8 ms·
Trapped in lockdown, Shanghai residents turn to WeChat groups for food
- kodah 5y agoThis is a good reminder that COVID isn't over. I am surprised to read there's guards at the front of people's neighborhoods though. I don't know how I feel about that.
- rmk 5y agoIt will never be over. It may now be endemic, i.e., steadily circulating and flaring up regularly in the population.
- robonerd 5y agoCOVID is pretty much over, lockdowns and mask mandates are being lifted around the free world. However authoritarian governments will likely continue to use it as a lame excuse for years to come.
- eynsham 5y agoChina also has much less naturally acquired immunity than everywhere else, and (mysteriously) refuses to make that up with vaccines—it’s not just an excuse, unlike in those authoritarian countries where immunity has already been built up so a lockdown would make a much smaller difference.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sudosysgen 5y agoIt certainly isn't. Doubly vaccinated people are getting reinfected within a month. We just decided to roll the dice on the long term risks of such a disease.
- _abox 5y agoTrue, I got covid 2 weeks after getting my booster (3rd mRNA dose). At a point where protection should have been optimal. However it only gave me slight sniffles for 2 days. The vaccine made me more sick :) so IMO the vaccine did its job. I agree with rolling the dice on this. We can't keep locking thingals down forever and masks only delay an eventual infection anyway. The anti covid measures do their own damage on our health and economy so I'm happy with the relaxation.
- sudosysgen 5y agoAh, what I'm talking about is something else - people are being infected through the vaccine, and get a second breakthrough infection within a month of the first one. I don't know how widespread it is. Reinfections are generally milder than the first infection, but it's not the case every time. If we let the virus run through like wildfire and accumulate mutation after mutation as it runs through billions of hosts every few months, there is a chance it has a huge cost on society. This is pretty unique, too. Normally, people can go multiple years before reinfection even without vaccines. A virus that can reinfect after mere months and is this infectious is inherently very risky. A nightmare scenario would be one where people keep catching it every few months without it getting less severe after the first few times.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoIs a scenario where we have to work from home a couple of times a year for a few days due to a mild infection really such a nightmare? Considering the constant lockdowns we'll need to prevent it, that sounds a lot worse tbh. Of course it's possible a dangerous strain will emerge but I think it's worth the risk.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThere is a lot more that can be done besides lockdowns - we can have actually useful contact tracing and testing. There are tons of measures that can be implemented to reduce transmission. We're giving up on all of that. Besides, viral infections are very damaging to the human body. An infection severe enough to knock you out for multiple days multiple times a year, on top of all the other disease we have, each time rolling the dice on long term side effects, is far worse than "work from home a couple of times a day". If there is an only 5% rate of long term side effects (which is much less than it is at now), and you end up catching it twice a year, that means you're guaranteeing most people to suffer from long term side effects. Not to mention, unless we're sending sick kids to school, parents will be in deep shit. And on a personal preference level, I would much rather have a week or two of lockdown every year on average until we can develop a vaccine that can prevent reinfection and mutation or treatments and testing or w/e is needed to limit it, than to be guaranteed to get sick for a week or two at random times alone and risk severe long term effects every time. Even the Chinese didn't have constant lockdowns. The majority of Chinese people didn't even see a single lockdown this year. If their government was competent enough to keep a basic surveillance testing regime the lockdown in Shanghai might have already been over.
- vkou 5y ago'Covid is over', yet daily case counts are higher than at any point in time except during the first omicron surge. Over 1 million a day, at the moment. The only thing that's over is the media's interest in talking about it, over other vitally important topics, like Will Smith.
- robonerd 5y agoInfection counts are irrelevant. What matters is that relatively few people will be killed by it because vaccination (even the shitty Chinese vax) and natural immunity have changed the equation. In my progressive west coast city, even front-line customer service workers like grocery store employees are abandoning their masks. Covid is becoming endemic, yet mostly harmless. Zero-covid is a delusion for totalitarians.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoYou mean our fight against Covid is pretty much over - and has ended with complete capitulation. We are now letting it do as it will, for better or for worse - surrendering to our fate.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoYou do realize we have vaccines now, no?
- somewhereoutth 5y agoIt doesn't seem that vaccines can be the complete answer - due to waning and variant mutational avoidance. Unlike measles vaccine. Hence other measures may be necessary if we wish to control Covid
- NicoJuicy 5y agoWarning efficiency vs. Infection, not deaths. And omicron is practically harmless for the vaccinated.
- spookthesunset 5y agoWhat was the alternative?
- somewhereoutth 5y agoBetter ventilation of indoor spaces, more utilisation of outdoor spaces, better sick pay provision, more WFH, etc, etc - essentially the complete mobilisation of society to defeat COVID, whatever it took. A dress rehearsal for climate change.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoI don't think covid was bad enough to warrant complete mobilisation of society. Climate change yes. If anything it hurt our fight against climate change. There were some short-term benefits like reduced travel but overall it has increased inflation a lot due to the massive costs of the lockdowns. We're all a bit poorer and guess what, poor people have less to spend on climate-positive products and tend to go for the cheaper but worse options. We should pick our battles for the ones that count.
- InvaderFizz 5y agoSeems a softer[0] touch than in 2020. 0: https://www.cbc.ca/player/play/1703503427818 https://www.cbc.ca/player/play/1703503427818
- logicalmonster 5y ago> This is a good reminder that COVID isn't over. Covid, the disease, should be over for pretty much everybody except for people with very unusual health problems. Most folks are either vaccinated or just not that concerned and living with what they think is an acceptable risk level. Covid, the dumb bureaucratic reaction and endless money-grift, may survive quite a bit longer. > I don't know how I feel about that. Do you need somebody what to tell you to think about a nightmare dystopia?
- TheGigaChad 5y ago
- loceng 5y agoBags full of people's pets that were gathered due to COVID concerns (it looks like still alive, though uncertain if the plan is to kill them): "Pets filled up in bags for their duly execution in Shanghai, China as a part of the government's Covid response [TW]" - https://www.reddit.com/r/ThatsInsane/comments/u0fxgd/pets_filled_up_in_bags_for_their_duly_execution/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ThatsInsane/comments/u0fxgd/pets_fi...
- fabioborellini 5y agoChina might be the only society treating people and other animals equally, then
- blablablub 5y agoWhy do you post a video from Wuhan and say in your post that it is from Shanghai?
- GekkePrutser 5y agoThat's so sad... Why not just let them sick it out with their owners??
- ars 5y agoThere's no point in doing this, COVID will spread until everyone gets it at least once. You just want to slow it down not to overwhelm hospitals and that it's. And if you immunize everyone there's very few hospitalizations. Just make vaccines available - you don't even need to mandate them, most people will take them, and that's good enough.
- benjaminwootton 5y agoSuch pragmatism left the room in February 2020.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoIn fact politicisation entered the room in 2020 - from then on it became an uphill struggle to put in place even the most basic public health interventions.
- ceejayoz 5y agoPart of the problem is China's vaccine is substantially less effective than the mRNA ones. "Just make vaccines available" works less for them than it does in, say, the US.
- eric-hu 5y agoAnother part of the problem is that China forbids Chinese citizens from getting foreign made vaccines. They’ve acquired them, but only allow foreigners to get them.
- wellthatsawrap 5y ago[flagged]
- blablablub 5y agoWhat you wrote is absolutely not true. No one gets foreign vaccines(mrna) in China.
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoI believe this will lead to anyone in China (Chinese or otherwise) to permanently leave the country if they are able.
- Cerium 5y agoCurrently you can't get out unless you have a business, student visa or permanent residence permit. The word is that tourist visa holders will be denied exit. Getting in is also very arduous.
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoI get the feeling that the public consciousness in the West may still be underestimating and excusing a dismal regime. Typically I hear, "but the CCP lifted a billion people out of poverty!"
- sidibe 5y agoThe Great Leap Forward and Cultural Revolution, also achieved by the same party, put them at such an artificially low point it was impossible not to spring back impressively eventually.
- bogomipz 5y agoI don't understand your comment, especially in relation to the OP's comment that you responding to. The West generally doesn't have a very high regard for the CCP or many of their policies. Your quote is attributable to the CCP I believe and I think more recently to Xi himself. Who do you hear that from exactly? The Chinese people lifted themselves out of poverty when the CCP abandoned some of Mao's more disastrous economic policies.
- LAC-Tech 5y ago
- Stevvo 5y ago
- miked85 5y agoI haven't seen yet why China is going into lockdown again. Is there a new variant?
- dayofthedaleks 5y agoThe Sinovac vaccine isnt effective against recent variants, so it's 2020 all over again until mRNA tech becomes available. Also many older people aren't vaccinated.
- triyambakam 5y agoHave we been looking at different data? I don't see how any mRNA product has performed significantly better.
- reissbaker 5y agoWhat are you talking about? A three-dose regimen of Pfizer or Moderna pitted against Omicron is 75% effective against infection and 88% effective against severe disease: https://www.healthline.com/health-news/by-the-numbers-covid-19-vaccines-and-omicron https://www.healthline.com/health-news/by-the-numbers-covid-... Sinovac wasn't great against the original strain, but against Omicron, Sinovac is basically worthless. A two-dose regimen provides literally no benefit, and three doses is only equivalent to unboosted, two-dose mRNA (aka, not really effective): https://news.yale.edu/2022/01/20/vaccine-used-much-world-no-match-omicron-variant https://news.yale.edu/2022/01/20/vaccine-used-much-world-no-... Sinovac is trash, but politically China can't admit failure and buy the Western vaccines, and hence it's stuck with lockdowns.
- mxtihvb 5y agoYour claim isn't borne out by Hong Kong's case fatality rate numbers, which are broken down here by age range, vaccine type and # of doses: https://mobile.twitter.com/tripperhead/status/1512420394271076356 https://mobile.twitter.com/tripperhead/status/15124203942710.... Note that Hong Kong's Center for Health Protection (CHP) has consistently been way ahead of any other public health establishment in tracking and responding to COVID; they launched on-arrival rapid testing in March 2020 (!) and realized COVID was airborne, not fomite-transmitted, months before the CDC did. They've also consistently released provably accurate numbers. Hong Kong has had a bad response to COVID recently, but all of it is due to the bureaucrats in charge ignoring the CHP's scientifically-based health advice in favour of mandates handed down from the mainland government. In any case, the numbers show that while Sinovac isn't as great as Pfizer, it's much better than being unvaccinated. The case fatality rate among 80+ year olds who got covid is 15.68% for unvaccinated people, 3.98% for those with 2 doses of Sinovac and 1.73% for those with 2 doses of Pfizer. For 70-79 year olds it's 5.28%, 0.6% and 0.33% respectively. Note that all of Hong Kong's recent wave was from Omicron. We forget how lucky as a civilization we were to develop mRNA vaccines in response to COVID, and how much better than expectations they were. We would have been thrilled with the efficacy of Sinovac. So while Sinovac is definitely worse than Pfizer, it's misleading and alarmist to say that it's 'basically worthless.'
- walterbell 5y agoIs there also a power struggle between Shanghai and other political factions, with the civilian population caught in the middle? Oct 2021, https://www.asiasentinel.com/p/shanghai-gang-seeks-xi-jinping-ouster https://www.asiasentinel.com/p/shanghai-gang-seeks-xi-jinpin... > those who understand the factionalism in China will appreciate the depth of the spillover to Hong Kong and therefore the rooting out that’s been taking place as a consequence ... power struggle with a rival political faction backed by former Chinese President Jiang Zemin. Oct 2021, https://jamestown.org/program/factional-strife-intensifies-as-xi-strives-to-consolidate-power/ https://jamestown.org/program/factional-strife-intensifies-a... > power struggle between Xi and former PBSC member and Vice President Zeng Qinghong. Zeng, a princeling and close aide of former president Jiang Zemin, is also a major leader of the so-called Shanghai Faction. Zeng is believed to be the “protection umbrella” behind several multi-billion enterprises. Feb 2021, https://www.orfonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/ORF_OccasionalPaper_300_XiGang.pdf https://www.orfonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/ORF_Occ... > This paper ... argues that any attempt to comprehend elite politics in China requires an understanding of the factional dynamics within the party. The paper outlines the evolution of factional politics in China, and shows how two factions – the Shanghai Gang and the Chinese Communist Youth League (CCYL) – have dominated the country’s politics over the past three decades.
- uranusjr 5y agoThis is indeed a much-speculated reason behind the heavy-handed lockdown (but without substantial proof either way, it’s anybody’s guess).
- kkfx 5y agoNot much a smart move IMVHO: discussing on a hyper-surveilled platform is not good at all and in any cases they can't download food so... IMVHO they best move is just talking with their neighbors, in a day or two, offline, there will be a sufficient mass of people ready to descend to the street, and others will joint. At that point there is not much room for a new Tian'anmen: they are too much to be repressed. On the other side: it's a lesson almost no one would like to learn that we need to produce enough food to nourish residents, witch means that any relatively small area (like a region) should allow at maximum the number of residents who can be nourished at a minimum level with locally produced foods, of course commerce would be still there and improve life, but for basic surviving local one must be there. And that's an enormous issue for China. They need a younger population to remain in a growing state they need to counter the USA, they need to counter USA/UK because they are already too much and so they have to source food from south America, Africa etc witch means they need a dominance of "nearby" sees and USA can't accept that but a younger population means more children, so even more mouth to be nourished. In Europe we have a less profound but not that different issue and in the north America I suspect that's the same.
- Ancapistani 5y ago> they are too much to be repressed As someone who very much supports individual rights and self-determinism... I think you're drastically underestimating the power and scope of the Chinese state's ability to "repress". Given the choice between losing power and executing literally everyone in the city of Shanghai, I'm not at all confident that the CCP would choose the former. More realistically, one or two very visible examples of rebellion being dealt with very harshly would almost certainly be enough to quell any potential uprising in China. I've worked with several people from China, and a handful from Shanghai itself. I've had extensive political discussions with a few of them who became my good friends, and based on that my perception is that the Chinese people as a whole are significantly different culturally from Americans or Europeans. By and large they seem to default to believing that those in power are acting in the interests of the community, that they are party to things that inform their decisions, that the people are powerless to stop those in power, and that even if that weren't the case... another group would rise to power anyhow that would be just as bad. To put it another way - my cultural heritage is one of "Liberty or Death!". Theirs is "The proud nail draws the hammer".
- cryptica 5y agoThis shows the fragility of big cities. People who live in a big city are highly dependent on the government and the economy. Cities don't produce much food themselves so it has to be brought in from other parts of the country every day. Shanghai has 24 million people; it's difficult to conceptualize how much food is required to sustain so many people. I find big cities terrifying. What if there is a food shortage or some other panic and everyone decides to leave within a short period of time. Will it even be physically possible to leave with millions of people and cars clogging all the streets and booking out all surrounding hotels and accommodation? If you live in a remote town without too many people, this is not a problem; everyone in those towns easily find ways to sustain themselves from their surroundings; fish, birds, deer, wild fruits, vegetables...
- savant_penguin 5y agoIf anything it shows the fragility of having someone point a gun into your head forbidding you to go get food If for whatever other reason you'd live in a remote area and the government used force to stop you from getting food in whatever way, the exact same thing would happen, as it already did in Ukraine (holodomor hunger) where you have one of the most fertile grounds on the planet
- cryptica 5y agoIf there was going to be a food shortage in a big city which could not be stopped... Would the government tell people that there is going to be a food shortage? IMO, they wouldn't because this would cause panic buying by some which would make it happen even faster. I think they would just use some other excuse and find ways to reduce average consumption to make people last as long as possible on the limited supply and hope that the situation improves.
- reducesuffering 5y ago> the exact same thing would happen People in Shanghai are completely unable to produce their own food, with many not stocking even a bag of rice. Meanwhile, there's plenty of rural areas that can produce family-sized amounts of eggs, milk, fruits, and veggies to survive on indefinitely should the government decide to blockade you.
- newhotelowner 5y agoElon musk complained about the California lockdown in 2020. Did he tweeted about China shutting down his factory in 2022 due to covid?
- vmception 5y agoWhy do you think someone should behave the same way in a single party system? Support is achieved in different ways in different societies.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- NicoJuicy 5y agoIf you're wondering. Yes, it's the same variant. Yes, they have a working vaccine ( just not a RMNA one), but with a ( bit) lower efficiency and the older population is less vaccinated. China is currently in the weak position of not being able to contain a super contagious COVID virus, as they have propaganda'd their policy as superior to the western one for the last years. Not implementing zero COVID policy would mean their tactic is not superior ( vs. Flatten the curve) There are other, more minor, variables, but that seems to be the biggest one. Eg. Election next year, ...
- tyng 5y agoI'm in the lockdown in Shanghai, feel free to ask me any questions. Things you read on the internet is mostly true (but may be exaggerated): Life: Yes we can only buy food through WeChat groups to organise wholesale deliveries (2000 eggs, 200 cabbages minimum order) on hiked prices, but it's easier than you might think; No one has died from starvation (yet), but there had been a few cases of death due to not getting medical help in time; The city's resources are stretched - it's a city with 25m population. Work: I'm still working 12 hour days online (we're a design & project management firm). I get to wake up 10 minutes before a morning meeting and be in my pajamas the whole day. So on a personal level, life isn't that miserable. But it's definitely a very difficult time to the elderly and the ill. Will I (or anyone in my shoes) leave China permanently because of this? I guess not, even though I have the means to do it. There are harder problems to solve in life than feeling terrified by a lockdown.
- rdtwo 5y agoWhat about parents with kids? Everyone stuck doing virtual school and work in tiny apartments?
- tyng 5y agoSchools are closed, and for good reasons. If I'm the parent I wouldn't want my kids to get COVID. The gospel of online education may be coming true? Jokes aside, it's not as miserable as many people may think.
- spookthesunset 5y ago> If I'm the parent I wouldn't want my kids to get COVID The risks of missing education, physical activity and socialization are far greater for children than Covid. We have two years of data to show this.
- tyng 5y agoIt's not a permanent lockdown... just for a few weeks (so far)
- drumhead 5y agoA lot of CCP in this thread.
- akimball 5y agoOne should never underestimate the impact of 'useful idiots' - at all IQ levels. Indeed those of higher IQ have a much larger impact factor.
- Ancapistani 5y agoGood. The more you know about how others see the world, the easier it is to see your own view from the outside.
- learndeeply 5y ago> Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, bots, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- contingencies 5y agoPosting two anecotes to contribute to the record. One set of friends who live in Shanghai are Chinese. They have complained about lack of food. They didn't have extra food in their house when the lockdown began. Another set of friends are a mixed couple (European/Chinese). Two days ago when specifically queried how they are going they said they had been in lockdown for nine days and had only received a small amount of vegetables from the government 5 days in. They said the volume of food was clearly completely insufficient for their family of four, and "thank god" they had some extra food in the house. They said while you are allowed to order waimai (home delivery food), the demand vastly outstrips the supply so it is functionally impossible to do so. In general, compared to the lockdowns experienced elsewhere in China (with the possible exception of Wuhan initially), it seems the suddenness, scale and length of the Shanghai lockdown was particularly extreme and this has caused logistics challenges.
- lambo4bkfast 5y agoImagine locking down for covid in 2022; jesus these people are weird