4 ms·
A sphere may be the best shape for enclosing the most amount of space using the least amount of material, but that's no good if most of that space isn't useful.
by kibwen 5y ago
A sphere may be the best shape for enclosing the most amount of space using the least amount of material, but that's no good if most of that space isn't useful. The fact that the upper reaches of a dome are almost all wasted space make them impractical for contexts like this, especially since breathable atmosphere will be at a premium (and imagine having to heat all of it; average Mars surface temperature is approximately the same as deepest Antarctica). Habitats on Mars will be more like submarines (subarenes?): long and narrow cylinders. I also don't think that any sort of sci-fi self-healing material will help here, because the pressure difference between inside and outside will explode your habitat before any self-healing mechanism kicks in (average surface pressure is the same as 45 km above Earth's surface). Exactly as this article suggests, you're better off sticking your subarene in a cave to protect it from storms and meteorites.
- XorNot 5y agoTechnically though that atmosphere isn't "wasted" its your reserve. Having a big volume of gas has a lot of advantages because it buffers up local emissions and releases - compare low ceiling vs high ceiling in buildings.
- kibwen 5y agoI just edited in a bit about heating costs, which is relevant here; compare the heating costs of low ceilings vs high ceilings in buildings.
- BlueTemplar 5y agoLow pressure means low heat transfer though - what is the typical temperature of Marsian underground ? (As for air - we just need enough barsooms of oxygen !)
- XorNot 5y agoRight, but even there you still have the square-cubed law working for you - the larger volume you deal with, the less surface area you lose heat through.
- trgn 5y agoI'm sure it wasn't your intention, but this comment describes perfectly why I find there's nothing appealing about colonizing Mars. Ah yes, that glorious future of humanity, let's go live underground in a tube. Not that I don't understand the intellectual appeal of space faring (smart people doing smart stuff with technology), but I find the picture of humans in space such an impoverished vision of the future.
- Teever 5y agoWhat do you consider to be an appealing vision of space travel/habitation? Like if space travel was an electric car and you were an ICE car kind of guy, what would space travel have to be like for you to be like "Okay, that's pretty cool."
- pengaru 5y agoAs long as you can convince the ICE car kind of guy he's in the upper caste that gets to stay earthbound while the poor are sent to Mars, it's probably not too difficult.
- trgn 5y agoWhy would the poor be sent to Mars? Its my impression the discourse is the other way around; the adventurous, people with options, would mindfully choose to leave earth and start anew.
- trgn 5y agoGravity similar to earth, breathable air. So my body still works fine on this new planet. Mediterranean climate would be great, but that's negotiable. I like your analogy with ice cars and electric cars. It perfectly captures the value system that drives space colonizatuon. It's the fetishization of technology. Because it requires advanced technology, therefore, in and of itself, space travel is the right thing to pursue. It's a modernist mindset.
- travisporter 5y agoBuilding a Marsbase is a Horrible Idea: Let's do it! - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqKGREZs6-w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqKGREZs6-w
- ceejayoz 5y ago> The fact that the upper reaches of a dome are almost all wasted space... Not psychologically, it's not. You might say the same about much of the inside volume of a cathedral; useless space! And yet, we make sure they all have it, because we value it. > because the pressure difference between inside and outside will explode your habitat before any self-healing mechanism kicks No, it won't. It's (at most) one atmosphere worth of pressure. ~14 psi. A small hole in a tire doesn't immediately burst it, and it's under significantly more pressure.
- asmithmd1 5y agoThe Apollo command module environment was 5 psi pure oxygen. This gave the astronauts lungs the same partial pressure of oxygen that earth atmosphere provides. So not even 14 psi difference, but 5 psi. A difference that can be dealt with during a repair. A commercial aircraft cabin while flying at 40,000 ft has about 8 psi of pressure differential
- NoSorryCannot 5y agoThe difference of 1atm between sea level and the void doesn't tend to yield violent explosions and has been survived. It's not remotely going to resemble a diving bell accident or something. A small puncture and large volume will give time to respond before disaster.
- nynx 5y agoThe difference between 1bar and vacuum (effectively mars pressure) frankly isn’t that much. Inflatable habitats are completely within reason.
- bbojan 5y agoThere is a problem with hemispherical habitats that is often overlooked. There are two forces at play - air pressure acts up trying to lift the skin of the habitat of the ground. This must be opposed by anchoring the habitat to the ground, the force of which acts downward. The problem is that the first force scales with the surface area enclosed (or even volume - I'm not sure as I can't find the reference at the moment), while the second one scales with the circumference. So r^2 versus r. This gives a fundamental limit on how big hemispherical habitats can be.
- wiredfool 5y agoScales with area, and if it’s small enough that there’s nopressure gradients, it’s just deltaPA. (Or effectively, pa because it’s basicaally a vacuum out there) The tensile strength of the membrane will also be interesting for larger habitats.