4 ms·
I think making a molten salt reactor work would be amazing. Doing so in a 3rd world country would be even better but it happening is really hard to see. I thin
by panick21_ 5y ago
I think making a molten salt reactor work would be amazing. Doing so in a 3rd world country would be even better but it happening is really hard to see.
I think more likely one of the companies working in Canada will get there first. Canada is the only international regulator of high standing who has a real strong program of trying to get such reactors actually certified.
The US has woken up out of their deep, deep slumber in the last 5 years but the DoE changing policy is basically like watching a glacier. They have done some good things and hopeful they continue to cooperate with Canada.
One of the biggest things holding back nuclear is that each country has a totally unique regulatory framework. And no market (except maybe the US) is large enough to justify the investment.
This is also a problem in other spaces but getting your electronics certified is a lot cheaper then spending potentially 100s of millions on a certification process.
To make nuclear commercial really happen international regulatory agency should exist or the nuclear regulator should cross license each other.
ThorCon gets around that by working with a company that almost doesn't (or didn't) have a regulatory agency or a regulatory framework and they are building them together. The government is building the regulator, the company the product.
I wish them the very, very best. If they are successful it could do more then almost any other project. Its far more important then getting a little bit more wind energy into Germany. Indonesia is one of the biggest countries in the world and coal is their only viable option right now.
Edit: This is great video to understand what ThorCon is actually doing:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rZx7kwZo4hQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rZx7kwZo4hQ
- ethbr0 5y agoApparently the International Atomic Energy Agency spends ~10% of its budget on creating and sharing safety standards [0]. Unfortunately, its safety model flows through "and then allow nations to create their own standards." Ceding standards / regulation to an international-level organization for advanced reactors that meet some criteria (e.g. proliferation-resistant, under a certain power, fail-safe, minimal worst-case scenario) would do wonders for low-carbon energy transitioning. Imagine a micro-reactor that's deployable in any member country, because it's already been vetted and certified. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Atomic_Energy_Agency#Nuclear_safety https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Atomic_Energy_...
- panick21_ 5y agoWhat is the worst thing of all, the US, the one country who could actually maybe lead something like that maybe has the worst possible regulatory standard. The US literally hard coded PWR reactor standards into the regulatory framework. Doing anything else is essentially impossible outside a few niches. That is why a number of companies re-located to Canada. In the US you basically need to give them a design (100+ million investment), lots of money (nobody knows how much) and an unspecified amount of time (great to tell an investor) and then they will tell you what you need to do so they would consider licensing the design. And then you would actually have to go threw that licensing process. And people are wondering why there are no GenIV designs. You can't even do a prove of concept reactor for less money to prove the design. SpaceX basically does that with NASA, they show tests rather then doing more paperwork. You can do a university style research reactor but that really not enough to prototype a serious commercial reactor. To do a prototype you would have to go threw the full process above, that is why most reactor companies go from design directly to product. The Western world should have been a nuclear society since the 80s.
- ncmncm 5y agoRegulation is thus far saving us from most badly ill-advised nuke projects. Some sneak through, costing ratepayers in more politically corrupt places many $billions for, in the end, scrap concrete.
- panick21_ 5y agoRegulation prevents all technical progress for 40+ years is a good thing. Its just mind-blowing that such a statement can be made on a site called 'Hacker News'. Lets promote fear of technology and use regulation from preventing new technology to replace deadly dirty coal for decades and decades. What an amazing plan anti-nuclear people have been pushing for the last 50 years.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt has saved us from being saddled today with many more of these leaky ramshackle contraptions that would have cost a $billion each to take apart. I live near Indian Point, recently shuttered for leaks. I expect to be made to pay for dismantling it. I am glad I won't need to pay for several more. Money spent on nukes could have been spent bringing renewable costs down. We could have had solar and wind decades earlier. Jimmy Carter put solar panels on the White House. Ronald Reagan stripped them off. And here we are.