4 ms·
95% of the security of TOTP stuff is that users have no freedom in implementing it and thus cant mess it up. There is no equivalent of having "hunter2" as your
by bawolff 5y ago
95% of the security of TOTP stuff is that users have no freedom in implementing it and thus cant mess it up. There is no equivalent of having "hunter2" as your password when the user doesn't choose the secret. They cant reuse secrets across sites if they dont choose secrets.
Every other realistic threat is not helped by TOTP. There is some threats that in theory TOTP can help with, but dont given how it is used on the web.
* phishing - just as easy to phish the token
* trojan on your computer/shared workstation - just steal the session cookie or take control of browser remotely
(For U2F/fido keys/webauth based 2fa the situation is a bit different, but almost nobody uses that)
- heavenlyblue 5y agoBut then users store these passwords on a sticky note attached to their display device…
- UncleMeat 5y agoWhich is pretty good against some real threats. Evil maids are very rare in comparison to credential stuffing.
- bawolff 5y agoIts debatable how bad that is. For most (not all) people, the realistic threats do not have physical access to your computer. However, this is kind of my point - you might put your password on a sticky not. In TOTP 2FA the equivalent is your qr code. I have never seen anyone print out a qr code and put it on a sticky note beside their computer.