I used to help run after school programs, and mentor quite a few Gen Z people in software engineering, sysadmin, etc. Also, I used to be a kid. Not every kid

I used to help run after school programs, and mentor quite a few Gen Z people in software engineering, sysadmin, etc. Also, I used to be a kid. Not every kid needs to conform to social norms. To your point, plenty of kids will be successful with and without smartphones, but I would argue those that don't will likely be less prone to endless hours of doom scrolling on apps literally designed with casino-like dopamine drip algorithms to keep them addicted. I choose to believe someone is not a shitty parent for trying to delay a child from having constant in-pocket access to addictive and harmful things.