6 ms·
I've taken LSD and 'shrooms a few times, and while I can understand what Jobs is saying, I think he was wrong. I had mystical experiences where I thought I und
by rwmj 15y ago
I've taken LSD and 'shrooms a few times, and while I can understand what Jobs is saying, I think he was wrong. I had mystical experiences where I thought I understood that the whole world was connected together, and I was connected to the world, and other deep insights. I think this was just brain-addled delusion, not any insight into how things really are.
That said, I fully support these things being legal, and (for people who aren't naturally anxious) trying them with a good "set" and "setting".
- tomelders 15y agoI too have taken LSD. Microdots were prevalent circa 1995 in South Yorkshire, which were strong to the point of not being funny. However, I did manage to get my grubby little junkie mitts on a few paper trips which were a lot more pleasant. My own personal view that it did change the way I look at the world in some strange and indescribable ways and the experiences made a large contribution to the person I am today, for better and for worse. I never had any grand epiphanies though, but I had some really good times. I also had some truly horrible times which resulted in some pretty strange phobias that I'm only just starting to get over, but I wouldn't say they've had any noticeable affect on my life. The moral of the story? There is no moral to this story.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- wellsaid 15y agoYou really put it accurately. When I came to psychedelics I had expectations and excitement and stuff. It didn't turned out exactly as expected.
- omarchowdhury 15y agoEverything is connected. It is understandable to discard insight on psychedelics as being 'brain-addled delusion' if the materialistic supposition is already implanted. Furthermore, such insight is usually overwhelming with assimilation into baseline consciousness being difficult. However, the same mystical states have been achieved by many without the use of drugs - a gradual onset over a lifetime of discipline.
- VMG 15y agodownvoted for irrational mysticism
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- MarkPNeyer 15y agohow is it irrational to say everything is connected? if you can show me two things that AREN'T connected, you'll have proven him wrong. but you can't, because you just connected the two things you named by putting them into the same sentence.
- Jage 15y agoSure, you can make the argument everything is connected. I don't need to drop acid to realize that argument, nor do I plan on dropping acid because of some mystical, inexplicable revelation it brings on a bunch of space cadets Call it ignorant, I don't really care. I grew up with people that did acid, and their personalities shifted in a remarkably profound way, becoming much more introverted and quiet. Whether this was just growing up and didn't have to do with the acid, I don't know, but I know that as the only one that didn't do it my personality did not shift in that way, nor would I want it to shift in what I think is a negative manner As a side note, and something to think about, are things really connected or is your brain just looking so hard to find patterns it connects things that have absolutely no correlation? I think one of the great philosophical ideas of the last few centuries has been that reality may not exist and we interpret it-- which was generally assumed throughout thought before psychology and existentialism-- but our mind has an inner reality that we transpose onto the existential world. Aristotle was famous for saying everything has a purpose, but does it really? Or are our minds just finding a purpose for everything relative to our existence. Just some random mental masturbation for you guys
- bluedanieru 15y ago
- ldh 15y agoI think it's a mistake to focus too much on the mystical "revelation" angle that some people use to frame the benefits of psychedelics. I have no trouble believing that the positive outcomes people get from psychadelics are real while rejecting the notion that there's some obscure mystical reality that's being tapped into. I think the "brain-addled delusions" you describe can be appreciated as rare and useful shifts of your own perspective even if that's all they are. Sure, there's nothing supernatural about it, but you may still have valid insights which you wouldn't necessarily have arrived at during your morning commute. Our mundane, day-to-day perspective on the world, on some level, is only distinguishable from "brain-addled delusion" because we're desensitized to it.
- rwmj 15y agoI don't disagree at all. As I said I think it may be worthwhile for some people to take LSD. It would be so much better if it were legal and we could take a serious look at how to reduce the harmful part of taking it, and also look at perhaps genetic or other factors which mean that some people really shouldn't be taking it.
- saddino 15y agoI think you may be missing the forest for the trees. My personal insight from psychedelics was that what I perceived as "reality" was simply wetware converting signals from my senses into perception. When something changes that perception (sometimes dramatically, like patterns on solid objects moving fluidly behind my hands or gazing at shimmering geometric rainbows etched into the walls) one understands that reality is just in your head. IMHO that's a powerful construct, especially for an optimist: it's easier to imagine changing the world when the world is so easily changeable in your head.
- codybrown 15y ago"It's easier to imagine changing the world when the world is so easily changeable in your head." Yes.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- elemenohpee 15y ago> I had mystical experiences where I thought I understood that the whole world was connected together, and I was connected to the world, and other deep insights. I think this was just brain-addled delusion, not any insight into how things really are. Hasn't this view been borne out by modern science? The fact that we are made of the same stuff as the dirt and the stars, and that there really is no dividing line between us and the universe, and by extension each other is, I think, a supremely important revelation. I'm curious as to why you dismissed this as a delusion?
- rwmj 15y agoIt's delusional in the same way that someone else telling me they had a religious experience is delusional. I cannot prove [to myself!] after the fact that what I experienced under the drug was real. I obviously believed it at the moment I was under the effect of the drug, but afterwards I couldn't recall exactly why I believed that. In other words, there was no way to prove or explain it. So it's delusional -- an event is supposed to have happened but there is no proof of it. There's simply no reason for me (now) to believe that what I experienced under the drug was real. (As I said above, I still think LSD should be legal so we can scientifically look at reducing harms from people taking it)
- elemenohpee 15y agoWell when you're going at it from that angle, how can you prove to yourself that anything you experience is real? There are centuries of thought surrounding epistemology, I don't see why problems of how and to what degree we know what we know should apply to drug induced experiences and not regular experiences. But then again, I don't know what you experienced. The most profound insights I had make perfect sense to me now, and they mesh with current scientific understanding as far as I can tell, so I have no reason to doubt them.