3 ms·
"One of his colleagues who invests heavily in the Web3 space had bought a digital asset in a Web3 game that is yet to be released. This game will likely be simi
by Animats 5y ago
"One of his colleagues who invests heavily in the Web3 space had bought a digital asset in a Web3 game that is yet to be released. This game will likely be similar to the Sims—a life simulation video game—that will allow players to own virtual assets that they interact with. For owning these assets, players get paid the equivalent of rent or dividends in cryptocurrencies."
There are way too many of those scams. See r/metaverse-blockchain for a few new ones every day. Most of them selling "land" don't actually have a working virtual world, but are selling anyway. Many of those future virtual worlds were supposed to go live by Q1 2022. It's now Q2 2022.
Report them to the SEC if they sell to Americans. If you're selling something that doesn't exist yet, you're buying an investment contract, which is supposed to be registered as a public securities offering. The SEC brings the hammer down on about two "cyber" scams per month. They're still working through the Initial Coin Offering backlog from 2018-2019.
- adamsmith143 5y agoSerious question. If I sell you a Dresser that I haven't built yet, is this an Investment Contract too?
- stormbrew 5y agoDid you tell the person you're selling it to that they'll be able to make 10x what they paid on it in a year as part of your pitch?
- adamsmith143 5y agoNope but if I did it still wouldn't make the point. I've bought Gold from dealers who will tell you it's going to the moon straight to your face, doesn't make it an investment contract. Ferrari dealer might tell you this model is going to be a classic worth 10x in 20 years, doesn't make it an investment contract. Real estate agent will tell you to your face that this home will appreciate 20% in 5 years, doesn't make it an investment contract. If all you had to do was say this thing will be more valuable in the future then half the commerce in the US would count as an investment contract.
- stormbrew 5y agoThe gold is already dug up. The ferrari is already built (even if it's not, like it's got custom features or w/e, they're going to build it whether you give them money or not because that's what they do). Real estate is a heavily regulated market precisely because it's an investment. None of these are like either the web3 nonsense or your hypothetical with my caveat added on. If you're offering to build something with someone else's money and you sell it to them as something that will grow in value over time, that is exactly selling someone an investment. And the fact that it sometimes happens without triggering regulatory oversight doesn't mean it's not in that category, it just means sometimes people casually break the law (which is true anyways).
- adamsmith143 5y ago>The gold is already dug up. The ferrari is already built (even if it's not, like it's got custom features or w/e, they're going to build it whether you give them money or not because that's what they do). Real estate is a heavily regulated market precisely because it's an investment. The gold might not even be in bar form yet, just a pile of gold ore dust. Ferarri is definitely not just building cars willy nilly. Real estate is 100% not considered a security. Yes it is regulated but so is the Banana industry, doesn't mean they are investments. >And the fact that it sometimes happens without triggering regulatory oversight doesn't mean it's not in that category Happy to be proven wrong if you provide the relevant SEC guidance but I highly doubt investments are categorized in the way you suggest. To be clear I despise NFTs and think most of the crypto space is fraudulent but I think you've created a strawman here.
- stormbrew 5y agoWell, you've moved the goalposts a couple of times so I'm not sure where I'm even getting the straw from. I'm not sure what to tell you if you think all of these are the same category of transaction: - selling someone "virtual land" that doesn't exist yet, and won't until and unless they obtain sufficient investment to build it (my understanding of the original thing), - someone commissioning you to build a dresser for them (what you initially said -- this is not a security, I agree, hence...), - you selling someone a promise of a dresser that will increase in value if they pay you to build it (my proposed change to your scenario to align it more closely to the original thing -- this is indeed, deliberately, a strawman intended to align your argument with the thing we're actually talking about), - buying gold that already exists, whatever form it's in, assuming the person you're buying it from already has it and doesn't have to mine it (the strawman to again align this with the original thing would be that they have to mine it -- I'm pretty sure this would be considered an investment into a mining operation), - buying an expensive car that is, bar some minor customizations, like every other car of the same model in existence and that the company has already invested in building, - real estate (just completely different from all of these, but my point was just that it's not a standard purchase and has its own structure around it. That said, there are real estate-related securities so...) Anyways, Animats seems more familiar with the specific legalities of this so I'll leave that to them. I never claimed to have a perfect understanding of US securities law, I just found your counter-example disingenuous.