9 ms·
Stanford prof calls cops on Berkeley prof who exposed her $5K/hr consulting fee
- musicale 5y agoAlso discussed previously at: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30952821 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30952821
- musicale 5y ago> Stanford prof calls cops on Berkeley prof who exposed her $5K/hr consulting fee I'm sorry Professor, but you need to call the Twitter police, not the Berkeley police.
- dfdz 5y agoHere is a much better summary of what happened from Boaz Barak: https://mobile.twitter.com/boazbaraktcs/status/1511366075035922439 https://mobile.twitter.com/boazbaraktcs/status/1511366075035...
- StopDarkPattern 5y ago
- cko 5y agoAside from how obnoxious it is to have gotten law enforcement involved just because she got called out, anyone else bothered by the continuous reminders in the article of who is black and who is white? I moved abroad two years ago but is this how the US is nowadays?
- inglor_cz 5y agoThe assumption that any interpersonal conflict between two people of different race must be racist in its core is horrible. There is zero chance to improve racial relations with such paranoia reigning supreme. Instead, the population will split into nervous, hunkering subgroups. That said, the 5000 USD hourly fee reminds me of the old maxim that "the best disinfectant is sunlight". She obviously does not like the fact that this price tag for her services is now widely known. This is how you fight corruption and similar vices. Transparency.
- goldenkey 5y agoSure it's not great but you have to understand that police in the US like to shoot people. Though they generally are happy to shoot anyone, there is a higher incidence of incidents with black colored folks, so they are necessarily more afraid of cops. I am white but was almost killed by the LAPD in 2011 so anecdotally I can tell you, the evil cops don't really focus on color - it's more about power.
- inglor_cz 5y agoBeing afraid of SWATting is absolutely realistic, yes.
- fleshdaddy 5y agoIn principle I kind of see what you’re saying but I mean if the cops chose to talk to him I’m sure they’d have the context of “this is a Stanford professor calling the cops on a Berkeley professor about a tweet.” And like you said it is more about power and at least from my perspective elite university professor falls under that. I could definitely be overestimating that though. My point is given the situation the chances of something like that happening is probably quite a bit lower than with any interaction with the police regardless of race.
- esyir 5y agoWhatever your thoughts on sj itself, I've basically never seen a "social justice consultant" who wasn't a grifter.
- stingraycharles 5y agoIt seems like it’s very much being framed as a racial issue, yes, likely because the Berkeley professor asserted that calling the cops on a black man is a dangerous thing to do. It seems that without the racial aspect, there wouldn’t be much of a story left, apart from a “Karen” story comparable with what one would find on Reddit.
- bena 5y agoIt's the NYPost. They're going to stir the pot anyway they can.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Irongirl1 5y ago@cko yes. this is the US nowadays. but tbh, its always been this way imho.
- yumraj 5y agoI think a bigger story should be as to why a public school district decided to pay someone $5000/hr for consulting. Wonder if there were kickbacks involved, or just incompetence.
- Sape2012 5y agoIt was slightly over $400/hr. The claim it was $5k/hr comes from the Berkeley guy who didn't include all the time she spent in his calculation. He either misunderstood or intentionally lied to make her look bad.
- jacques-noris 5y agoNo, the document states, that she gets 5000$/hr: “for two Four hour sessions at the rate of 5.000.00 per hour for q a total of 40.000$“
- throw242 5y agoThe “four hour sessions” are a deliverable. There is no mention of how many hours went into preparing for them. I was once paid 3,500 for a single 15 minute talk. It took me about 5 days to read various technical materials and condense them into an executive summary that could be delivered in 15 minutes. There were about 100 people in the audience. They got excellent value for money and I got paid reasonably for my research.
- op00to 5y agoYes, it’s $5,000 per hour, but that hour reflects a significant amount of time and work behind the scenes.
- caboteria 5y agoLooks like Professor Boaler just created an HN account.
- yumraj 5y agoHow do you know she spent any time at all? Do you happen to have first hand knowledge? The Berkeley guy volunteers for free, just for the record.
- Sape2012 5y agoI found this story absurd enough ($5k/hr?!) that I looked into it more and think the full story should be told: - Her hourly rate is closer to $400/hr. The Berkeley guy said it was $5k/hr because he just took the total pay and divided by hours spent on one thing. But she spent hours on some other things too that he didn't included in the denominator. - He originally tweeted her address and other harassing things, which is against Twitter's rules. That tweet was reported and taken down. - Stanford has threat prevention staff that alerted her to his tweets and also alerted the authorities, as is apparently their policy when people are tweeting harassing stuff about their faculty. She never personally reported him to the police. I wouldn't fault her if she did though. - It's clearly not racially motivated. - Despite all that, she tweeted an apology to appease the mob. - Finally, I don't like either of them. He is a harassing doofus who is trying to make her seem racist. She is trying to dumb down math for California students in the name of equity. He's worse but I don't really like her either.
- berberous 5y agoRegarding her hourly rate, here is the public document, which clearly states she is charging $5k per hour: https://twitter.com/cheesemonkeysf/status/1508923491180896263?s=21&t=a9QVtU412GyyywUUMKpDmw https://twitter.com/cheesemonkeysf/status/150892349118089626... Now perhaps that is a misleadingly drafted document, or the full agreement provided a variety of free services as well, but on its face, it seems reasonable to assume she is charging $5k per hour since that is how she is phrasing it in contracts she is signing.
- caboteria 5y agoNot sure where you're getting $400/hour since you didn't provide any evidence but the contact is quite clear that the rate is $5000/hour: > Provide four (4) two-hour sessions at the rate of $5,000.00 per hour for a total of $40,000 https://twitter.com/minilek/status/1509678967472549889 https://twitter.com/minilek/status/1509678967472549889
- anotaiw2 5y agoI saw the $400/hr in some article that I can't find now but this one from the SF Chronicle explains how the total work involved is more than just four two-hour sessions: https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/California-math-wars-get-ugly-Accusations-of-17060072.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/California-math-... "The Oxnard district training or others like it don’t include only the time in front of teachers or at the district, but also about 18 hours of preparation, Boaler said, which isn’t specified in the contract. The deal also means significant travel time." It's not uncommon for consulting to work that way where you pay $X for a report and a couple hours of presentation but theres a bunch of behind the scenes work you're implicitly paying for too. So her effective rate was probably a little over $1k/hr. Doesn't seem that unreasonable for a Stanford prof.
- davidg109 5y agoBoth sides are behaving like children and it’s hard to believe they represent prestigious schools. I don’t believe she targeted him because he happens to be black. She likely would have threatened the police irrespective of colour.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Nelson and Boaler’s very public beef is rooted in a controversial debate over how to teach math to California’s K-12 students. > Boaler is behind the ongoing effort to change the math curriculum framework in California that includes, in part, increasing equity, pushing algebra 1 back to 9th grade and applying social justice principles to lessons. Every time I hear anything about math education in the US, I leave convinced that "professors of education" should have nothing to do with it. And this opinion doesn't have anything to do with contemporary politics, since as far as I can tell, they've had a malign influence for at least a century (e.g. math education in the US was dumbed down by the "education experts" in first half of the 20th century, until the requirements of the space race and cold war forced a turnaround in the 60s).
- Qw3r7 5y agoCouldn't agree more. Its all lunacy.
- Spivak 5y agoLet’s say you flip the recommendation to “smarten up” math education K-12. Teach Algebra gradually over K-6, do Geometry 7-8. Trig in 9, Calc 1 & 2 in 10-11, and Real Analysis in 12. What do you think the outcome will be in aggregate? I’ll bet my hat it does nothing to produce better outcomes while furthering the race-influenced class divide. We literally have 4 living generations of people who’s only lasting association with math is “that thing that was needlessly hard and useless.” It’s the education equivalent of peacocking. It says nothing about you other than your family circumstances afforded you ample time to waste. Nobody remembers a damn thing about Trig, Geometry, Formal Proofs, or Calc unless they went on to a STEM field where they kept the knowledge fresh and even then they were still retaught it all in college anyway. But let me tell you everyone remembers the stress. I say this as someone who has two degrees in math and tutored half my damn class just to get them through trig and calc. High school math is garbage and pointless. “Oh but it teaches you how to think analytically.” The hell it does, the nuggets of creative problem solving are buried in mountains of rote memorization and bullshit trivia. If you want to raise the tide for all ships I would just do two years of algebra so people actually understand it completely instead of rushing them to the next thing only to flail for 4 years barely keeping their heads above water and then just stop. Then let people who are genuinely passionate about maths (or need it because they want to do calc based physics which would also be optional) opt in to that track, and crucially, don’t reward it in any way except as “nerd extracurricular” so people aren’t pressured into it.
- rahimnathwani 5y agoJo Boaler (i) is the author of the new California Math Framework, and (ii) sells PD consulting to districts. Many people (including me) are furious about the CMF, because it's based on inaccurate and/or misleading research and citations, makes little sense, and will harm students (and disproportionately harm students whose parents can't afford tutoring or private school). Hundreds of math and engineering experts have signed petitions against it. I've heard that there are laws against being both the author of state standards, and selling consulting about those standards. I don't know the specifics of these. Someone posted a Tweet including (i) an agreement between Jo Boaler and a school district, for PD presentation at $5k per hour, and (ii) a school board resolution agreeing an amendment to the total on that contract (doubling the contract value, whilst keeping the # hours unchanged). Their objections were (i) that's illegal due to #3, and (ii) the amount of money could fund almost a whole year's teacher salary, and that would be more valuable. A Berkeley professor retweeted the Tweet. The Tweet he retweeted contained public records only (the agreement, and the school board resolution) and did NOT contain any personal details about Jo Boaler except for her name. That professor had previously tried to engage with Jo Boaler about the framework, including by asking questions during a Zoom presentation. She ignored him. Jo Boaler sent a threatening letter to the professor (i) implying that she had contacted the police about him retweeting the content, (ii) accusing him of disseminating private info and misinformation, and (iii) saying he could have just reached out to her. He posted the letter on Twitter. She went on a PR offensive making it seem like she's a victim, when she was the (only) one who made a threat.
- rahimnathwani 5y agoIf anyone wants to delve deeper into the math framework itself, to form their own opinion, I'd recommend reading at least: 1. California Math Framework ch1: https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/ma/cf/documents/mathfwchapter1.docx https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/ma/cf/documents/mathfwchapter1.doc... 2. California Math Framework ch2: https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/ma/cf/documents/mathfwchapter2.docx https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/ma/cf/documents/mathfwchapter2.doc... 3. A Pathway to Equitable Math Instruction stride 1: https://equitablemath.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2020/11/1_STRIDE1.pdf https://equitablemath.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2020/11... 4. One of Boaler's papers that claims that detracking improves achievement, even for the top performers. See if you are convinced the conclusions follow from the experimental data. [pasting a message I wrote a long time ago - i haven't checked the links are still valid]
- CodeWriter23 5y ago> One of Boaler's papers that claims that detracking improves achievement, even for the top performers. If you can’t count it, you can’t analyze it.
- rhexs 5y agoThank you for this -- "A Pathway to Equitable Math Instruction stride 1" introduced me to the incredibly important concept of "ethnomathematics", which cited "Living Mathematx" (https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED581384.pdf https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED581384.pdf). The paper starts out quite strong and grabs the reader's attention with this: "Everyday, we accumulate more evidence that humans are destroying the planet". It then goes on to cite something called "Nahua metaphysics", which is I'd agree is crucially important in the teaching of mathematics to children. Glance through this, it is less readable than "Toward a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity". Absolutely terrifying that someone like this is at a prestigious university working on "education research".
- AvocadoPanic 5y agoYou should read more education research, it's not uncommon.
- 5y ago
- rahimnathwani 5y agoMy objections to Jo Boaler's recommendations are mainly related to the content covered in chapters 6 and 7 of her book (Mathematical Mindsets). Not all of it is wrong. But some of the things she's written in that book, and in the intro the California Math Framework 2021 is wrong-headed: 1. She claims that studies show that detracking improves student outcomes for all students, including the strongest. The cited studies mix a number of interventions, so it's impossible to draw the conclusion that detracking caused the increase in performance. 2. She attacks a straw man when she talks about the 'elitist construction of math'. I don't believe her characterisation that many/most people believe that math ability is genetic. 3. The talk of open-ended 'Low floor, high ceiling' tasks sounds nice in principle. But I challenge you to come up with a task that would work for people spanning 5 grade levels's of math ability (like the 6th graders at several schools in the Bay Area), and that a median California math teacher could supervise effectively. 4. No, there's no rule that says, if you group kids by ability, you can't provide differentiated instruction within each classroom. 5. If high school math achievement is used as a gatekeeper for college admissions, and this reinforces inequity, the answer cannot be to hold some students back. Rather, we should improve early math education so that people can all progress. Even if it's true that folks who study calculus in high school end up studying it again in college, this doesn't indicate they didn't benefit from that high school exposure. 6. The five strides of Equitable Math (https://equitablemath.org/ https://equitablemath.org/) (recommended in the California Math Framework 2021, Chapter 2), is NOT a good guide to improving math teaching. Its characterisation that every problem with math education is the cause of 'White Supremacy culture' is plainly wrong. Many of those problems exist in places like China, and it's hard to claim that's also a result of white supremacy. I highly recommend reading Stride 1 on that web site. 7. She pushed some changes at San Francisco Unified School District, the main one of which was moving Algebra I from 8th grade to 9th grade. She and the district claimed great success, and published some misleading stats. I won't go into the reasons why those stats are misleading here. But just look at what happened to those students when it came time to take the SAT. The first cohort of students who did algebra in 9th grade had a 10% lower pass rate on the Math SAT than did the previous cohort (61%, down from 66%). This is on the public record: you can request the aggregate data from CA Dept Ed (it used to be online, but they took down the page, as they don't care about SAT results now that UC doesn't look at them).
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 5y agoThis isn't going to go away anytime soon if white folks, in govt or corporate America, are eager to shell out 5k/hr for professionally-moral white folks to tell them how to be more virtuous themselves. Seems entirely analogous to the Robin DiAngelo income stream playbook. It's a booming market, it would be surprising if more people didn't choose to pursue the social justice pulpit for a living with that sort of comp rates.
- lr1970 5y ago$5K/hour to a useless "education professor" smells like a blatant misappropriation of the school funds. No wonder, this school district is short of money to pay actual teachers. This whole episode calls for a thorough audit and serious consequences to those responsible for squandering the money.
- hiharryhere 5y agoThe headline is immediately debunked in the first paragraph. “… after she allegedly threatened to call the cops”
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]