4 ms·
I used to wonder about that at the time, but they would have both wanted to be in the driver's seat, and it simply wouldn't have worked. But the world would ha
by DonHopkins 5y ago
I used to wonder about that at the time, but they would have both wanted to be in the driver's seat, and it simply wouldn't have worked.
But the world would have been a better place if IBM had bought Sun instead of Oracle.
Which bring me to this old joke:
Q: What do you get when you cross Apple and IBM?
A: IBM.
- dehrmann 5y agoI always thought Sun would have been a good cultural fit for Google.
- jeffbee 5y agoQuite a bit of Sun software engineering ended up at Google so you're not wrong. Especially after Oracle shut down all Sun software development and laid everyone off in 2017 there was a huge wave of referral hiring.
- invalidname 5y agoEric Schmidt was the CTO of Sun for a while and brought that culture to Google. I see a lot of the problems Sun had in Google and IMHO it's about to collapse under its own weight and lack of focus.
- hulitu 5y agoTaking into account the elegance of SUN OS and Solaris compared with Android and the usability of OpenLook compared to Android GUI, i would doubt it.
- mcv 5y agoA lot of people at the time thought Google should have bought Sun. Google was heavily involved in Java at the time (with Dalvik especially), and got in a lot of trouble with Oracle when they bought Sun.
- cestith 5y agoI really wish Compaq after buying DEC would have bought Sun, BeOS, and Apple rather than get acquired by HP.
- zwayhowder 5y agoI worked at EMC at the time that Sun was aquired by Oracle. There were rumors that EMC was considering purchasing Sun to gain the final toe hold in the DC that they eventually filled by merging with Dell. I am sure if EMC had bought Sun I'd still be there. Sun & EMC were both engineer led organisations in the old days, and the two cultures would have worked well together. (IMHO based on my experience working at EMC and with many many Sun alumni).
- jabl 5y ago> Sun & EMC were both engineer led organisations in the old days Isn't that exactly the problem? Server and storage HW were rapidly getting commodified. That's why the "vacuum cleaner salespeople" of the IT world (Dell, Compaq etc.) won, there's little value add in server HW engineering except at the bottom of the stack (Intel, NVIDIA, AMD, etc.).
- smackeyacky 5y agoThats a little harsh towards Compaq. They inherited industry leadership with the 386 and their stewardship of the PC in that time was pretty damn good. Dell, the cow people etc...not so much.
- simonh 5y agoIt's also why HP, the actual engineer led scientific instrument manufacturer HP, left the computer industry and became Agilent leaving the vacuum cleaner sales people part behind. It's a crying shame, but you're right, PC manufacturers were and still are in a brutal race to the bottom. For a while I though HP might have a chance on mobile, when they took on webOS. If they could have established a compelling platform stack with hardware, operating system and a decent dev environment they could have had a chance to grow their margins a bit. The problem is I suspect the PC side of HP just wasn't up to it. I had an HP digital camera around that time and it was a bulky, blocky uninspiring lump of a device.
- rjsw 5y agoHP had plenty of handheld/mobile experience, from their own work and aquired with DEC and Compaq.
- pjmlp 5y agoWell, too bad IBM withdraw their offer, and if anyone thinks that they would care more about Solaris than Aix, IBM i or IBM z/OS, they are fooling themselves. Databases they already had DB2. Informix did not had an happy life after aquisition, so most likely the love for MySQL wouldn't be that great. And in what concerns Java, IBM has always had their own implementations, with extensions like JIT caches, AOT compilation, real time GC, special flavour of value types (ObjectLayout), so also here little value to get from Sun.
- panick21_ 5y agoIBM would have continued Solaris development, maybe not made a major investment in it but would also not have destroyed it. They would have continued to develop it and ZFS in the open. I simply don't see IBM doing what Oracle did and basically stopping OpenSource development.
- pjmlp 5y agoThe company that usually wins the number of patents per year? Maybe you should delve into how much FOSS love there is on IBM when it doesn't fit business targets. Wishful thinking.
- panick21_ 5y agoPatents have nothing to do with it. And its not wishful thinking at all. Solaris development was happening in public it was well integrated with the community its not at all crazy to think that at least part of the development team would have continued working in the same way. There were good products build on top of Solaris technology that IBM would have continue to develop and sell. Those products would not easily be built on top of AIX anytime soon. IBM didn't need ANOTHER proprietary Unix, why would they go the Oracle route and make it proprietary again? What possible reason would IBM have to do that? The Openness of Solaris was what made it different form their other offerings. IBM had also invested quite a bit of money in Linux and RedHat is literally part of IBM now. And apparently they have not acted the same as Oracle.
- randomsilence 5y agoIBM has Eclipse. Not only is it an underhanded offense towards Sun, but IBM has shown that they are not willing to push the software to its best possible state. Eclipse is nice but JetBrains' products and Visual Studio Code are nicer. IBM is struggling with cloud computing. Adding SUN, they would have tried to turn it into a SPARK offer and burned much more resources. Both SUN and IBM couldn't continue as before. How could IBM have used SUN to create something better? At SUN's scale, there was no way forward for their OS or their chips. They were too late in open sourcing their OS, which could have created the market for their chips. Oracle did what SUN's management should have done years before. In my opinion, Steve Jobs chose to build consumer products because that brings the scale to produce chips. It's in IBM's name to serve businesses, not consumers. The cultural change to create the foundation for SUN's hardware business is almost impossible to pull off. I would like to argue that the world is a better place because Oracle is maintaining Java, something that SUN didn't fully achieve. Instead of browsers and Javascript, we could have a jvm everywhere. We are building the full stack with technologies like react and virtual DOMs anyway. It's too late for that, but it's in Oracle's own interest to make Java shine.
- panick21_ 5y agoWhat you get is 'Taligent'. A partnership between Apple/IBM in 1992. > Taligent OS and CommonPoint mirrored the sprawling scope of IBM's complementary Workplace OS, in redundantly overlapping attempts to become the ultimate universal system to unify all of the world's computers and operating systems with a single microkernel. Apparently it a combination of 'Talented' and 'Intelligent'. So what you get apparently is the worst aspect of both organization. Its like if you would have Sun and Apple merge and you end up building a Sun GUI on top of a System 7 kernel.