4 ms·
Yet another reason why Linux and BSD distros, were never taken seriously on the Desktop. Alternatives of alternatives of a similar but tweaked distros further c
by rvz 5y ago
Yet another reason why Linux and BSD distros, were never taken seriously on the Desktop. Alternatives of alternatives of a similar but tweaked distros further confuses the user into thinking their desktop will (just work) but will start to be quickly unsatisfied that a single tweak or issue in something in that desktop, will make them migrate and distro hop constantly only to waste time fiddling with their computer.
The only proper qualifying example of OS uniformity other than Windows or macOS is ChromeOS, which is going to be replaced by Fuchsia in the future anyway. There is only one of that, like there is only one Windows or macOS.
That's just the tip of the iceberg of issues with the Linux Desktop and also without getting to the discussion of 'defining' Linux support.
Downvoters: You know it is true. Perhaps that is why this very long time veteran Linux user got fed up and moved to macOS: [0] After realising that they were spending more time fixing their computer, OS and apps in order to get things done.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30821580 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30821580
- southerntofu 5y ago> Yet another reason why Linux and BSD distros, were never taken seriously on the Desktop I think you're overblowing this point. Many administrations, non-profits and companies actively use GNU/Linux or BSD desktops and are quite happy with it. Red Hat, Ubuntu and Suse are famous example providing good levels of support and customization if you can afford it. Mandriva in its time was very user-friendly and popular (at least here in France) but unfortunately they were shut down for business reasons if i remember. But i agree with your critique that switching distro just because you want to switch desktop environment is the wrong answer because it introduces so many layers of complexity you know your tiny distro is gonna fall behind in terms of features/security. I wish more distros exposed higher-level knobs to customize everything without learning the specifics of every piece in the stack. That's for me the strongest selling point in nix/guix even though i feel it's not as user-friendly as it could be.
- Ekaros 5y agoAlso that the things change like every other year or at least every few years. And something might or might not break when updating. Windows did stay pretty consistent for long time. Windows 8 broke this, but after that it hasn't been too bad again.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoIt's true, the rather ludicrous number of distros out there causes many issues for people used to more homogeneous OSs. Probably the worst thing about it is that any time you have a problem someone will tell you that you chose the wrong distro and you'll be pushed to switch to another one, where you will of course encounter a different problem and repeat the cycle. Personally I think the proliferation of distros is itself a symptom of a greater problem with the Linux Desktop software ecosystem. If there were more stable ABIs, no such thing as library conflicts, less interaction complexity, etc. then one could mix and match software to fit their needs with little effort and a distro would be unnecessary.
- Koiwai 5y ago> ... moved to macOS. I mean, I've had lots of problems with Linux, but none of them could be solved by moving to macOS, AFAICT it could only be worse. It's unfortunate Linux is not for you, but I don't think that's Linux's fault, or anyone's fault.