4 ms·
Humans all have different versions of the 'driving' software installed, there's no way of identifying which ones will misbehave. If Teslas are malfunctioning, w
by bee_rider 5y ago
Humans all have different versions of the 'driving' software installed, there's no way of identifying which ones will misbehave. If Teslas are malfunctioning, we shouldn't ground Chevy Cruise.
We exist on a spectrum of competence. If a type of car has a widespread issue that unexpectedly gets it into a state where a minimally competent non-impaired person can't operate it safely, that type of car should be pulled from the road. However, because humans are so sloppy (0 human drivers should be the ultimate goal), it is generally assumed that most accidents are caused by us, and so we require a significant accumulation of evidence to take a type of car off the road. Without a human in the loop, what's the unreliable part to point the finger at?
- eru 5y agoWell, the obvious incentive with such a rule would then be to install slightly different versions of the software in every vehicle. (Or perhaps to have separate versions on file, and just load that different version when the first version is grounded.) > Without a human in the loop, what's the unreliable part to point the finger at? It's a cost benefit analysis. If the problem is sufficiently rare, it might make more sense to leave the cars running while you investigate. Even human lives aren't infinitely valuable. Typical traffic engineering in the US assumes a cost of human life of about 6 million USD or so.