2 ms·
The entire point of the phrase "security theater" is to emphasize that there is no observable difference in outcomes. Ordinary people understand this, and crimi
by woodruffw 5y ago
The entire point of the phrase "security theater" is to emphasize that there is no observable difference in outcomes. Ordinary people understand this, and criminals (especially the kinds that seize airplanes) are usually at least as smart as laypeople. Evaluating the success of the TSA based on perceived deterrents is at best an unknown unknown, but the fact that we know those deterrents to be ineffective makes the null hypothesis (it's just not that common to hijack planes anymore, potentially for other reasons) much more likely.
> Look into news reports from the 60s and 70s, before serious security at airports. Hijackings were almost normal. Today they are almost non-existent.
I would wager that this has more to do with the FAA requiring the reinforced and locked cockpit doors, and almost nothing to do with the TSA. The hijackings of the 1960s and 1970s were not done as acts of terror -- they were frequently "statement" actions, done with the goal of making the plane land somewhere troublesome for the US (like Cuba).
> I also appreciate the security theater because it makes airports a generally drug-free environment.
Do we go to the same airports? I regularly see daydrinking, mixing alcohol with sleep medications, and all kinds of behavior that adults generally do when they're in a space where they know their actions don't have real consequences for them. I'll go as far as to say that I've seen more open drug use (and consequent poor behavior) in airports than I've ever seen in the Port Authority in NYC. And I rode interstate buses for years.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> the reinforced and locked cockpit doors Nope. Hijackings disappeared long before 9/11, when they started x-raying carry-ons in the 80s. No longer could just anyone bring an AK-47 on in a guitar case. https://airport.nridigital.com/air_mar20/timeline_the_history_of_airport_body_scanners https://airport.nridigital.com/air_mar20/timeline_the_histor... "As time went by, a series of skyjacking attempts – which in 1969 alone amounted to 40 in the US [ie one every week] – eventually led to the introduction of the first x-ray scanning machines for baggage in the 1970s. However, passengers themselves were only checked with an electronic magnetometer and later through metal detectors."
- woodruffw 5y agoSo that we're on the same page: the TSA was founded in 2001, as a response to 9/11. Nobody is saying that there shouldn't be any security at airports. When people talk about the TSA's security theater, they typically mean: 1. Non-evidence-backed methodologies and screening requirements, such as the 3oz liquid limit and requiring passengers to remove their shoes (but only some of the time?) 2. Arbitrary "secondary screening" procedures and rampant pretextual justifications for screening selection (read: "looking too much like a terrorist") 3. Overdependence on questionably useful scanning technologies[1][2]. I chose millimeter wave scanners arbitrarily, but "backscatter" scanners have similar problems. If x-raying luggage keeps people from bringing AK-47s onto airplanes, then we should continue to do that. But we can skip the rest of the theater and save some time and money in the process. [1]: https://www.nbcdfw.com/news/local/tsa-agent-slips-through-dfw-body-scanner-with-a-gun/1911599/ https://www.nbcdfw.com/news/local/tsa-agent-slips-through-df... [2]: https://www.propublica.org/article/sweating-bullets-body-scanners-can-see-perspiration-as-a-potential-weapon https://www.propublica.org/article/sweating-bullets-body-sca...
- sandworm101 5y agoThe TSA today is a federal agency, bundled into DHS. Before that there were plenty of people doing screenings at airports that, today, we would describe as TSA. The fact that they were employed by local agencies rather than the feds doesn't change the fact that they searched everyone in basically the same manner as today. I had my bags x-rayed and walked through metal detectors every time I flew in the 80s and 90s.
- woodruffw 5y ago> The fact that they were employed by local agencies rather than the feds doesn't change the fact that they searched everyone in basically the same manner as today. I had my bags x-rayed and walked through metal detectors every time I flew in the 80s and 90s. I don't think I would consider today's screening techniques "basically the same" as those in the 1980s and 1990s. My understanding is that the liquid limit, shoe removal, and use of largely ineffective personal scanning machines are all post-9/11 changes. All of that is a significant departure from having your bags scanned and walking through a single metal detector. (More generally, this raises the question: if things are "basically the same" in your opinion between now and the 1990s, why weren't we able to stop 9/11?)