4 ms·
The Lewis and Clark expedition is a topic that I find fascinating but because Lewis and Clark and everyone involved seem a bit enigmatic as people they don't se
by duxup 5y ago
The Lewis and Clark expedition is a topic that I find fascinating but because Lewis and Clark and everyone involved seem a bit enigmatic as people they don't seem to get the historical movies, mini series and etc you might expect.
The fact that they spent nearly 3 years traveling in the wilderness so far from the civilization they knew / into a fair amount of unknown is fascinating to me. Something you can't really do anymore.
Their reliance on laxatives is fairly amusing / interesting. Granted, would maybe not include that in a movie...
- dr-detroit 5y ago
- beart 5y agoYes, particularly when you consider how different the landscape must have been before it was settled and deforested.
- pramsey 5y agoIt was already settled, just not by white folk. In fact that would be another whole aspect of the adventure. Over each rise a whole new culture, which may or may not welcome or tolerate you.
- beart 5y agoGood point, that was a poor choice of language on my part.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ncmncm 5y agoNotably, before smallpox wiped out most of the North American population, the continent was largely deforested. Deliberately. Bison ranged to Louisiana. The "little ice age" after ~1500 is suspected to have been caused by the pulse of reforestation, and thus dip in carbon dioxide, occasioned by the disappearance of the long-time stewards of open range land. In the 14th century, a very large expedition west from Africa is documented, with likelihood part of it reached South America. (One ship was separated and returned, reporting fresh water out of sight of land, suggestive of Amazon outflow.) There is ecological evidence of pre-Columbian disruption in Amazonia thereafter.
- starkd 5y agoThe use of mercury laxatives may make for a rather funny scene though. Much like the scene in Blazing Saddles where they are sitting around a campfire eating beans. Not that Lews&Clark expedition would make a great comedy.
- Tao331 5y agoConsidering they started calling them "Thunder Clappers", they must have found it entertaining to some extent.
- HideousKojima 5y ago>Not that Lews&Clark expedition would make a great comedy. Speak for yourself, this was Chris Farley's last movie: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almost_Heroes https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almost_Heroes
- nukemaster 5y ago>Something you can't really do anymore. People seem to do this sort of thing pretty often in the Arctic. There's a lot more empty space than some people think.
- thwayunion 5y agoIn the strictest sense, OP is of course correct. In the age of global satellite coverage, nothing is unknown in quite the same way as the west was to Lewis and Clark. > People seem to do this sort of thing pretty often in the Arctic. The arctic is a different beast. It is impossible to survive for long in the arctic without either a supply chain or substantial reserves, and expeditions can last for at most a season. However, the United States has a lot more empty public land than people seem to realize. Even in the densely populated Northeast, you can walk into the White Mountains or Adirondacks without a map, leave the trail, and probably spend years exploring in a mostly self-sufficient manner. Especially if you commit to turning back whenever you encounter people or trails. And that's to say nothing of the west or the great deserts. Just because a map exists and trails are cut doesn't mean you have to acknowledge their existence. Remember: Lewis and Clark, for the most part, were traversing already inhabited land.
- RajT88 5y agoThere was a show made about modern people living sort of like this: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5360318/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5360318/
- duxup 5y agoNot really going to get the same experience spending nearly 3 years in the Arctic.
- tshaddox 5y agoGrowing up in Missouri there was no shortage of Lewis and Clark namesakes, memorials, material taught in school, etc. Granted, I would expect a disproportionate amount of that stuff in Missouri because the expedition began there and traveled along the river the state is named after, and Missouri has a big cultural focus on westward expansion (see the Gateway Arch). Still, my impression was always that their expedition is a staple of American cultural history.
- Ccecil 5y agoNorth Idaho here. We have Lewiston, ID and Clarkston, WA is just across the river. Tons of references to them around here too. Also, The Mullan trail came through here...so we have a lot of stuff named after that expedition As well as the French trappers and Jesuit priests...
- majormunky 5y agoI live in Hayden waves I was just thinking that this area also seems to have a bunch of references to Lewis and Clark.
- thwayunion 5y agoThere are regions of the country where Lewis and Clark are taught in some detail (e.g., Missouri). However, even in those regions, surprisingly little is taught about the actual details of their expedition. The story is mostly told as one of naturalists and cartographers, with some passing mention of native peoples. A "grand adventure in the wilderness" sort of narrative is what I recall from school. If you read the actual journals, two things stick out. First, the expedition was mostly boring. Second, the fact that the west was populated is difficult to miss. The expedition was almost more about establishing trade and diplomatic relations with existing civilizations than about discovering and charting virgin lands. I wonder if one reason that L&C aren't studied more widely is that the happy version of the story is mostly boring ("we made a map and documented fauna") and the more complex/detailed/interesting version of the story makes abundantly clear the extraordinary scope of the Manifest Destiny genocide.
- samatman 5y agoThe correct word here is culture. Civilizations are cultures which have cities, as the etymology indicates. The Americas had several indigenous civilizations, including one in Missouri, but that was gone several centuries before Lewis and Clark (most likely culprit being the first wave of smallpox), and the expedition didn't encounter any. It's also true that civilized is used as a term of praise, and uncivilized is really only used as a term of disparagement, but these are connotations, and not ones I intend here.
- thwayunion 5y agoThe large nations had systems of what the US Army referred to as "settlements" whose size and complexity were perceived as serious threats. Some of the nations comprised of those settlements were even referred to explicitly as civilizations when they assimilated. Maybe "settlements" don't count as cities; the whole thing is a bit pedantic to me. But, in any case, "culture" is too weak a term for the complex social systems, political systems, and living patterns that existed during the time of L&C.
- mountainb 5y agoThere's a gargantuan amount of professional scholarship on it.
- pugworthy 5y ago| Something you can't really do anymore. In a virtual kind of way, you can do this in Minecraft. I play on a private server with a group of seasoned high tech types, and we have a tendency to explore very far from civilization (as it were). It’s a dangerous process fraught with peril, but if you can get back to civilization with the maps you make along the way, there is great benefit to the other players.
- vorpalhex 5y agoYou can do this in real life. Obviously you aren't going to be as far from civilization but there are plenty of real places to explore quite alone for days or weeks. It is worth doing, but start small.
- adxl 5y agohttps://www.pbs.org/show/lewis-clark/ https://www.pbs.org/show/lewis-clark/ A superb account.