7 ms·
Erik Naggum
- jzebedee 5y agoErik died in 2009. Erik Naggum in memoriam https://perpelle.net/artikler-og-leserinnlegg/erik-naggum-in-memoriam/ https://perpelle.net/artikler-og-leserinnlegg/erik-naggum-in...
- JasonFruit 5y agoApparently it's smart troll day on HN. (Xah is just down the page right now.) It's like a celebration of the kind of person I admired before I realized that other people are real too.
- sva_ 5y agoProbably saw this guy mentioned on that awfully long Xah Lee wikipost.
- codr7 5y agoThe more you know, the more lonely you get. I suspect they crave the company of peers more than attention. Naggum eventually couldn't cope if I remember correctly. We're failing all over the place.
- JasonFruit 5y agoI don't believe that's true. Several of the smartest people I know are among the most socially-capable and personally engaged. I think a healthy person recognizes value in aspects of a person additional to their intellect.
- legrande 5y ago> People search for the meaning of life, but this is the easy question: we are born into a world that presents us with many millennia of collected knowledge and information, and all our predecessors ask of us is that we not waste our brief life ignoring the past only to rediscover or reinvent its lessons badly Yeah the Not Invented Here mindset is hard to avoid. So many people ignorant of the whole body of knowledge on various subjects before them, and the best they can do is re-invent the wheel and cry 'Eureka!' (e.g Like when stumbling upon a yoga asana/posture that was committed to text 2000 years ago or accidentally coding Bubble Sort with no prior knowledge of algorithms).
- Hermel 5y agoSometimes, re-inventing something is easier than trying to find it somewhere else.
- civilized 5y agoRe-inventing can be good for your personal learning. But if you're building something that others are going to have to deal with, those others will usually be better off if a classical solution or approach is used. The classical solution will usually be less buggy and better explained than whatever you roll for yourself.
- Beltalowda 5y agoOr sometimes, what already exists is "okay" but not all that great, and by "reinventing" it you can improve on things. As with many things, NIH is a great attitude to have in some cases, and a horrible one in other cases. Being mindful what you're doing and why is key.
- tbrownaw 5y agoBicycle wheels, airplane wheels, and office chair wheels are all pretty different for pretty good reasons.
- ectopod 5y agoAnd a lot more fun.
- mrtree 5y agoA reminder to get checked with the doctor regularly and to treat intestinal issues seriously.
- kzrdude 5y agoHe had ulcerative colitis. People more or less use "having an ulcer" as slang for being in a bad mood. Maybe he was like the giant with a thorn in its foot - something bothered him, and that made him less than in a good mood.
- aidenn0 5y agoWasn't he diagnosed more than a decade before he died?
- javert 5y agoI noticed on his websites that he likes to write dates in a format like "2009-121" or "2006-257", i.e., year and then day of year (1..366). I also use that concept, though I write it as XXYYY where XX is years post 2000 and YYY is the day number. For example, today is 22100. Why do I like this? I find this is more "mentally ergonomic" to use for software tooling I have made for myself only. I usually don't care about the month or date of the month; I care about offsets (e.g. tomorrow is 22101 and ten days from now is 22110). If I'm computing an offset in my head, I don't have to account for wrap-arounds due to month (e.g. 10 days from March 25 is April 4 because March has 31 days.) The XXYYY format is about as concise as you can get (i.e., takes up minimal space on the screen) while still capturing all the information I care about. XXYYY sorts easily (though that's also true of YY.MM.DD which is my second favorite format).
- JasonFruit 5y agoHave you considered that your system might not be communicative to others?
- javert 5y agoAs I stated in my comment, I use this in tooling made for myself only.
- JasonFruit 5y agoApparently my reading needs work.
- rdpintqogeogsaa 5y agoThis is actually specified in ISO 8601; they call it the ordinal date.
- javert 5y agoAh, thank you. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_8601#Ordinal_dates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_8601#Ordinal_dates Looks like I'm using the second format (YYYYDDD) with the first two year digits truncated.
- vdas 5y agoI read comp.lang.lisp from 1998 - 2006. Lot's of interesting technical material. Many of Erik's technical posts are insightful. A few of these quotes make him look like a doofus keyboard warrior, but I could tell after reading his writing for so long that he was a genuine good guy, albeit at times a bit abrasive. Can't believe that it has been twenty years since I was introduced to common lisp. Think that I will go back to it after I retire.
- Beltalowda 5y agoAt least Naggum's was creative and entertaining in his abrasiveness. I'm not sure if I would have enjoyed actually interacting with him, but I always chuckle a bit reading through his old rants. If you read these things with a bit of humour it's quite funny.
- whartung 5y agoI was a denizen of c.l.l deep into the Naggum era. And, yes he could be abrasive. Notably he did not suffer idiots well. But if you read many of the threads, you'll notice that the provocateur upon which Erik focused his attention, the majority of the time, is talking past what Erik was saying. Most of those threads are folks yelling past each other, rather than actually addressing the points being made (and most of the folks he was directing his attention too dumped the technical side of the, uh, "discussion", almost immediately). He didn't suffer those people well either. My friends used to get into these spittle flying, lips shaking, table rattling lunch arguments at high volume. And whenever that happened, they were always talking (or, rather, shouting) past each other. And this happened face to face, 2 feet away from each other. The internet just makes that dynamic all the worse. I never had a bad interaction with Erik. He was always responsive and respectful to any communications I had. I wasn't close to him, but more than not enjoyed his commentary and his typically well thought out point of view (even if I didn't agree with it). He certainly doesn't need someone like me to defend him, but I do miss him. I consider his loss a blow. I had another friend, a closer friend, also an Erik. He had a caustic side to him as well, and we lost him just as the pandemic was starting. I miss him dearly as well. Maybe it's the name.
- 5y ago
- nabla9 5y agoI miss people like Erik in the Internet. Erik was like a predator who contributed to the ecosystem. He ate frequent low quality shitposters from comp.lang.lisp and then swam in circles preventing them from emerging. His rants were educating or entertaining. Usually both. They came from deep technical knowledge. When was the last time you followed a Internet flamewar and learned something?
- throwmeariver1 5y agoIt's like the fondness of bullies in high school until you realize that other people are indeed people and not cardboard popups.
- nabla9 5y agoHe was not a bully. He was short tempered, self-assured and way too aggressive, but not a bully.
- mmaunder 5y agoHis famous anti Perl rant circa 2000: (I worked as a Perl dev in 2000) https://groups.google.com/g/comp.lang.lisp/c/LGeQBt_ClfI/m/Y_iyHKvrdvwJ https://groups.google.com/g/comp.lang.lisp/c/LGeQBt_ClfI/m/Y...
- isoprophlex 5y agoThis guy would have had a field day with python, if he were alive right now
- fulafel 5y agoIt had been around for 9 years when that was written, Python 1.5 or 1.6 was then-current.
- isoprophlex 5y agoHehe but the whole "i used to write poor sql for money, now i write even worse pandas code for 50% more money" thing wasn't
- tptacek 5y agoIt's... not very good? The bar for language takedowns is apparently much higher today than in 2000.
- pvg 5y agoIt's weaksauce for 2000, no? Pretty much everything in Unix Haters Handbook (1994) is better than this. In the more usenetty vein, Christiansen's C-shell Considered Harmful is easily much better.
- tptacek 5y agoThere's a lot of filler in it, it's not very pointed, and it's mostly handwavy. You could substitute almost any other language in there and it would read the same. "This is your brain on Perl"? I think "A Fractal of Bad Design" ruined me for these. People call Perl a "write-only language". That's a good takedown! And in just a couple words! I don't get why people have so much reverence for Naggum.
- suction 5y agoProbably it's just me, but after 2016 and all that idiotic internet edgelord-ery that enabled and accompanied it, and the repercussions we will still feel for decades, I've lost all patience and interest with these type of 14-and-this-is-deep edgelords, especially when they're in their 20s or even older. They don't add anything that for instance Houellebecq hasn't formulated before them, and way more poignantly. Just because they don't read literature but stew in the muddy waters of forums and usenet and other places, doesn't mean their pontificating can be excused.
- unixhero 5y agoThese types drove me away from IRC and and Computing environments all together. I met a whole bunch of them and the whole vibe was very dismissive. I became an economist and later returned to computing again. Edgelords is an accurate term for these types!
- suction 5y agoI'm going through a similar situation. I'm very reluctant to tell new people I meet that my job is internet-related. Many nontechnical friends have come to know the internet mainly as either a cesspool of disturbed people, or a silly pastime for kids with an attention whore syndrome - and anyone who works in the field, even on unrelated projects, is basically fueling the fire. Can't say I even blame them.
- jonjacky 5y agoFor those who may not be familiar with Erik's thinking and style, here is a sample post[1] from Erik on Paul Graham's Arc dialect of Lisp, which, I recall, still powers HN: I have briefly looked at Arc. It is yet another demonstration of the problem of too strong an ego that cannot live with what somebody else has made. Be it the standard conditionals, nil versus false versus the empty list, or whatever else this purportedly strong ego is too weak to accept, it is nothing more than proof of the core problem of the IT world -- the hardness of its pillars makes them brittle, not strong, so they cannot be used to build upon. What was it that stood so much in the way that Paul Graham could not have accomplished it without creating a new language? Why was creating a new language and starting from scratch better than building on what had come before? Why is the IT world defined by people who are unable to deal with the concepts of continuity, longevity, and design for long-term stability? Why do they believe they are so much smarter than everything that has gone before them, when they clearly are not and repeat mistakes that take years to undo, if not replaced by another stupid "revolution" that itself starts from scratch? If people built societies the way computer people build communities, we would still live have small warring tribes and no concept of a law that binds all people and absolutely no concept of a constitution that binds lawmakers. For all the talk about the Internet changing the world, we lag the real world by about 40,000 years when it comes to how we make lots of people who do _not_ agree to everything live and work together. Suddenly, I feel old and tired. [1] archived at https://groups.google.com/g/comp.lang.lisp/c/O5Vss_BdSy4/m/ticLHuSRQesJ?pli=1 https://groups.google.com/g/comp.lang.lisp/c/O5Vss_BdSy4/m/t...
- tptacek 5y agoLike the Perl takedown downthread, this is pretty disappointing milquetoast stuff. It's sentence after sentence repeating the same question --- "why another new language?" --- that was literally one of the first Paul Graham answered when he did Arc. It reads as if Naggum believes he's the first to have thought of asking. Embarrassing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago