3 ms·
Let’s say you flip the recommendation to “smarten up” math education K-12. Teach Algebra gradually over K-6, do Geometry 7-8. Trig in 9, Calc 1 & 2 in 10-11, an
by Spivak 5y ago
Let’s say you flip the recommendation to “smarten up” math education K-12. Teach Algebra gradually over K-6, do Geometry 7-8. Trig in 9, Calc 1 & 2 in 10-11, and Real Analysis in 12.
What do you think the outcome will be in aggregate? I’ll bet my hat it does nothing to produce better outcomes while furthering the race-influenced class divide. We literally have 4 living generations of people who’s only lasting association with math is “that thing that was needlessly hard and useless.” It’s the education equivalent of peacocking. It says nothing about you other than your family circumstances afforded you ample time to waste. Nobody remembers a damn thing about Trig, Geometry, Formal Proofs, or Calc unless they went on to a STEM field where they kept the knowledge fresh and even then they were still retaught it all in college anyway. But let me tell you everyone remembers the stress.
I say this as someone who has two degrees in math and tutored half my damn class just to get them through trig and calc. High school math is garbage and pointless. “Oh but it teaches you how to think analytically.” The hell it does, the nuggets of creative problem solving are buried in mountains of rote memorization and bullshit trivia.
If you want to raise the tide for all ships I would just do two years of algebra so people actually understand it completely instead of rushing them to the next thing only to flail for 4 years barely keeping their heads above water and then just stop. Then let people who are genuinely passionate about maths (or need it because they want to do calc based physics which would also be optional) opt in to that track, and crucially, don’t reward it in any way except as “nerd extracurricular” so people aren’t pressured into it.
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoThe world is getting more complex, rather than less and the requirements to compete in that world are increasing. Giving up on math is giving up on the future.
- Spivak 5y agoSee here’s the thing. I completely totally agree with you. Which is specifically why I want to drop the math curriculum that is 4 years of blinding speed though material with just enough understanding and blind memorization to pass an exam it before forgetting it all. I want a world where people come away not afraid of maths and feel like they can use it as a tool to solve real problems. But that doesn’t happen unless you sit with the material for a while. What you see as dumbing down I see is actually having a whole generation of people understand and remember algebra which is way better than we have now.
- zozbot234 5y agoK-6 is way too early for Algebra I or anything like that, but what you can do is smoothly transition from arithmetic to "pre-algebraic" thinking, most commonly seen in complex word problems. Geometry can be taught alongside math throughout the whole K-9 or so curriculum, laying the prereqs for trig, so-called "precalculus" and calculus in 10-12. This is not a fancy approach, it's basically how math has always been taught outside the U.S. When you hear amazing things about "French math", "Russian math", "Singapore math" or whatever, that's what it's about. It's a smartened up form of traditional teaching: no need for useless Ed-school woo about how "students should just learn their math by themselves".
- derekp7 5y agoThe big transition in thinking comes when you realize that there is a difference between arithmetic and math. And that kids can absolute hate arithmetic, but fall in love with math.
- zozbot234 5y agoThis doesn't change the fact that algebra is extremely unintuitive for a young kid who only knows arithmetic. Working on complex word problems - as was common in traditional math teaching, even as far back as ancient times - can help bridge that gap.
- techdragon 5y agoIt’s not hard to teach basics of algebra to small children. When you work with teaching analogies like “has two apples” all the time, it’s actually not that hard to get kids to understand that you can you can do math with “things” and that it doesn’t matter what the “things” are, so two apples and five oranges becomes 2a + 5b… I don’t expect a 9 year old to do complex algebra but the fact that you can do math with placeholders is definitely within their grasp.
- zozbot234 5y ago> it’s actually not that hard to get kids to understand that you can you can do math with “things” and that it doesn’t matter what the “things” are, so two apples and five oranges becomes 2a + 5b… It's hard if you want to do it prior to 8th grade let alone 6th grade, and that isn't even the most challenging part of what Algebra involves; you might as well just teach them Dragonbox and hope they all grok it. The common approach of introducing algebraic thinking gradually via complex word problems has very much stood the test of time.
- derekp7 5y agoJust to add an anecdote about rote memorization -- not one teacher or textbook explained the "why" behind the area of a triangle being base times height divided by two. Just had to memorize that along with everything else. It wasn't until years later I saw something online that showed two right triangles stacked on top of each other forming a rectangle. And then further illustrations on how you could bisect triangles of other shapes to make two right triangles that you could double up to make rectangles. Then it was obvious why you had to take the formula for a rectangle's area and divide it by two for triangles. Similar visualizations are useful for other shapes too. But for some reason (unless I spaced out during that lesson) this was never brought up in any high school or college math class.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Let’s say you flip the recommendation to “smarten up” math education K-12. Teach Algebra gradually over K-6, do Geometry 7-8. Trig in 9, Calc 1 & 2 in 10-11, and Real Analysis in 12. That's a straw-man, no one wants to make math education that aggressive. > What do you think the outcome will be in aggregate? I’ll bet my hat it does nothing to produce better outcomes while furthering the race-influenced class divide. If you dumb down math education, you will probably just end up "furthering the race-influenced class divide": http://www.csun.edu/~vcmth00m/AHistory.html http://www.csun.edu/~vcmth00m/AHistory.html: > Modeled on Summerhill, and supported by the challenges at that time of structures of authority, both within education and the larger society, "free schools" proliferated, and eventually helped give rise to the Open Education Movement. The Open Education Movement was nothing new; it was just a repetition of progressivist programs promoted in the 1920s, but the idea of letting children decide each day what they should learn at activity tables, play corners, or reading centers, was once again promoted as profound and revolutionary.41 > The effects of the Open Education Movement were particularly devastating to children with limited resources, due to their lack of access to supplemental education from the home, or tutoring in basic skills outside of school. Lisa Delpit, an African American educator who taught in an inner city school in Philadelphia in the early 1970s wrote about the negative effects of this type of education on African American children. Relating a conversation with another African American teacher, she explained, "White kids learn how to write a decent sentence. Even if they don't teach them in school, their parents make sure they get what they need. But what about our kids? They don't get it at home..." Summarizing the effects of the open classroom movement from her perspective in 1986, Professor Delpit wrote: >> I have come to believe that the "open classroom movement," despite its progressive intentions, faded in large part because it was not able to come to terms with the concerns of poor and minority communities.42 > Another prominent educator, Nancy Ichinaga, came to similar conclusions about the effects of the Open Education Movement on low income students, based on her experience as principal of Bennett-Kew Elementary school, in Inglewood, California. Ichinaga began a 24 year career as principal of Bennett-Kew in the Fall of 1974, one month before scores from the California's standardized test were released. At that time the school included only grades K-3 and it was called Bennett Elementary school. Bennett's 1974 third grade students ranked at the third percentile in the state, almost the absolute bottom. The school was then in its fourth year of the "Open Structure Program" and the student body throughout her tenure as principal was nearly 100 percent minority and low income. Reacting with shock and dismay at the test scores, Ichinaga confronted the teachers who admitted that their program was not working. The entire student body was illiterate and the student centered mathematics program was in shambles. > With the collaboration of her teachers, Nancy Ichinaga introduced clearly defined and well structured reading and math programs which included practice in basic skills. After a few years, test scores increased to well beyond the 50th percentile, and by the end of the 20th century, her school had earned national acclaim and became a model for others to emulate.43 At an education conference held in May 1999, Principal Ichinaga described the situation in her school in 1974:
- coastermug 5y agoI don’t love the idea of ‘dumbing down’ maths, but I think there’s a needless race slant that gets added here (not by yourself, almost by US society). Im from the Uk, went a state school, with a Masters in Engineering, and a father who was an Engineer. My perspective is that the curriculum that I grew up with failed to properly teach me maths. Further, as much as I don’t personally like some of the policies implemented in the US education system (positive discrimination), I find myself agreeing with some of the policy/curriculum changes suggested. The largest difference between myself at university and my peers who went to paid or selective schools was that they knew how to learn. This was the hardest but most valuable lesson I learned from my prof in my first year. I remember trying my hardest, and in hindsight trying to learn in the most ineffective ways- copying out of textbooks. Seems stupid ? But that’s essentially how I was taught maths at school from 2000 to 2010 at school. I can see 100% how upbringing currently has an outsized impact on maths attainment, far beyond other subjects. - and the impacts on social justice.