5 ms·
Health insurance is not tied to employment status. Anyone can go to healthcare.gov and buy an equivalent BCBS or Kaiser or whatever gold/silver/bronze insuranc
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
Health insurance is not tied to employment status. Anyone can go to healthcare.gov and buy an equivalent BCBS or Kaiser or whatever gold/silver/bronze insurance. Unless you are in a particularly shitty state.
What employers do have is the ability to sell you health insurance with pre tax dollars, which is also available to self employed individuals. But the people who are screwed are those who are employed by employers that do not offer health insurance. They have to buy insurance with post tax dollars.
There is similar bullshit with retirement funding, where employer sponsored retirement account limits are drastically more than individual ones (401k vs IRA), and especially if you are a married couple with 1 spouse with 401k access and one spouse without.
- kaesar14 5y agoThis just feels like a ‘well ackshually’ retort to health insurance being tied to employment. This is an extra added expense and often times the barebones insurance is garbage with high deductibles and out of pocket maximums.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoHow is it an “extra added expense”? Just because you do not pay for 50% of the premium out of your own pocket directly does not mean you are not paying implicitly. Your employer is obviously counting it in the total cost of employing you, and the figure is given to you in box 12 code DD on your W-2. You can also buy a platinum level BCBS health plan yourself, without an employer, and get the same low deductible and low oop max. https://www.healthcare.gov/choose-a-plan/plans-categories/ https://www.healthcare.gov/choose-a-plan/plans-categories/ It is evident then that health insurance is NOT tied to employment. Buying it with pre tax dollars is tied to the type of employer you have. NJ has a very nice pdf where you can basically see how much your insurance will cost based on your age and level do coverage you want: https://www.state.nj.us/dobi/division_insurance/ihcseh/ihcrates2022.pdf https://www.state.nj.us/dobi/division_insurance/ihcseh/ihcra...
- nebula8804 5y ago>Health insurance is not tied to employment status. Anyone can go to healthcare.gov and buy an equivalent BCBS or Kaiser or whatever gold/silver/bronze insurance. Unless you are in a particularly shitty state. Out of curiosity, I went and looked up the plans in NJ for a 32 year old person(56k salary). This is someone in a lower risk pool. The bronze plans are in the upper ~280$/month and include a $6000 deductible. There are three plans out of 36 that are ~380 a month that have a $2500 deductible. Everything else is more. This is NJ, one of the better states and definitely not a shitty state. These plans are garbage. Every time someone on HN extols the virtues of Healthcare.gov, I recheck my options and they always come back much worse than what I get working for a private employer (typical S&P 500 corp). I wish people would look up their possible plans on Healthcare.gov before tossing it out as something other than a scam.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhat does box 12 code DD on your W-2 say? Your employer is probably just paying a lot for your coverage. When I got quotes for insuring my employees in NJ, they all matched up with the premiums on healthcare.gov, also seen here: https://www.state.nj.us/dobi/division_insurance/ihcseh/ihcrates2022.pdf https://www.state.nj.us/dobi/division_insurance/ihcseh/ihcra... ACA compliant health insurance pricing is pretty commodified since all the rating factors are codified in law (age, location, smoking status, and that is it I think). Edit: >These plans are garbage The plans simply reflect the cost of healthcare. The companies that sell the healthcare have profit margins in the sub 5% range. Mechanisms to bring the cost down would be to have taxpayer funded medicine in the public domain so the medicine is sold without patent, increasing number of doctors by greatly expanding residency positions and reducing training requirements so that you can start practicing before age 28, reducing the need for "certificates of need" so more hospitals can open and compete, etc.
- LordDragonfang 5y ago> The plans simply reflect the cost of healthcare. Anyone who works in healthcare and looks at billing can tell you this is not actually the case, prices are not based on any reasonable metric and are rarely actually paid by insurers anyway. >The companies that sell the healthcare have profit margins in the sub 5% range. Point of contention here, these companies aren't selling healthcare, they're reselling it. Which is a service which should ideally not have any profit margins, and would be best suited for a large, collective entity that everyone paid into according to their financial ability, as opposed to smaller social-class exclusive pools.
- CameronNemo 5y agoIt is still a headache to have to register for a plan after losing your job and possibly transfer/link your information to a new account. COBRA is better than nothing, but it is often more expensive than makes sense. Furthermore you cannot use the exchanges if your employer offers plans IIRC. So your employer can control which plans you have access to. The subsidies should just be given directly to the person who needs healthcare. There is no need to involve a third party. It just complicates the situation for no gain.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> Furthermore you cannot use the exchanges if your employer offers plans IIRC. So your employer can control which plans you have access to. I do not think this is true. Everyone can sign up on healthcare.gov. Employers will want you to opt into the subsidized plans they offer, especially if you are a lower compensated employee, in order to pass their non discrimination testing requirements, but they have to make the portion they are paying for high enough to make it enticing enough, they cannot force you. > The subsidies should just be given directly to the person who needs healthcare. There is no need to involve a third party. It just complicates the situation for no gain. Absolutely. The whole employer tax benefit situation should be abolished, and all individuals dumped on healthcare.gov. Same with retirement benefits. Employers should not receive any beneficial tax treatment for providing benefits, and it would make compensation much more transparent and easier for employees to compare from one employer to another.
- CameronNemo 5y agoHmm you're right on that first part. I don't know where I got that from. I seemed to remember playing around on CoveredCA and it said I couldn't get a plan because my employer offered plans, but I can't reproduce that now.