2 ms·
The entire source code of Ardour is posted on the Internet. Nevertheless, it has no known bad-intent copies, and generates more than US $200k/yr. It is also the
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
The entire source code of Ardour is posted on the Internet. Nevertheless, it has no known bad-intent copies, and generates more than US $200k/yr. It is also the basis of two products generally viewed as "commercial", even though they are also GPL-licensed.
Almost all of the source code of VCV Rack is posted on the Internet. There have been a few forks for specific reasons, but it's almost certainly the most widely used software modular synthesis in existence, and has created both a paying job for its creator and a mixed libre/paid ecosystem for module developers.
The entire source code of Vital, one of the most acclaimed software synthesizers of 2021 is posted on the Internet. The author (Matt Tytel) makes a living from his work.
The definition of commercial might be a little wider than you think.
Finally, there are several ways to use SC in a product that do not involve the GPL. You fire up sclang as a separate process, feed it SC code, and sclang controls the server. Nothing you write is linked to anything GPL licensed.
- iainctduncan 5y agoPaul, I am very happy to hear that Ardour is succeeding in supporting you. While I'm not really using Linux these days for audio as I'm doing my Scheme in Max stuff now, your contributions were very influential to me back in the oughts when I was, and I remember learning a lot from your posts on various linux audio forums. It's heartwarming to know that the work is succeeding in making a good lifestyle business for you. :-)
- iainctduncan 5y agoSo is one of those Harrison MixBus? It would be nice to hear that worked out. What's the other? (or both if I'm wrong on the first count)
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoMixbus is one, Waves Tracks Live is the other (but is now discontinued, for reasons largely unrelated to the product itself).
- NateEag 5y agoI'm glad to hear Ardour is working well for you. I honestly had assumed it wouldn't be making much income, though I now realize that was based on just about no information (the sole data point I had was that it worked poorly for me when I attempted a trial on macOS about two years ago). I'm glad to hear I was mistaken about that. I wasn't aware that VCV Rack was actually profitable either, nor that there's a mixture of libre and paid modules available for it. I'd vaguely considered that as a business model for OSS audio stuff in years past but didn't think it was likely to work in practice. Apparently I may be wrong about that - do you know if anyone's actually making decent income selling closed modules for VCV Rack? You make a good point about running sclang as a standalone process to firewall the GPL from the rest of a product. Somehow that hadn't occurred to me, but it seems like it would work. Overall - thanks for the rebuttal. You make a strong case that open source audio software is more compatible with commercial sales than I thought, and I appreciate you taking the time to do it.