3 ms·
Absolutely his murders invalidate his manifesto. The ideas that he expressed in the manifesto are the same ideas that moved him to murder people. His oppositi
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
Absolutely his murders invalidate his manifesto. The ideas that he expressed in the manifesto are the same ideas that moved him to murder people. His opposition to technology is why he was bombing computer stores and the University of Utah Engineering Building.
This is why saying "but he's a murderer" isn't an ad hominem. His murders are the working-out of his ideas; his ideas are worth rejecting just on that basis.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThat doesn't mean they are wrong in part or in whole. >His murders are the working-out of his ideas; his ideas are worth rejecting just on that basis. This is simply saying "if he is right, I would rather be wrong". It also completely ignores that arguments can be valid in part, but not in combination.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoMost of us consider murder to be self-evidently wrong. The intersection of "right, and causing murder" is very close to empty for most definitions of "right". Your question makes me wonder what your definition of "right" is.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoMurder is typically defined as unjustifiable or wrong, so you would expect the set to be empty. Replace "murder" with 'killing" and most people will have the opposite reaction.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago>>>> I don't think his murders invalidate his manifesto. - colinmhayes (the original post I responded to). And, for your point to be relevant to this discussion, you would have to claim that what the Unabomber did was "killing" rather than "murder". If you claim that, I'd like to see your definitions and where you think the line between killing and murder is. And if that isn't your claim, it looks like you're just arguing in order to argue.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI have no interest in defending the actions of the Unabomber. I did feel that you were using the tautology of murder to ignore my actual point. >You: His murders are the working-out of his ideas; his ideas are worth rejecting just on that basis. >Me: That doesn't mean they are wrong in part or in whole. If the unabomber said as part of the manifesto that the sky is blue, would you now reject that the sky is blue? There is nothing about murder that invalidates the logic, truth, or accuracy of an argument, and especially not the individual components of an argument. It is fine and fair if you don't personally want to learn or engage with an argument that has lead to violence. But that does not mean that it is internally inconsistent, or devoid of accurate observations about the world (e.g. new technologies can impose externalities on the unwilling).
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoWhether the sky is blue has no moral component. The Unabomber was saying 1) what he thought was wrong with society, and 2) how we should make a better society. These judgments ("wrong" and "better") presuppose some definition of "good". But the guy was deliberately killing people. Am I supposed to believe his definition of what "good" is? No, I'm supposed to suspect that it's seriously skewed. (In fact, he's giving me evidence that it's seriously skewed.) There's something about murder that invalidates the moral truth of an argument. Could his argument still be internally consistent? Sure. Could it have accurate observations? Also sure. But should his manifesto be regarded as having any overall validity? No. (Recall that the original point I was replying to was whether his murders invalidated his manifesto.)
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI think we might just have to agree to disagree. I feel that you view his acts of murder as inseparably linked to the manifesto, and that people can not accept manifesto to be true, while condemning the murders. This ignores the possibility of a completely pacifist implementation of the manifesto's ideals. My understanding is that a significant portion of it is not necessarily a call to violence, as much as a call to action. It states the technology and collectivism should be rejected, and this could be either a violent or non-violent process.