5 ms·
It's not "don't say gay", it's "don't subject, expect or mandate young kids to learn stuff about things like sexual orientation (or even gender identity) that t
by zozbot234 5y ago
It's not "don't say gay", it's "don't subject, expect or mandate young kids to learn stuff about things like sexual orientation (or even gender identity) that they cannot possibly relate with prior to the biological changes of adolescence, and that are enough of a minefield for adults already. Leave this stuff to family and broader society for the time being."
- edent 5y agoDo you really think that young kids don't notice their parents affection for each other? Or that their older sibling is dating someone? Or that people get pregnant?
- zozbot234 5y ago
- brohoolio 5y agoThe teachers can’t address why someone in the class has two dads without risk of being sued. Heck the wording is vague enough you might not discuss marriage. The ambiguity in the law is there as a feature to hush normal conversations that might otherwise happen.
- kurthr 5y agoArguably, using "Mom" or "Dad", or even gendered pronouns is restricted. Of course not using these would upset the very people who wrote the laws, which is another part (beyond the enforceability) that makes them insane.
- scruple 5y agoWhy is an individual students parents a subject for a classroom? That is utterly bizarre and it sounds like the teacher in your hypothetical is singling out the student.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoFlorida education law, and this law, and education law in general, all have some real problems. It's somewhat unfortunate that misinformational memes of this sort travel much faster than reasonable understandings of its problems (this is but one example.) I believe it impairs the resolution of the nation's problems. Yeah, it galvanizes some support, but also hardens the opposition, and impairs the ability to make any sort of incremental progress, leaving achievable reforms stalled for years or even decades. Moreover, as a matter of principle, I don't really want to be part of a political movement which values spinning a story to its advantage more than it cares about informing the public. Build your movement on something solid.
- otterley 5y agoIt’s important to read all the parts of the law. The concerning parts are 1/the vagueness of it, and 2/enforceability though a private right of action (instead of having the state enforce it, parents get to sue the schools). It’s a minefield that educators must now trepidatiously tiptoe through. It makes their jobs significantly harder and more stressful. And for what real benefit, exactly? How is this improving our society in any real way?
- kjksf 5y agoIt's not "leave this stuff to family". It's "you're going to jail if you dare to talk about it". That's the obvious violation of First Amendment: government cannot use force to dictate what you say. And this topic is not on the short list of exceptions (threats of violence etc.). And stepping back: realize you're being played by politicians. Republicans know well this bill is unconstitutional. They know there are topics way more important to spend their very limited legislative time on. But DeSantis is going to run for the president so Republicans are picking fights with stupid bills to whip up their base to vote for them. Those stupid fights are also distracting you from things that actually matter i.e. how to maintain and increase prosperity of the people.
- rascul 5y ago> That's the obvious violation of First Amendment: government cannot use force to dictate what you say. Laws around hate speech and defamation seem to contradict you.
- otterley 5y agoI don’t think this is true; it’s not a criminal statute. While the law is problematic for plenty of reasons, the threat of imprisonment is not one of them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- micromacrofoot 5y agolol no it’s not - it’s literally a vigilante system that prevents teachers from talking about reality