3 ms·
> bills restricting voting access to people of color I'm not aware of any such bill. What's its name? And why is it not dead on arrival due to the Equal Protec
by josephcsible 5y ago
> bills restricting voting access to people of color
I'm not aware of any such bill. What's its name? And why is it not dead on arrival due to the Equal Protection Clause?
- philosopher1234 5y agoI’m not playing plausible deniability games with you. Everyone knows what the point of these bills are.
- josephcsible 5y agoHow is anything I said "plausible deniability games"? You claimed that bills exist that would restrict voting access to people of color. I asked you exactly which bills these are, and you can't/won't tell me.
- Timwi 5y agoThe reason they won't tell you is because you've already presented yourself as someone who would deny the racist goals of a bill merely because it doesn't explicitly mention race. Differently put: everyone knows what these bills are except people who are in denial of institutionalized racism. You've used an argument structure that is reminiscent of that used by people who are in denial of institutionalized racism. Therefore, it is assumed that you are in denial of institutionalized racism, and thus, there's no point telling you about the bills because you're just going to be in denial about them anyway. Meanwhile, anyone who is not in denial can just use any random search engine and find articles like this one: https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2021/03/25/vote-m25.html https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2021/03/25/vote-m25.html
- josephcsible 5y agoThis is a Kafka trap. You're setting up a world in which nobody can disagree with you without being in denial.
- philosopher1234 5y agoAfter 4 years of trying to engage thoughtfully and being given the run around, I'm done putting myself out there for people who don't demonstrate an ounce of genuine interest in understanding the issue.
- Zanneth 5y agoMaybe you don't fully understand the issue then. If you did, then you should be able to argue both sides thoughtfully.
- philosopher1234 5y agoOr maybe you have too much faith in my opponents. Will a lifelong religious devotee be dissuaded of his faith by one argument with me on hacker news? I think the lot of you are naive, and unaware of what really motivates your views (its not logic).
- joshuamorton 5y agohttps://archive.ph/zUVTp https://archive.ph/zUVTp is one of many, they work by making it more difficult to vote if you are working class, and usually urban in a state with a high percentage of minority residents. These laws, in practice, disenfranchise mostly minority voters. It's not dead due to work by the Roberts Court to gut the voting rights act, which was the law that prevented this kind of shenanigans.
- josephcsible 5y agoIsn't the part of the bill you linked to just saying "buses and other readily movable facilities shall only be used in emergencies"? What does that have to do with being working class or a minority?
- joshuamorton 5y agoThe entire article, I didn't mean to link to a particular subheading. And now the "plausible deniability games" begin in earnest. It is entirely possible to write a law that is ostensibly race neutral while making it apply discriminatorily. For a non-racial example, consider preferring tall candidates or military veterans as a proxy for men. Similarly, things like requiring a drivers license or travel to an in-person voting location prevent working class people who don't own a vehicle and who work 9-5 from being able to vote without sacrificing wages (or perhaps at all!)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- josephcsible 5y ago> It is entirely possible to write a law that is ostensibly race neutral while making it apply discriminatorily. I agree it's possible, just not that this bill does so. > requiring a drivers license or travel to an in-person voting location But the bill you linked to doesn't require either of those things. There are explicit provisions for people without driver's licenses in it, and it didn't ban absentee voting.