7 ms·
> Why not? If you think that smartphone usage is harmful to your child, then you absolutely are justified in letting them be "that kid". It's a trade-off - is
by lelanthran 5y ago
> Why not? If you think that smartphone usage is harmful to your child, then you absolutely are justified in letting them be "that kid".
It's a trade-off - is peer ostracisation worth the benefits from lack of tech?
Most people, myself included, would say "No".
> Being moderately socially constrained is actually a perfectly fine thing if the alternative is worse.
It is not a moderate social constraint, it's a complete and utter exclusion from the set of peers.
- cjbgkagh 5y agoDon’t forget that those peers are also being damaged and may not make the best friends. From my observation children are increasingly dysfunctional.
- lelanthran 5y ago> From my observation children are increasingly dysfunctional. Hasn't every generation complained about this? We forget that we were children once too, and pushed at the boundaries as we matured into teens. This is what children do.
- watwut 5y agoSome generations are worst then others. Some are more violent then others for example. Tho, afaik, children of our generations were way more dysfunctional then we are willing to accept in these debates.
- cjbgkagh 5y agoJust because people complain about it, doesn’t mean it is not true. I think there are objective measures in intelectual ability, physical fitness, and mental soundness. And those objective measures appear to be getting worse. The big win of sanitation, nutrition, and general education appear to be long behind us.
- hanselot 5y ago
- tstrimple 5y ago> “Children; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. They no longer rise when elders enter the room, they contradict their parents and tyrannize their teachers. Children are now tyrants.” ~ Socrates
- cjbgkagh 5y agoSocrates; the guy famously sentenced to death for corrupting the youth. He himself encouraged the youth to do exactly those things. Decadence is nothing new. Society goes through ups and downs. There have been numerous reformation periods did yield substantial benefits. I don't think anyone is arguing that things have always throughout history gotten worse in all places simultaneously. It's my opinion that the exploitative power of machine learning with mass surveillance in the hands of profit incentivized corporations may not lead to the most conducive environment for developing brains. Even my mature brain has a hard time with it.
- jaspax 5y agoI'm curious about this peer group in which failure to have a cellphone results in "complete and utter exclusion". My nieces and nephews are in this age range (10-13 yrs), and none of them have cell phones, and none of them suffer total exclusion from their peer groups. As far as I can tell, they're all socially active and popular. Apparently it's different where you live, but I would take that as a bad sign on several levels.
- lelanthran 5y ago> I'm curious about this peer group in which failure to have a cellphone results in "complete and utter exclusion". Well the article in question has the kids blocked from google search. Such a radical block will almost certainly block everything else that their friends are using. So, sure, they may not need their own phone, but at ages 10-13, blocking the child from all popular tech makes them more or less unable to join conversations with their peers who are not blocked.
- lrvick 5y agoWhen all my peers were using AIM, and Yahoo instant messenger on Windows, I was on Linux communicating via online forums and IRC learning from mostly adults willing to mentor me as an anonymous username on the internet. I was homeschooled and moved every 3-6 months growing up and in spite of all these "handicaps" I still learned to make several IRL friends within a week or two of every new city I ended up in. I would say hi, show them a magic trick, do some comedy bits I had been working on, or share the latest anime I was into. Whatever. Making friends is the skill to build in a kid, not technology conformity. Stop worrying about making kids popular and making them conform in ways beyond basic manners and respect. The roads less traveled are more likely to kelp a kid develop atypical skillsets which will give them an advantage in the job market later.
- lelanthran 5y ago> When all my peers were using AIM, and Yahoo instant messenger on Windows, I was on Linux communicating via online forums and IRC learning from mostly adults willing to mentor me as an anonymous username on the internet. Right, and that was before all the kids were on facebook, or twitter, or whatever. You're talking about a time when the only online-networking being done, was being done on a desktop computer. IME, less than 1 out of every 100 children in 2000 were actually using desktop computer. We are now in a time were 95/100 children are using some sort of portable personal computer that is with them all the time. > I was homeschooled and moved every 3-6 months growing up and in spite of all these "handicaps" I still learned to make several IRL friends within a week or two of every new city I ended up in. Which was perfectly possible when almost none of the kids were on computers. Now they all are. > Stop worrying about making kids popular and making them conform in ways beyond basic manners and respect. The roads less traveled are more likely to kelp a kid develop atypical skillsets which will give them an advantage in the job market later. I'm afraid you're not a good example: you appear to lack some important skills wrt to the world as it is. Think about it this way - there are people who didn't bother putting up with the hardship of a reduced social network, and they ended up more successful than you. I don't think you have any interaction with children. I do.
- lrvick 5y agoI spent most of my childhood straight-edge and was thus cast out by peers for not joining them in their nonstop sex, alcohol, and drug addictions, and not being interested in sports. Instead I made fast friends with the other outcasts like me. The computer nerds, the anime nerds, the hobbyists, the actors, the musicians, the magicians, and the artists. People that spent life chasing their imagination and not worrying about trying to be "normal". Those friendships helped me become the person I am today. Kids without smartphones will be similar cast out of social circles that revolve around "app culture". Your kid will be better off without the influence of people that shallow. People sometimes basically tell me "Oh, if you don't install snapchat, discord, or x app, we can't be friends". If someone can't figure out how to maintain a friendship with me without a particular app I have ethical objections to, then I don't consider it a loss. Your kid will learn not to either. Ancedotal, but virtually all the nerds I grew up with are very successful now, and many of the popular kids that excluded me are still struggling to pay bills having never developed any specialized skills.
- lelanthran 5y ago> I spent most of my childhood straight-edge and was thus cast out by peers for not joining them in their nonstop sex, alcohol, and drug addictions, and not being interested in sports. That's a false dichotomy - you posit that those things are the only alternatives, which is incorrect. I never did non-stop sex, drugs and alcohol (and ignored sports) in school, and yet I was part of a number of different social groupings in school. > Ancedotal, but virtually all the nerds I grew up with are very successful now, and many of the popular kids that excluded me are still struggling to pay bills having never developed any specialized skills. That's funny - I was never a nerd (computer or otherwise), and grew up fairly successful. I think you might be missing the fact that your exclusions has lead you to believe a number of things that simply aren't true, like your first statement above.
- lrvick 5y agoI am sure there are endless counter-examples to my point, which helps make it stronger if anything. Removing any one popular activity from the life of a child be it smartphones, or tobacco, is likely to exclude them from some social groups, and perhaps make them more likely to land in others. If anything the take-away here is that the idea that a kid not having a smartphone will handicap them in life is nonsense. There are so so many paths to success in this world, though sometimes traveling a different path than the majority can have some advantages.