3 ms·
Believe me I have my share of problems with Blue and have made countless jokes but whether it is a vanity project or not. They are launching humans to sub-orbi
by panick21_ 5y ago
Believe me I have my share of problems with Blue and have made countless jokes but whether it is a vanity project or not.
They are launching humans to sub-orbital space. They have working Ox-rich engine and such an engine has never before been built in the US. They are not SpaceX level but such a project is quite a complex under-taking.
They are a contractor for ULA and the whole military is depending on them. This is pretty serious business.
- jacquesm 5y agoSure. But if you want to succeed in space the first thing you need is drive, and BO doesn't seem to have any. Whether it fails or succeeds it's not going to make any difference to Bezos and I think that the people who will win this kind of thing are the ones for whom it does make a difference. Sub-orbital launches are simply not useful, and a new type of engine only makes sense if it gives you a shorter path to the finish or a capability that you otherwise would not have. As for the military depending on them: SpaceX has been awarded a whole pile of contracts and the only thing that BO has going for it is to be able to ride the gravy train without delivering anything so far except for some research that may one day be useful. Instead of competing in the marketplace it seems BO is better at playing politics and competing in the courts, but the latter they've lost and the politicians will sooner or later want deliverables and without those the gravy train will sooner or later roll to a halt. Note that the engine program is now 4 years behind schedule and not a single BE-4 has flown. Even BO admits that the engine has problems, which makes me wonder if it will ever fly with the present design, and if they have to go back to the drawing board you can add a couple of years more worth of delays. Meanwhile, SpaceX launches a payload to orbit on average every 8 days for 2022 (once every 12 days in 2021), the amount of experience they are gaining alone is going to add up to a sizeable barrier.
- DennisP 5y agoI recently saw some interesting speculation on reasons BO might be having such trouble with the BE4. To oversimplify, they're trying to do with one turbopump what the Raptor does with two, and it's hard to keep that one pump from taking damage from such extreme conditions. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6zjdAQef3oY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6zjdAQef3oY
- jacquesm 5y agoInteresting. That's not going to be an easy fix. By the way, that SpaceX turbo pump shaft is a real work of art. And what a great video by the way.