4 ms·
Surely some sex/gender education is required and appropriate for this age group. Things like consent/personal space etc are useful and important for kids of any
by Gigachad 5y ago
Surely some sex/gender education is required and appropriate for this age group. Things like consent/personal space etc are useful and important for kids of any age. Would be much more logical to have some kind of standard education program for the topic.
- avs733 5y agoYou are obviously and logically correct. The obviousness is exactly the point of the law because it creates vagueness. It’s just another right wing attack on public schools.
- _skzr 5y agoThere is no reason for you or anyone else to talk about my 6 year old’s genitalia with him. Our desire to keep you from talking to our kids about their junk is a right wing attack?
- avs733 5y agoIt’s very strange that people want to conflate genitalia and you know…like pronouns? There’s actually lots of good reasons, including proper hygiene, helping children understand consent, privacy, boundaries. But you’ve made a choice in how to frame the conversation that is designed to eliminate any need to learn…I can’t help you there but demands of ignorance shouldn’t be how we legislate.
- drooby 5y agoFWIW, my school provided basic sexual anatomy and puberty eduction (basic biology stuff) in 5th grade. We then had a “health class” in middle school (grades 6-8), which explored sexual orientation and safe sex practice. This all felt very appropriate. 3rd grade feels a bit young to start with sexual anatomy and puberty tbh Consent and personal space are separate subjects that probably aren’t prohibited under this new law.
- 99_00 5y agoYou are conflating three related but different things: sex education, gender education, and consent/personal space. The bill forbids only one of those three things, sexual orientation or gender identity.
- dragonwriter 5y agoThat's aspects of two of the three things you listed, not only one.
- rich_sasha 5y agoMy daughter has a great book, "Dear Girl" - phrased like a sort-of sequence of mini-letters to my "dear girl" with various little nuggets: it's great to ask questions, it's ok to be different, be brave and so on. One of the pages says, "if something feels wrong, just say no, that's OK". Similarly, that's not in this book, but we teach her it's OK if a family has "two daddies", or frankly any configuration, and so on. That it's less common but it's normal. I consider that appropriate sex ed for a n-year old, n<=5 or so. Surely, surely, there is a tier for 5 < n <= 10. Clearly, not "here's how you do doggie style with 4 people while allowing for BDSM tendencies". But the world is so saturated with sex you can barely buy bread without bumping into it. If we're not teaching kids, well, anything in this space, they'll just learn off school corridor banter and any glimpses of porn their older friends will show them.