3 ms·
Patents have nothing to do with it. And its not wishful thinking at all. Solaris development was happening in public it was well integrated with the community
by panick21_ 5y ago
Patents have nothing to do with it.
And its not wishful thinking at all. Solaris development was happening in public it was well integrated with the community its not at all crazy to think that at least part of the development team would have continued working in the same way.
There were good products build on top of Solaris technology that IBM would have continue to develop and sell. Those products would not easily be built on top of AIX anytime soon.
IBM didn't need ANOTHER proprietary Unix, why would they go the Oracle route and make it proprietary again? What possible reason would IBM have to do that? The Openness of Solaris was what made it different form their other offerings.
IBM had also invested quite a bit of money in Linux and RedHat is literally part of IBM now. And apparently they have not acted the same as Oracle.
- pjmlp 5y agoYet another reason not to bother with Solaris, given the long investment IBM has had into Linux since 2000. IBM withdraw their offer, because they didn't had any commercial reason to go forward with the deal, and they aren't a charity to start with. Also interestingly, it was Oracle that turned Solaris into the first commercial UNIX that has successfully tamed C into production, not Sun. Something that naturally the Oracle haters don't care about.
- GekkePrutser 5y ago> IBM withdraw their offer, because they didn't had any commercial reason to go forward with the deal, and they aren't a charity to start with. I kinda wonder what IBM really is these days anyway. They're a bit of a server manufacturer for some niche stuff. A bit of a CPU manufacturer for some niche uses. A bit of a consultancy operator. A bit of a software supplier. A bit of an operational outsourcer. They're dabbling in everything yet don't shine at anything. No clear focus. If they didn't have their name and legacy I bet they would have been lost in the waves long ago.
- pjmlp 5y agoJava, UNIX, mainframes, services for all that stuff that must be done at Fortune 500s but isn't fashionable to write blog posts about.
- cestith 5y agoThey're an integrator and consultancy with a first-party mainframe platform, first-party data center play, first-party Linux development and support subsidiary, and the core developers for a lot of current-generation automation tooling.
- panick21_ 5y agoI understand why IBM didn't buy Sun that's not what we are arguing about. Sun was selling products that could only work on top of Solaris. Had IBM bought Sun they would have continued to sell those products (as they were profitable) and likely continue at least some level of Solaris development to support those products. They would have a had no reason what so ever to make that further development proprietary. > tamed C into production I have no idea what that even means. See has been successful in production on literally millions of computers and server around the world. And if we are talking about usefulness to production Zones and DTrace are about 1000x more helpful then anything Oracle innovated. > Something that naturally the Oracle haters don't care about. Yeah people don't tend to care as much what happens in proprietary OS by shitty vendors.
- pjmlp 5y agoSo there you go, an opportunity to learn about SPARC ADI and hardware memory tagging on Solaris. IBM invented timesharing and containers, no need for Solaris stuff.
- panick21_ 5y agoMemory tagging isn't remotely new, LISP Maschines and many others had done it before. So by that count they didn't invent anything. The code for it isn't even public so other could learn for it as Oracle made Solaris proprietary again. > IBM invented timesharing and containers, no need for Solaris stuff. I'm not sure what you are referring to by containers here. Please tell me where I can find a non-property Unix that allows me to use these amazing IBM containers. You seem to place equal value on some proprietary system that people can't actually use, and those that made it available to everybody in Open Source. Call me crazy but I value innovations more that are in the open and available.
- pjmlp 5y agoThey applied the knowledge of Lisp Machines and created the first commercial succesfull C Machine. Something where Apple, Google and Microsoft are followers, with ARM MTE, PAC and Pluton, while Intel just borked their n attempt at it. You can educate yourself on AIX LPAR and System 360. Yes, I do place equal value in commercial stuff, my FOSS zealot days are a behind me, https://xkcd.com/2347/ https://xkcd.com/2347/