does raising taxes help against permanent inflation?
- csomar 5y agoIt doesn't. The OP is confusing MMT where monetary policy is controlled through fiscal policy; and the current state of affairs where they are separate. Collecting more taxes will raise prices, lower your purchasing ability and help the government carry on in reckless spending.
- jl2718 5y agoYou’d think so, but, actually the opposite. Tax collection pays the interest on the debt. Higher taxes means more debt load. The government, like any modern public company, does not care about profit. They operate to maximize cash flow. Income is from taxes, but most cash flow comes from debt leveraged on that income. More income, more debt. Less income, less debt.